United States Federal Circuit

The district court's order granting summary judgment that certain of plaintiffs' products do not infringe asserted claims of defendant's patents, and denying defendant's motion to dismiss plaintiffs' declaratory judgment actions, are: 1) affirmed in part and reversed in part as to the denial of defendant’s motion to dismiss, where the district court had jurisdiction over both plaintiffs Microsoft's and SAP's declaratory judgment challenges to the '502 patent and over SAP's challenge to the ’402 patent, but not over Microsoft's challenge to '402 patent; 2) affirmed as to the grant of summary judgment to Mircosoft with regard to the '502 patent; and 3) and affirmed in part and reversed in part as to the grant of summary judgment to SAP.

Appellate Information

• Decided 04/04/2014
• Published 04/04/2014

Judges

• MOORE

Court

• United States Federal Circuit

Counsel