DOUGHERTY v. LAWHORNE 29 (2020)

United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit.

Robert W. DOUGHERTY, Plaintiff - Appellant, v. Dana LAWHORNE, Sheriff, Alexandria Adult Detention Center; Schuler, Chief Deputy (Major), Alexandria Adult Detention Center; Sergeant Hall, Alexandria Adult Detention Center; Sergeant Mensah, Alexandria Adult Detention Center (Law Library); Deputy Anderson, Alexandria Adult Detention Center (Mailroom); Ivan T. Gilmore, Warden, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Donald Gourdine, Inst. Program Dir. and Inst. Classification, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Major M. Bryant, Chief of Security and Institutional Review Officer (Discipline), Coffeewood Correctional Center; C. A. Ward, Chief of Security and Institutional Review Officer (Discipline), Coffeewood Correctional Center; Anita B. Long, (Captain) Unit Manager Coffeewood Correctional Center; Captain S. A. Jones, Watch Commander, Grievance Hearing Officer, and Institutional Review-Discipline; Lieutenant Brice, Unit Lieutenant (retired), Coffeewood Correctional Center; L. P. Jones, (Lieutenant) Unit Manager, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Lieutenant R. Gallagher, Unit Lieutenant, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Lieutenant M. S. Miller, Custody, Shift Supervisor, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Sergeant R. Lewis, Custody, Hearing Officer, Coffeewood Correctional Center; D. P. Sacra, Sergeant, Custody, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Sergeant Monroe, Custody, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Walter, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Jenkins, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Roches, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Hensley, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Powell, Former Mail Room Officer, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Newcomb, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal Hefright, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Corporal F. O. Alas-Barrientos, Coffeewood Correctional Center; T. L. Crickemberger, Hearing Officer (of record), Coffeewood Correctional Center; M.S. Kimberly Tucker, Grievance Officer, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Ms. P. C. Zwigart, Secretary to Warden Gilmore, Coffeewood Correctional Center; Ms. Peggy Tatro, Administrator, Mediko Correctional Healthcare (contracted provider), Coffeewood Correctional Center; Ms. S. Cooper, Treatment and Law Library, Coffeewood Correctional Center; A. David Robinson, Chief of Corrections Operations, Virginia Department of Corrections; Wendy S. Hobbs, Regional Administrator Grievances, Virginia Department of Corrections; Marcus M. Hodges, Regional Administrator, Virginia Department of Corrections; Karen L. Stapleton, Offender Discipline Manager, Virginia Department of Corrections; Karen D. Brown, Chairman, Virginia Parole Board; Helen W. Morton, Hearing Officer, Virginia Parole Board; Helen W. Hall-Green, Hearing Officer, Virginia Parole Board; Iris Stallworth, District 29-Fairfax, Virginia Parole Board; Miniar F. Stone, Parole Board Member, Virginia Parole Board; B. J. Hice, Hearing Officer, Virginia Parole Board; Sergeant D. P. Happe, Custody, Coffeewood Correctional Center, Defendants - Appellees.

No. 19-7835

Decided: April 16, 2020

Before WYNN and HARRIS, Circuit Judges, and TRAXLER, Senior Circuit Judge.

Robert W. Dougherty, Appellant Pro Se.