United States Federal Circuit

The decision of defendant International Trade Commission (ITC) that the asserted claims of plaintiff's '607 patent related to smartphone touchscreens are invalid and that intervenor Motorola does not infringe the asserted claims of plaintiff's '828 patent is: 1) affirmed in part, where substantial evidence supports the ITC's finding that Perski '455 anticipates claims 1–7 of the '607 patent, and substantial evidence supports the ITC's finding of no anticipation with regard to SmartSkin; 2) reversed in part and remanded, where the ITC’s decision that Perski '455 anticipates claim 10 of the '607 patent lacks substantial evidence; and 3) vacated in part and remanded, as to the ITC's obviousness finding and the ITC's decision that Motorola does not infringe the '828 patent claims.

Appellate Information

• Decided 08/07/2013
• Published 08/07/2013

Judges

• MOORE

Court

• United States Federal Circuit

Counsel