III v. LLC

Reset A A Font size: Print

James E. Shields, Jr., Christine F. Shields, James E. Shields, III and Joseph Luke Shields v. Alvin R. Savoie & Associates, Inc. d/b/a Savoie Construction, Foster–Taylor Fireplaces, Inc., Lennox Hearth Products LLC, American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance Company, The Travelers Indemnity Company of Connecticut, and Ace American Insurance Company

Asi Lloyds as Subrogee of James and Kristin Shields v. Savoie Construction, Inc., Savoie Construction and Development, LLC, and Foster–Taylor Fireplaces, Inc.

NO. 2016 CA 0827

Decided: February 17, 2017

BEFORE:  HIGGINBOTHAM, THERIOT, AND CHUTZ, JJ. James E. Shields, Jr., James E. Shields, Sr., Gretna, LA, Attorneys for Plaintiffs–Appellants, James E. Shields, Jr., Christine F. Shields, James E. Shields, III, and Joseph Luke Shields George J. Richaud, Metairie, LA, Attorney for Defendant–Appellee, Alvin R. Savoie & Associates, Inc. d/b/a Savoie Construction Christopher R. Teske, Eric S. Charleston, New Orleans, LA, Attorneys for Defendant–Appellee, American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance Company Sean M. Casey, Mandeville, LA, Attorney for Defendants–Appellees, Foster–Taylor Fireplaces, Inc. and the Travelers Indemnity Company Connecticut

 In this consolidated matter involving issues surrounding payments made to homeowners for damages due to a residential home fire, the homeowners, James E. Shields, Jr. and Christine F. Shields, along with their two sons (the Shields), appeal the summary judgment dismissal of their builder's liability insurer, American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance Company (American Empire). This consolidated appeal is closely related to another consolidated appeal decided this date, which involves the same parties and same issues:  Shields v. Alvin R. Savoie & Associates, Inc., d/b/a Savoie Construction and American Empire Surplus Lines Insurance Company, 2016–0825 c/w 2016–0826 (La. App. 1st Cir. --/--/--), ––– So.3d ––––. In fact, the parties filed duplicate briefs raising the same assignments of error in all of the consolidated appeals. While the parties sought to consolidate all four appeals, this court denied that request on September 27, 2016. However, the four appeals were assigned for consideration by the same panel on the same docket.

In the related appeals, we outlined the facts and procedural history of this protracted litigation in detail before concluding that the trial court did not err in granting summary judgment in favor of the builder, Alvin R. Savoie & Associates, Inc., d/b/a Savoie Construction (Savoie Construction), and in dismissing all of the homeowners' claims against the builder. We also concluded in the related consolidated appeal that since Savoie Construction had a valid defense of statutory peremption under the Louisiana New Home Warranty Act (NHWA), then by extension and operation of law, that defense was available to Savoie Construction's liability insurer, American Empire. Because we have previously determined that the Shields' claims against Savoie Construction were perempted pursuant to the NHWA in the related appeals, it follows that the Shields no longer  have a viable claim against Savoie Construction's insurer, American Empire. Thus, the summary judgment dismissal of American Empire from this litigation was correct, albeit for different reasons than those expressed by the trial court.

Consequently, for the same reasons expressed in our opinion in the related appeals decided this day, we hereby affirm via summary opinion, in accordance with the Uniform Rules of Louisiana Courts of Appeal, Rule 2–16.2, the trial court's judgments granting summary judgment in favor of American Empire and dismissing all of the Shields' claims against American Empire. All costs of this consolidated appeal are assessed against the Shields.

AFFIRMED.

HIGGINBOTHAM, J.

Chutz, J., concur

Copied to clipboard