PERMENTER v. ECLINICAL WORKS LLC (2018)

United States District Court, M.D. Georgia, Macon Division.

PERMENTER et al v. ECLINICAL WORKS LLC

ABRIDGED CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 5:18-cv-00382-MTT

Decided: October 12, 2018

Plaintiff, ALEX PERMENTER, United States of America, ex rel, represented by BRANDON LEE PEAK, 945 BROADWAY, 200, COLUMBUS, GA 31901, 706-460-4800, Fax: 706-381-8004, Email: brandon@peakwooten.com, TERMINATED: 01/07/2022, LEAD ATTORNEY RAMSEY B PRATHER, 105 13TH ST, COLUMBUS, GA 31901, 706-322-1990, Email: ramsey@butlerprather.com, TERMINATED: 01/28/2022, LEAD ATTORNEY ROBERT H SNYDER, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE, STE 885, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-800-4828, Fax: 404-393-0365, Email: rob@cannellasnyder.com, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED RORY A WEEKS, 1960 SATELLITE BLVD STE 4000, DULUTH, GA 30097, 770-822-0900, Email: rweeks@atclawfirm.com, TERMINATED: 06/06/2025, LEAD ATTORNEY ALEXANDRA COLE, 315 PONCE DE LEON AVE STE 885, ATLANTA, GA 30030, 404-800-4828, Email: sachi@cannellasnyder.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ANNA GREEN CROSS, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE, STE 715, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-948-3022, Email: anna@crosskincaid.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED BRIAN P ADAMS, PO BOX 142, MACON, GA 31201, 478-238-0231, Fax: 478-216-9188, Email: brian@brianadamslaw.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED CHASE LYNDALE, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE STE 885, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-800-4828, Email: chase@cannellasnyder.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED DEVIN MASHMAN, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE, STE 885, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-852-8491, Email: devin@cannellasnyder.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED HANNAH DROSKY AMANUEL, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE STE 885, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-354-8990, Email: hannah@cannellasnyder.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MARY BETH HAND, 598 D T WALTON SR WAY, MACON, GA 31201, 478-238-0231, Email: mbhand@brianadamslaw.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MEREDITH C KINCAID, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE, STE 715, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-948-3022, Email: meredith@crosskincaid.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED WILLIAM DANIEL ORTIZ, 315 W PONCE DE LEON AVE, STE 885, DECATUR, GA 30030, 404-800-4828, Email: will@warlawgroup.com, TERMINATED: 06/07/2024 Plaintiff, ERIC RODIGHIERO, United States of America, ex rel, represented by BRANDON LEE PEAK, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 01/07/2022, LEAD ATTORNEY RAMSEY B PRATHER, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 01/28/2022, LEAD ATTORNEY ROBERT H SNYDER, (See above for address), LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED RORY A WEEKS, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 06/06/2025, LEAD ATTORNEY ALEXANDRA COLE, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ANNA GREEN CROSS, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED BRIAN P ADAMS, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED CHASE LYNDALE (See above for address) ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED DEVIN MASHMAN, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED HANNAH DROSKY AMANUEL, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MARY BETH HAND, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MEREDITH C KINCAID, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED WILLIAM DANIEL ORTIZ, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 06/07/2024 Plaintiff, CHRIS WHEELER, United States of America, ex rel, represented by BRANDON LEE PEAK, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 01/07/2022, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED RAMSEY B PRATHER, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 01/28/2022, LEAD ATTORNEY ROBERT H SNYDER, (See above for address), LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED RORY A WEEKS, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 06/06/2025, LEAD ATTORNEY ALEXANDRA COLE, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ANNA GREEN CROSS, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED BRIAN P ADAMS, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED CHASE LYNDALE, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED DEVIN MASHMAN, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED HANNAH DROSKY AMANUEL, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MARY BETH HAND, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MEREDITH C KINCAID, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED WILLIAM DANIEL ORTIZ, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 06/07/2024 Plaintiff UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Ex rel, represented by TODD P SWANSON, US ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, P. O. Box 1702, MACON, GA 31202-1702, 478-752-3511, Email: todd.swanson@usdoj.gov, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ANNA GREEN CROSS, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED BOWEN REICHERT SHOEMAKER, US ATTORNEY'S OFFICE, PO BOX 1702, MACON, GA 31202, 478-752-3511, Email: bowen.shoemaker@usdoj.gov, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED CHRISTELLE KLOVERS, US DEPT OF JUSTICE, PO BOX 261 BEN FRANKLIN STATION, WASHINGTON, DC 20044, 202-305-3656, Email: christelle.klovers@usdoj.gov, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED MEREDITH C KINCAID, (See above for address), ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED RAMSEY B PRATHER, (See above for address), TERMINATED: 01/28/2022 Defendant, ECLINICAL WORKS LLC, represented by DUKE R GROOVER, JAMES BATES, PO BOX 4283, MACON, GA 31208-4283, 478-742-4280, Email: dgroover@jamesbatesllp.com, LEAD ATTORNEY, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED AARON KATZ, 399 BOYLSTON ST, BOSTON, MA 02116, 617-915-6305, Email: akatz@aaronkatzlaw.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ALLISON MEGHAN BROWN, 601 LEXINGTON AVE, NEW YORK, NY 10022, 212-446-4757, Email: alli.brown@kirkland.com, PRO HAC VICE, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED, CHRISTOPHER D COX, 601 LEXINGTON AVE, NEW YORK, NY 10022, 212-446-4753, Email: christopher.cox@kirkland.com, PRO HAC VICE, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED CHRISTOPHER GORDON, 231 RIVERSIDE DR, MACON, GA 31201, 478-742-4280, Fax: 478-742-8720, Email: cgordon@jamesbatesllp.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED ELIZABETH TOLON MCINERNEY, 2099 PENNSYLVANIA AVE NW, WASHINGTON, DC 20006, 202-508-4828, Email: elizabeth.tolon@ropesgray.com, TERMINATED: 01/03/2024, PRO HAC VICE EMMA NOTIS-MCCONARTY, PRUDENTIAL TOWER, 800 BOYLSTON ST, BOSTON, MA 02199, 617-235-4139, Email: enm@dcglaw.com, TERMINATED: 01/03/2024 GEOFFREY M WYATT, 1301 PENNSYLVANIA AVE NW, WASHINGTON, DC 20004, 202-389-3393, Email: geoffrey.wyatt@kirkland.com, PRO HAC VICE, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED JAMES W COBB, 75 14TH ST NE, STE 2700, ATLANTA, GA 30309, 404-596-5601, Email: jcobb@caplancobb.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED JESSICA DAVIDSON, 601 LEXINGTON AVE, NEW YORK, NY 10022, 212-446-4723, Email: jessica.davidson@kirkland.com, PRO HAC VICE, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED JULIA B STONE, 75 14TH ST NE STE 2700, ATLANTA, GA 30309, 404-596-5600, Email: jstone@caplancobb.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED NINA R ROSE, 1301 PENNSYLVANIA AVE NW, WASHINGTON, DC 20004, 202-389-3394, Email: nina.rose@kirkland.com, PRO HAC VICE, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED RICHARD TODD BERNARDO, ONE MANHATTAN W, STE 42-128, NEW YORK, NY 10001, 212-735-3453, Fax: 917-777-3453, Email: richard.bernardo@skadden.com, ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED SUSAN ELIZABETH HALL, 231 RIVERSIDE DR, STE 100, MACON, GA 31201, 478-749-9923, Fax: 478-742-8720, Email: ehall@jamesbatesllp.com, TERMINATED: 01/13/2025

Cause: 31:3729 False Claims Act

Jury Demand: Defendant

Nature of Suit: 375 Other Statutes: False Claims Act

Jurisdiction: U.S. Government Plaintiff

Date Filed 06/25/2025 06/25/2025 06/25/2025 # 347 346 [Tabular or graphical material not displayable at this time.] 345 Docket Text ORDER re 345 Order (Restricted); and 346 Order (Redacted). The Court will allow the parties 14 days to address whether redactions are necessary. Absent sufficient cause, redactions shall be removed and a revised order will be filed on the public docket. The Court reminds the parties that Federal courts are public institutions and cannot retain the confidence of the people if they operate under a cloak of secrecy. Ordered by US DISTRICT JUDGE MARC T TREADWELL on 6/25/2025. (kat) (Entered: 06/25/2025) ORDER (Redacted) GRANTING in part and DENYING in part 215 Motion for Summary Judgment; and DENYING 297 Motion to Exclude Relators' Second Supplemental Response and Objections to Defendant eClinicalWorks' Amended First Interrogatories. Ordered by US DISTRICT JUDGE MARC T TREADWELL on 6/25/2025. (kat) (Entered: 06/25/2025) *** Restricted to Court users and Attorneys of record in the case *** ORDER GRANTING in part and DENYING in part 215 Motion for Summary Judgment; and DENYING 297 Motion to Exclude Relators' Second Supplemental Response and Objections to Defendant eClinicalWorks' Amended First Interrogatories. Ordered by US DISTRICT JUDGE MARC T TREADWELL on 6/25/2025. (kat) Modified on 6/25/2025 to add “restricted” language (kat). (Entered: 06/25/2025)

Assigned to: District Judge Marc T Treadwell

Was this helpful?

Why was this helpful?

Easy to understand

Solved my problem

Other

Why was this not helpful?

Missing the information I need

Too complicated / too many steps

Out of date

Other

Thank you for your feedback!

Welcome to FindLaw's Cases & Codes

A free source of state and federal court opinions, state laws, and the United States Code. For more information about the legal concepts addressed by these cases and statutes visit FindLaw's Learn About the Law.

Go To Learn About The Law