IN RE: Forest COTTEN

Reset A A Font size: Print

Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Third Department, New York.

IN RE: Forest COTTEN, Respondent, v. GREENE COUNTY BOARD OF ELECTIONS et al., Respondents, Peter J. Markou et al., Appellants.

Decided: August 21, 2009

Before:  CARDONA, P.J., KAVANAGH, STEIN, McCARTHY and GARRY, JJ. Thomas J. Spargo, East Berne, for Peter J. Markou and others, appellants. Kathleen O'Keefe, Earlton, for Forest Cotten, respondent.

Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Platkin, J.), entered August 19, 2009 in Greene County, which granted petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, to declare invalid certificates of substitution naming respondent Linda H. Overbaugh as a Republican Party and Conservative Party candidate for the office of Greene County Legislator for the 1st Legislative District in the September 15, 2009 primary elections.

As discussed more fully in Matter of Ruck v. Greene County Bd. of Elections, 65 A.D.3d 808, 884 N.Y.S.2d 288 [2009] [decided herewith], the petitions designating Republican Party and Conservative Party candidates for the office of Greene County Legislator for the 1st Legislative District in the September 15, 2009 primary elections mistakenly named Linda L. Overbaugh (hereinafter Overbaugh) as a candidate instead of naming the person interested in running for that position, respondent Linda H. Overbaugh (hereinafter respondent).   In a proceeding challenging the validity of the designating petitions, Supreme Court, as relevant herein, invalidated the petitions with respect to Overbaugh without opposition.

Following Supreme Court's decision in that case, respondents Peter J. Markou and Frank J. Porto III, in their capacity as the Republican Party Committee to Fill Vacancies, and respondents Raymond Pacifico and Nicholas J. Passero, in their capacity as the Conservative Party Committee to Fill Vacancies, filed certificates of substitution with respondent Greene County Board of Elections designating respondent to fill the purported vacancies created by the invalidation.   Petitioner, a candidate for the office of Greene County Legislator for the 1st Legislative District for the September 15, 2009 primaries of the Democratic Party, Independence Party and Working Families Party, commenced this proceeding seeking, among other things, a declaration that the certificates of substitution are invalid.   Supreme Court granted the petition and respondent, Markou and Porto (hereinafter collectively referred to as respondents) now appeal, as limited by their brief, from that part of Supreme Court's order which invalidated the certificate of substitution seeking to fill the purported Republican Party vacancy.

Respondents urge this Court to rule that the exclusion of Overbaugh from the ballot in Matter of Ruck v. Greene County Bd. of Elections, supra resulted in a vacancy that could properly be filled with a certificate of substitution (see Election Law § 6-148[1] ).   However, Supreme Court explicitly invalidated the designating petitions with respect to Overbaugh in that case and no cross appeal was taken from that holding.   Due to that invalidation, no vacancy within the meaning of the Election Law has been created (see Matter of Elgin v. Smith, 10 A.D.3d 483, 484-485, 781 N.Y.S.2d 182 [2004];  Matter of Leemhuis v. State of New York, Bd. of Elections, 186 A.D.2d 863, 588 N.Y.S.2d 1022 [1992], affg. for reasons stated below 155 Misc.2d 531, 588 N.Y.S.2d 980 [1992];  Matter of Nowik v. Jablonski, 133 A.D.2d 874, 875, 520 N.Y.S.2d 427 [1987] ).   Accordingly, the certificate of substitution was, in turn, properly invalidated (see Matter of Harper v. New York State Bd. of Elections, 34 A.D.3d 919, 920, 823 N.Y.S.2d 297 [2006];  Matter of Nowik v. Jablonski, 133 A.D.2d at 875, 520 N.Y.S.2d 427).

ORDERED that the judgment is affirmed, without costs.

PER CURIAM.

CARDONA, P.J., KAVANAGH, STEIN, McCARTHY and GARRY, JJ., concur.

Copied to clipboard