United States Ninth Circuit
Multistar Industries, Inc. v. US Department of Transportation, 12-73138
Petitions for review challenging a compliance review of a for-hire motor carrier conducted by defendant, are dismissed in part and denied in part, where: 1) on petitioners' substantive challenge, there was no final decision by the agency as to certain violations, and so the petition for review as to the merits of violations 5 and 11 are dismissed; and 2) procedurally, petitioner received all of the process it was due with regard to the contested violations, and the defendant's denial of petitioner's petition for review was not arbitrary or capricious.
Appellate Information
- Decided 02/07/2013
- Published 02/07/2013
Judges
- BERZON
Court
- United States Ninth Circuit