PAC. GAS AND ELEC. v. CITY OF OAKLAND, A095373
Summary adjudication and damage award for excessive taxes paid, in favor of plaintiff who challenged the constitutionality of City's business tax, affirmed.
- Decided 10/31/2002
- Published 10/31/2002
- California Court of Appeal
- For Appellant:
- Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton, Otis McGee, Jr., Robert J. Stumpf, Jr., San Francisco, Raymond Ramsey, John A. Russo, Barbara J. Parker, Oakland, Bruce W. Plebuch, Office of the Oakland City Attorney, for Appellant.
- For Appellees:
- Mark H. Penskar, San Francisco, Elizabeth A. Collier, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, for Respondent.