Court of Appeals of New York
People v. Extale, 35
In a prosecution for first degree assault and first degree vehicular assault in which the prosecutor, over defense counsel objection, withdrew the count charging first degree vehicular assault, the defendant's conviction of second degree assault is reversed and a new trial ordered, because: 1) only the trial judge, and not the prosecutor, has the authority to withdraw a count of an indictment; and 2) the defendant might have benefited if the jury had chosen to convict him on the withdrawn count rather than on the count on which it did convict.
Appellate Information
- Decided 03/27/2012
- Published 03/27/2012
Judges
- Smith
Court
- Court of Appeals of New York
Counsel
- For Appellant:
- Jon P. Getz, Geoffrey Kaeuper