Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
The People of the State of New York, v. Heavin Dunlap.
On April 13, 2026, the People commenced this action by filing a complaint charging defendant with Assault in the Third Degree (Penal Law § 120.00(1)) and Harassment in the Second Degree (Penal Law § 240.26(1)). The People were required to be ready for trial within 90 days of the action's commencement—i.e., by July 17, 2026. See CPL 30.30(1)(b). The People filed a certificate of compliance ("COC") and statement of readiness on July 6, 2026, with supplemental COCs on July 16 and August 24, 2026. Defendant moves to dismiss the action on speedy-trial grounds, arguing that the People's COC was invalid and their statement of readiness was illusory. The court assumes the parties' familiarity with the facts and arguments raised in the motion. As explained below, the motion is GRANTED.
(1)
According to the allegations and submissions to the court, defendant and the complainant were students at the same high school and had an acrimonious history. On March 30, 2026, at about 11:09 a.m., in the school cafeteria, defendant allegedly threw a cup of hot coffee at the complainant's face, causing "substantial pain, a burning sensation, and swollen bumps" on complainant's face. Complainant notified New York City Police Department ("NYPD") School Safety agents who were on scene at the school. Emergency Medical Services ("EMS") personnel also arrived and treated the complainant; it is unclear who called EMS. School staff eventually allowed defendant to leave the school. Complainant's mother called 911, and NYPD police officers responded. Police documents reflect that an I-card was then generated for defendant's arrest. On April 12, 2026, defendant surrendered to a detective, and the complainant positively identified defendant through a single-photo identification procedure. Defendant was arraigned on the instant charges the next day.
According to the People, they requested discovery from the arresting officer's precinct and the assigned detective on May 26, 2026, with follow-up requests on May 28, June 10, and June 20, 2026. The record does not contain a copy of these requests, and the People do not detail in what form those requests were made or what was requested. The People received materials from the precinct's discovery liaison in response to the prosecution's request on June 22, 2026.1 The People filed their COC on July 6, indicating that they had not yet obtained the 911 recordings and associated records (which were requested on May 29 and expedited on July 2), or the body-worn camera ("BWC") footage and activity logs for the police officers who responded to the school. On July 7, 2026, a day after filing their COC, the People made contact with the detective about the missing activity logs and learned that detective investigative reports ("DD5s") also existed in this case, although the precinct's discovery liaison had previously stated that no DD5s existed.
On July 8, 2026, defense counsel sent the assigned prosecutor a list of discoverable materials that had allegedly been omitted. That list included the 911 materials, BWC footage, and activity logs that were flagged in the People's COC; it also included EMS records, the I-card issued for defendant's arrest, any materials from the NYPD School Safety Division, as well as impeachment materials and certain items of police paperwork. On July 10, the assigned prosecutor responded. He stated that, together with his conferral response, he was disclosing the 911 materials and the newly-discovered DD5s, which the People had just obtained, and that the People were continuing to look for the BWC footage and the activity logs. (The People filed a supplemental COC documenting these belated disclosures on July 16, 2026.) In his July 10 response, the prosecutor added that he had already been informed that no EMS records, NYPD School Safety records, or I-card existed in this case, but that he would inquire again to confirm whether that was correct.
According to the People, the assigned prosecutor then made follow-up requests to the arresting officer and their precinct discovery liaison on July 14, July 15, July 16, and July 29, 2026, but received no response. The record does not contain a copy of those requests. On August 6, 2026, in response to another follow-up request, the People received the outstanding activity logs. On August 16, 2026, they "specifically requested that the BWC footage" and received those materials the next day, with an explanation that the footage had been "tagged" to the wrong arrest number. Finally, in response to an August 21 inquiry, the arresting officer stated that the requested EMS records and NYPD School Safety materials did not exist. The record is not clear when the BWC footage and activity logs were disclosed; defendant says this happened on August 17. The record is clear, however, that the People filed a supplemental COC documenting the belated disclosure on August 21, 2026.
(2)
To declare ready, the People must first certify that, "after exercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries and efforts to ascertain the existence of, obtain, and disclose material and information subject to discovery, the prosecution has disclosed and made available all known material and information it has obtained subject to discovery." CPL 245.50(1). The "key question" in determining if the People have exercised due diligence is whether they made "reasonable efforts to comply with statutory directives." People v. Bay, 41 NY3d 200, 211 (2023) (cleaned up); see CPL 245.50(6). This is a "fundamentally case-specific" inquiry that turns on a variety of factors, including a list of factors set out in the discovery statute. Bay, 41 NY3d at 212; see CPL 245.50(5)(a). Where the defense challenges the validity of a COC, the People bear the "burden of establishing that they did, in fact, exercise due diligence and made reasonable inquiries prior to filing the initial COC." Bay, 41 NY3d at 213. Where the People fail to carry this burden, the court must strike their COC as invalid and must deem their accompanying statement of readiness illusory. See id.
Having considered the statutory factors—including the People's discovery-compliance efforts, the complexity of the case, the volume of discovery provided and outstanding, the People's awareness of omitted materials and their explanations for the omissions, the People's responses to conferrals, the People's corrective actions, and whether the delayed disclosures were material or prejudicial—the court concludes that the People did not validly certify their diligence under the circumstances, and that the motion to strike their COC as invalid and annul the statement of readiness must be granted.
In reaching that conclusion, the court has not overlooked the efforts taken by the People to attempt to comply with their discovery obligations. The volume of discovery requests alone—five pre-COC requests and six post-COC requests—suggests a certain level of diligence. In another case, such a record might well be sufficient to support a COC. But for a number of reasons which reflect the specific facts of this case, the court cannot conclude that the People exercised due diligence here.
For example, the People have not established that they made diligent efforts to obtain discovery from the detective who processed defendant's arrest. The detective was a central discovery custodian: he performed the identification procedure in the case and swore out the People's complaint, and the People's documents listed him as the arresting officer and their only law enforcement witness. Moreover, in the only pre-COC communication of which the court is aware between prosecutors and law enforcement concerning the existence of discovery in this case, the precinct's discovery liaison directed prosecutors to inquire with the detective about the existence of additional discoverable material, thereby putting them on direct notice that the detective was an important source of discovery. Yet the People did not make contact with the detective until after they filed their COC, and it is unclear what efforts they made pre-COC to contact him. True, the People say they sent four pre-COC discovery requests, but they have not submitted those communications to the court and have not specified in their briefing whether those communications were sent to the detective or to the precinct's discovery liaison. As a result, the only contact with the detective that is substantiated in the record occurred post-COC. That is not good enough: the People do not demonstrate due diligence where they fail to establish any pre-COC efforts to obtain discovery from their central discovery custodian.2
The People also failed to make any meaningful effort to ascertain the existence of discovery from the NYPD School Safety agents who were first on the scene. NYPD School Safety agents are civilian employees of the NYPD, which plainly is a "local police or law enforcement agency," CPL 245.20(2), so materials generated by those agents are constructively in the People's possession and are thus discoverable if they fall into one of the categories of discovery set out in CPL 245.20(1), see People v. Lantigua, 87 Misc 3d 1249(A), at *6 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2025). Here, in addition to being discoverable, material from the School Safety agents—even just their identities—would have been important, because those agents were on the scene soon after the incident occurred and might have information about the history between the parties. Nevertheless, it appears that the People did not send a single request to the agents themselves, or their division within NYPD, to attempt to ascertain the existence of their discovery. Indeed, it is not clear if prosecutors have disclosed—or are even aware of—the name and assignment for the responding School Safety agents, despite the fact that that information plainly is subject to automatic discovery. See CPL 245.20(1)(d). The People's failure to make any meaningful effort to discover these materials, either before filing their COC or after counsel put them at issue during conferral, is not consistent with due diligence.
The People claim that they were told these materials did not exist, but that claim is not credible. For instance, the People assert that "the assigned officer had previously informed the People that such records did not exist" before the People certified their discovery compliance. But there is nothing in the record indicating that the People ever asked for School Safety materials; indeed, their submissions assert only that they requested "any and all documents relating to Defendant's arrest." Moreover, the only pre-COC communication in the record concerning the existence of discovery was from the discovery liaison, and that email does not mention discovery from School Safety agents, let alone confirm specifically that no such discovery existed. To claim, on this record, that the People were told pre-COC that no School Safety discovery existed borders on falsehood. At a minimum, it is a mischaracterization of the record—and it is one that precludes crediting the People's further claim that, post-COC, the detective told them that School Safety materials "did not exist." Because the People have not submitted the communication with the detective, and in light of their other mischaracterization, the court simply cannot credit the People's assertion that the detective inquired about the existence specifically of discoverable materials from the School Safety agents.
Under the circumstances, the People's efforts to uncover BWC footage for the responding officers also was not satisfactory. Body-worn camera footage is always important discovery. This case is no exception: the BWC footage here apparently contained important exculpatory evidence that would have been useful for the defense and would have provided leads as to the existence of additional, potentially important discovery. Here, the People explain that their disclosure of the BWC footage was delayed because it was incorrectly associated with the wrong arrest number. But the People did not act diligently in attempting to resolve this problem. The record reflects no specific request for the missing BWC footage until August 16, when the People "specifically requested that the BWC footage relating to the incident be shared." The fact that the People received the requested BWC footage the day after they made this "specific request" only highlights the problem: had they made a diligent effort to pursue this information before filing their COC, it would have been available to the defense earlier. Given the importance of BWC generally, and given the scope of the BWC footage affected in this case, reasonable diligence required the People to make some tailored effort to resolve the problem before certifying their compliance. They failed to do so here.
For these reasons—and having considered the other statutory factors, including the relative simplicity of the discovery in this case and the volume of material provided and omitted—the court concludes that the People did not exercise reasonable diligence in attempting to discharge their discovery obligations in this case. Their COC and accompanying statement of readiness were therefore invalid. Although the People also filed a supplemental COC and statement of readiness on July 16, 2026, they did not at that time cure the diligence-related defects identified above, and that COC and statement of readiness are thus invalid for the same reasons. As a result, the People failed to validly declare ready within 90 days of the action's commencement. The action must be dismissed accordingly.
This constitutes the order of the court.
Dated: October 29, 2026
Bronx, New York
Hon. Philip V. Tisne
FOOTNOTES
1. The email from NYPD providing these materials is the sole exhibit to the People's brief.
2. Even if the People had made diligent, unsuccessful pre-COC efforts to contact the detective, a separate question would arise about whether the People could validly declare ready for trial without having first spoken to their sole law enforcement witness. The defense does not raise this argument, and the court need not address it here in light of its decision to dismiss the action for other reasons.
Philip V. Tisne, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. CR-CR-009930-26BX
Decided: October 29, 2026
Court: Criminal Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)