Supreme Court of California
People v. Beltran, S192644
The Court of Appeals decision holding that the voluntary manslaughter instruction was prejudicially erroneous and reversing defendant's murder conviction is reversed, where: 1) the proper standard when examining heat of passion in the context of manslaughter focuses upon whether the person of average disposition would be induced to react from passion and not from judgment; 2) the instruction on heat of passion given by the trial court was not ambiguous; 3) although the formulations of the principle by the attorneys in closing arguments may have confused the jury, defendant was not prejudiced thereby, where the trial court provided a correct statement of law in response to the jury's request for clarification; and 4) there is no reasonable probability the error of which the defendant complains affected the result, where evidence of provocation was both weak and contradicted.
Appellate Information
- Decided 06/03/2013
- Published 06/03/2013
Judges
- CORRIGAN
Court
- Supreme Court of California