ALTON BROWN v. PA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS PRISON HEALTH SERVICES INC JEFFREY BEARD CALVIN JOHNSON CLIFFORD HARA WILLIAM STICKMAN JOHN SHAFFER DONALD VAUGHAN DIRECTOR JOHN DOE MARGARET GORDAN ROBERT BITNER SHARON BERKS HARRY WILSON MARK KRYSEVIG CAROL SCIRE LOUIS FOLINO DAN DAVIS DAVID DIGUGLIELMO JOHN MURRAY SCOTT WILLIAMSON MICHAEL LORENZO JOAN SCOTT WENDY MOYER DOC ARIAS JULIE KNAVER JANE DOE PRYZBYLOWSKI CHARLES SCOTT MYRON STANISHEFSKI JANE DOE PHY ASST RAY MACHAK CALEB NWOSU JOHN DOE DOC NURSE JOHN DOE NURSE JOHN DOE TRETINEK MICHAEL HERBIK MARY CANINO MARY ANN MISTRIK THREE UNKNOWN GUARDS DAY LEVI HOSBAND TONY WOLFE WORKMAN ROBERT FRANK MARY REESE NURSE GRESS DIANE MANSON KIRBY ODDO CLUDE HAUGHT SGT LIPSCOMB SGT MARSHALL BIAGINI KRONANDER COLE ROHRER SGT MICHNIAK LINDA MILLER WM ZINKEL WM STOWERS LING SHAN MICHAEL SPENCER DENNIS COTTON MARCIA NOLES WILLIAM BANTA SGT ZIMMERMAN SGT NAFUS LT WHITE TEN UNKNOWN RHU STAFF WALTER GRUNDER CROSS ERIC ARMEL LAUREL KARRY RELEVANT CORRECTIONAL STAFF UNION STEVE BENKO ROBERT STAFFORD LINDA HARRIS REDMAN JOAN MANN MELISSA VARNER HENDERSON PUSHCART LT MOZINGO JOHNSON RICHTER HALLEY REED SGT BARNES RUUD NOSE PETROSKY CAPT MOHRING MAMIS KNIZER JOHN ANDRADE SMITH SGT BURNETTE STEPHEN CUBBERLY MICHAEL MAHLMEISTER DEPUTY BENNING MAJOR HASSETT CONNER BLAINE JR SMITH ANTHONY PETRUCCIO JOHN PALAKOVICH KYLER WARD DEPUTY DICKSON DIRECTOR HARRISON SUPT JOHNSON GEARHART SGT BUSH MARTIN HORN HENRY JACKSON DAN DAVIES SUPERINTENDENT SCI GRA 1997 COLLINS TEN JOHN DOE AT SCI CUM BLOOR MYERS GONDAL SHULTZ DITTY MOSCHETTA MILLER BOWER SGT STEWART LT MAYLE JOHN DOE CONNER BLAINE JR ROSSI JACKSON ZABOROSKI ANSELL KERRI CROSS LT MCCOMBIE SNYDER SCHAFER ODDO LAW LIBRARIAN SGT JOHN DOE SGT JOHN DOE TEN UNKNOWN JOHN DOES SCIG GINCHEREAU JOE GERAGI LORI LAPINA DON SKUNDA RANINDRANATH KOLLI PAUL NOEL EDWARD SWIERCZEWSKI STEPHANIE DUMAS JOAN DELIE FRANK COLE NURSE KIME THOMAS MCCONNELL CLAIBRONE ANTHONY BONO GIDDENS ROBERT KEEFER LYNCH GARY ABRAMS JOSH ORPEN RANDY MINNICK MICHAEL FERSON KEITH SHAW SIMPSON SHANE MECHLING RONALD BLANDFORD MIKE ZAKIN CHRIS MYERS MIKE ADVARCHY WALKER LT KOSTINGO SGT CASSICY SAM POPOVICH CRUMB OFFICER LAWRENCE OFFICER NEWHOUSE SCOTT BRADLEY SGT CLARK (2010)

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.

ALTON D. BROWN, Petitioner v. PA. DEPT. OF CORRECTIONS;  PRISON HEALTH SERVICES, INC.;  JEFFREY A. BEARD;  CALVIN B. JOHNSON;  CLIFFORD O'HARA;  WILLIAM STICKMAN;  JOHN S. SHAFFER;  DONALD VAUGHAN;  DIRECTOR JOHN DOE;  MARGARET M. GORDAN;  ROBERT S. BITNER;  SHARON BERKS;  HARRY E. WILSON, MARK A. KRYSEVIG;  CAROL A. SCIRE;  LOUIS S. FOLINO;  DAN DAVIS;  DAVID DIGUGLIELMO;  JOHN K. MURRAY;  SCOTT WILLIAMSON;  MICHAEL A. LORENZO;  JOAN SCOTT;  WENDY MOYER;  DOC. ARIAS;  JULIE KNAVER;  JANE DOE;  C.O. PRYZBYLOWSKI;  CHARLES SCOTT;  MYRON STANISHEFSKI;  JANE DOE (PHY.ASST.);  RAY MACHAK;  CALEB NWOSU;  JOHN DOE (DOC 1);  NURSE JOHN DOE 1;  NURSE JOHN DOE 2;  R. TRETINEK;  MICHAEL HERBIK;  MARY CANINO;  MARY ANN MISTRIK;  THREE UNKNOWN GUARDS;  J. DAY;  LEVI HOSBAND;  TONY WOLFE;  R. WORKMAN;  ROBERT FRANK;  MARY S. REESE;  NURSE GRESS;  DIANE MANSON;  B.A. KIRBY;  P.A. ODDO;  CLUDE HAUGHT;  SGT. LIPSCOMB;  SGT. MARSHALL;  C.O. BIAGINI;  C.O. KRONANDER;  C.O. COLE;  C.O. ROHRER;  SGT. MICHNIAK;  LINDA MILLER;  WM. ZINKEL;  WM. STOWERS;  LING SHAN;  MICHAEL SPENCER;  DENNIS COTTON;  MARCIA S. NOLES;  WILLIAM BANTA;  SGT. ZIMMERMAN;  SGT. NAFUS;  LT. WHITE;  TEN UNKNOWN RHU STAFF;  WALTER GRUNDER;  K. CROSS;  ERIC T. ARMEL;  LAUREL R. KARRY;  RELEVANT CORRECTIONAL STAFF UNION;  STEVE BENKO;  ROBERT STAFFORD;  LINDA HARRIS;  C.O. REDMAN;  JOAN L. MANN;  MELISSA VARNER;  C.O. HENDERSON;  J. PUSHCART;  LT. MOZINGO;  E.P. JOHNSON;  C.O. RICHTER;  C.O. HALLEY;  C.O. REED;  SGT. BARNES;  C.O. RUUD;  S.L. NOSE;  C.O. PETROSKY;  CAPT. MOHRING;  C.O. MAMIS;  C.O. KNIZER;  JOHN ANDRADE;  C.O. SMITH;  SGT. BURNETTE;  STEPHEN T. CUBBERLY;  MICHAEL J. MAHLMEISTER;  DEPUTY BENNING;  MAJOR HASSETT;  CONNER BLAINE JR.;  F. SMITH;  ANTHONY L. PETRUCCIO;  JOHN A. PALAKOVICH;  K.D. KYLER;  U.M. WARD;  DEPUTY DICKSON;  DIRECTOR HARRISON;  SUPT. JOHNSON;  D.L. GEARHART;  SGT. BUSH;  MARTIN HORN;  HENRY JACKSON;  DAN DAVIES;  SUPERINTENDENT SCI-GRA.1997;  C.O. COLLINS;  TEN JOHN DOE'S AT SCI-C;  R. CUM;  C.O. BLOOR;  C.O. MYERS;  GONDAL;  C.O. SHULTZ;  DITTY;  S.E. MOSCHETTA;  S.W. MILLER;  C.O. BOWER;  SGT. STEWART;  LT. MAYLE;  JOHN DOE (C.O.1);  CONNER BLAINE JR.;  C. ROSSI;  T.D. JACKSON;  J. ZABOROSKI;  B.E. ANSELL;  KERRI CROSS;  LT. MCCOMBIE;  R. SNYDER;  W.C. SCHAFER;  P.A. ODDO;  LAW LIBRARIAN;  SGT. JOHN DOE # 1;  SGT. JOHN DOE # 2;  TEN UNKNOWN JOHN DOES;  SCIG;  E.H. GINCHEREAU;  JOE GERAGI;  LORI LAPINA;  DON SKUNDA;  RANINDRANATH KOLLI;  PAUL NOEL;  EDWARD SWIERCZEWSKI;  STEPHANIE DUMAS;  JOAN DELIE;  FRANK COLE;  NURSE KIME;  THOMAS MCCONNELL;  G. CLAIBRONE;  ANTHONY BONO;  G. GIDDENS;  ROBERT H. KEEFER;  A. LYNCH;  GARY ABRAMS;  JOSH ORPEN;  RANDY MINNICK;  MICHAEL FERSON;  KEITH SHAW;  C.J. SIMPSON;  C.M. SHANE;  N.K. MECHLING;  RONALD BLANDFORD;  MIKE ZAKIN;  CHRIS MYERS;  MIKE ADVARCHY;  P.WALKER;  LT. KOSTINGO;  SGT. CASSICY;  SAM POPOVICH;  A. CRUMB;  OFFICER LAWRENCE;  OFFICER NEWHOUSE;  SCOTT A. BRADLEY;  SGT. CLARK, Respondents

No. 69 WAL 2010

Decided: July 08, 2010