United States Ninth Circuit

Transportation Control Measure 2, adopted as part of a plan to attain federal air quality standards in the Bay Area, does not impose an enforceable obligation on defendant to increase public transit ridership. Summary judgment for plaintiff and injunction are reversed.

Appellate Information

• Argued 10/08/2003
• Decided 04/06/2004
• Published 04/06/2004

Judges

• CLIFTON, Circuit Judge:, Before:  HAWKINS, THOMAS, and CLIFTON, Circuit Judges.

Court

• United States Ninth Circuit

Counsel

• For Appellees:
  
• David D. Cooke, San Francisco, CA (argued);  Francis Chin, Oakland, CA;  and Melanie Morgan, Oakland, CA, for the defendant-appellant., Deborah S. Reames, Oakland, CA (argued);  Anne C. Harper, Oakland, CA;  Suma Peesapati, Oakland, CA;  Alan M. Ramo, San Francisco, CA;  Helen H. Kang, San Francisco, CA;  and Marc S. Chytilo, Santa Barbara, CA, for the plaintiffs-appellees.