Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
The People of the State of New York, v. K. Rashim, Defendant.
Pending is defendant K. Rashim's 1 fully briefed, counseled omnibus motion. It is resolved as follows. Because the parties are the primary audience, familiarity with the case and its procedural history is assumed.
It is hereby ORDERED that the branch of the motion seeking to invalidate the certificate of compliance (COC) and first SCOC is GRANTED, the related statements of readiness are STRUCK as illusory, and (as the C.P.L. § 30.30 time has otherwise elapsed) the accusatory instrument is DISMISSED AND SEALED, subject to any application the People may make to defer sealing at the time this decision is handed down. The remaining branches of the motion are DENIED as academic.
* * *
I. Background
This is another in a series of recent cases where body-worn camera footage from the main incident date was not provided, or even apparently sought with specificity, before the People declared ready for trial. While the People can try to overcome that omission by showing reasonable efforts to obtain the footage, or by explaining why they thought it did not exist, the record here is not sufficiently developed to permit those findings—and the People have not otherwise explained why they did not seek the body-worn camera footage from the incident date until after being alerted by the defense. Because the People bear the burden of showing due diligence and developing the record, and because the defense has plausibly argued that the footage was relevant and revealed more missing discovery, this shortcoming—assessed holistically, in tandem with all relevant § 245.50(5)(a) factors—reveals a lack of due diligence that, in turn, leads to dismissal.
The Charges and Arraignment
In brief, the defendant was charged with having menaced the complaining witness on March 5, 2026 and then resisting arrest three days later on March 8. The complaint was filed, and the defendant arraigned, on March 9, 2026, starting the 90-day § 30.30 speedy trial clock.
The People's Discovery Package and Certificate of Compliance
The People declared ready on 80 days later, on May 28. According to the COC and the attached discovery receipt, the People's disclosures included an ICAD, activity logs and body-worn camera footage from six officers, police-generated paperwork, the ZOLPA, and other documents. Among the officers whose material was disclosed was the arresting officer, Officer Roque-Conception, who also was the deponent on the accusatory instrument. People's Resp., Ex. 1 at 1-4.
Tthe activity logs and body-worn camera footage all apparently stemmed from the arrest on March, not the original incident date of March 5, although neither the COC nor the discovery receipt specified the dates. The COC did not list anything as missing or unavailable.
The Supplemental Certificate of Compliance & Good-Cause Extension
A few days later, still within the 90-day speedy trial window, the People filed a supplemental COC reflecting the correction of certain inadvertent Giglio omissions in their initial discovery package, alongside a supplemental statement of readiness.
At the next court appearance on June 16, standing defense counsel requested, and was eventually granted, a COC-challenge good-cause extension through July 23 because the assigned defense attorney was on trial. See Court Action Sheet for 6/16/2026; Defense's Aff. ¶ 14.
Discovery Conferral Reveals Incident-Date Footage and 911 Calls are Missing
The assigned defense attorney began the discovery conferral process on June 26—a little less than a month after the People declared ready—by emailing a list of missing items. Heading that list was "all BWC from the date of the alleged incident" on March 5, followed by (among others) "911 call recordings" and "all radio runs" from March 5. Defense's Mot., Ex. A at 1. Defense counsel also inquired about the circumstances behind the arrest; apparently, one of the disclosures reflected that the defendant was arrested because an officer recognized him on the street, raising questions about how that had come to pass. Id.
The People responded three days later, on June 29, indicating that they had reached out to Officer Roque-Conception, who said he would "see if there is BWC footage recorded on the day of the alleged incident." Id., Ex. B at 1. The People were otherwise "still" not in possession of any 911 calls, and would turn those over promptly. Id. Regarding the circumstances behind the arrest, the People had been informed by Officer Roque-Conception that "when he arrived on scene the CW provided the name of the defendant," leading to an ID procedure conducted on March 9. Id. (emphasis added).
Disclosure of (Some) Missing Incident-Date Material Outside of the 90-Day Speedy Trial Period
On July 8, the People filed another SCOC, reflecting that they had disclosed incident-date footage from Officer Roque-Conception and 911 materials to the defense. Regarding the latter, the People explained (as mentioned above) that they had initially requested the 911 calls on May 6, and made a post-readiness expedited request for them on June 29, ultimately receiving them only on July 6. Regarding the former, the People had reached out to Officer Roque-Conception "[a]fter it was brought to the People's attention" that footage from the incident date might be available. SCOC at 2.
Motion Schedule and Additional Disclosures
This motion schedule was set July 17, 2026, after another good-cause extension was granted through July 30. The defense ultimately filed this motion a few days early on July 24. It is now fully briefed.
During its pendency, on August 20, the People turned over additional body-worn camera footage from the incident date from seven new officers, as well as activity logs from the same seven officers plus an updated activity log from Officer Roque-Conception.
II. Legal Standard
As the parties are aware, a COC is valid if it is the product of due diligence and good faith (the latter of which is not meaningfully challenged here). The People bear the burden of establishing due diligence by showing that they exercised reasonable efforts to comply with their statutory discovery obligations. See People v. Bay, 41 NY3d 200, 210-13 (2023). The People also must ensure that the record is sufficiently developed to reflect that their efforts were reasonable against the backdrop of the case and prosecution as a whole. See People v. Martinez-Perez, 87 Misc 3d 130(A), 2025 NY Slip Op. 51648(U), at *1 (App. Term, 1st Dept. 2025). The People's diligence is assessed based on the totality of their efforts, an assessment that is guided by the factors set out in C.P.L. § 245.50(5)(a). See C.P.L. § 245.50(5), (5)(b).
III. Discussion
As explained below, the People have not met their burden of showing reasonable efforts to comply with their discovery obligations arising out of this relatively simple case. Accordingly, their COC and first SCOC must be invalidated, the statements of readiness struck as illusory, and the accusatory instrument dismissed.
The main omissions here were the body-worn camera footage from the incident date and the 911 material, and it is simplest to focus on the former.2
The broad question is: why did the People apparently not provide any discovery from the response to the scene? The People were aware that a 911 call had been placed—they requested 911 calls before declaring ready, and disclosed an ICAD, which "memorializes in shorthand statements made to [a] 911 operator," United States v. Pizarro, No. 17-CR-151, 2018 WL 2089346, at *1 (S.D.NY May 4, 2018) (Nathan, J.), as part of their initial package—which would suggest a response to the scene. The March 5 incident date was also just a few days removed from the March 8 arrest date.
Moreover, the arresting officer had been on the scene. Indeed, once asked by the People post-readiness, Officer Roque-Conception made clear that he had responded on the incident date, which strongly suggested that body-worn camera footage would have been available. See Defense's Mot., Ex. B at 1.
This question is answerable. More to the point, an answer that reflected "reasonable inquiries and efforts" to comply with their discovery obligations, C.P.L. § 245.50(1), could provide a significant counterweight to the discovery omission.
That is especially important in a case like this one, where many other § 245.50(5)(a) factors weigh in the People's favor. For instance, the People turned over copious footage from the arrest, as well as a reasonably comprehensive discovery package overall. They also corrected this omission in part within the extended conferral period, providing the 911 calls and one of the body-worn camera recordings within that window. A "number of the due diligence are satisfied" when outstanding discovery is disclosed and mistakes are corrected during conferral. People v. Whitney, 88 Misc 3d 905, 909 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx Co. 2025) (David, J.).
So what is needed is some indication of why the mistake was made that would permit finding that the People exercised reasonable diligence overall.
But the People have not provided that record. Their sworn affirmation says nothing about outreach attempts, and they have attached no exhibits reflecting those attempts.
The unsworn record from their memorandum of law also does not clarify matters. The People say that they initially sought discovery on May 6, which, as the defense observes, see Defense's Reply at 3, is beyond the 35-day initial discovery window of C.P.L. § 245.10(1)(a)(ii). They then requested the 911 calls on May 7, before receiving discovery from their liaison on May 8. People's Resp. at 11-12 (pdf pag.).
In other words, there was one real outreach attempt in May via the discovery liaison, nearly two months after the case had commenced. Afterwards, no additional efforts were made until the People declared ready.
On the crucial issue—why was the March 5 incident date overlooked?—the People offer only:
After conferring with the NYPD liaison on May 8, 2026, it was the People's belief that the only BWC generated was BWC recorded during the arrest of the Defendant on March 8, 2026.
People's Resp. at 14.
Setting aside that this is unsworn, there is no way to evaluate whether the "the People's belief" was reasonable. If the discovery liaison had affirmatively stated that there was no footage from the incident date, that could be one thing, even though other elements of the record—the ICAD, the date differential in the complaint, and so on—would suggest otherwise. But if that was what happened, the statement recited above does not clearly reflect it. The People also do not explain why they waited for prompting from the defense to investigate the issue.
What is clear is that the People made outreach after they declared ready, and again after they obtained Officer Roque-Concepcion's body-worn camera footage from the scene. See People's Resp. at 14. That is all laudable; so, too, is the People's responsiveness to the defense's objections and their reasonably speedy provision of the initial footage. But to the extent that post-readiness efforts may now have independent curative effect after the August 2025 amendments to Article 245, there still is no explanation for why that outreach did not come earlier, and the post-readiness efforts do not make up for the lack of pre-readiness outreach.
Meanwhile, the defense persuasively argues in reply that the initial mistake has snowballed into a series of delayed disclosures; in the defense's framing, the "belated disclosure revealed more missing discovery." Defense's Reply at 5.3 Several entirely new officers were involved in the response to the scene, and the defense offers a sworn statement that their body camera footage was not duplicative of Officer Roque-Conception's and included, among other things, interviews with the complaining witness. See Defense's Reply Aff. ¶¶ 6-8. In other words, the combined footage from the incident date was relevant to the case, and reveals other potential discovery that has not yet been provided.
At the same time, however, it is somewhat difficult to fully credit the alleged prejudice stemming from the delay itself, as the defense requested a good-cause extension due to the assigned's trial, which meant counsel could not fully review the discovery in the meantime. That is not a critique; it simply means that the "several additional weeks" without access to the relevant discovery, and the resultant deprivation of the ability to examine "potential avenues of cross-examination," Defense's Mot. at 13, does not land with quite as much force when the case was functionally on pause. A well-earned reprieve to focus on another matter does not pair well with retrospective ticking-clock urgency.4 But while prejudice from the initial delay does not quite persuade, the broader question of prejudice under the § 245.50(5)(a) factors ultimately favors the defense.
For these reasons, the People have not met their burden of showing that they made reasonable efforts to comply with their discovery obligations, as assessed under the C.P.L. § 245.50(5)(a) factors—all of which have been considered, even if not mentioned. The total absence of any relevant discovery from the incident date, and the omission of all incident-date body-worn camera footage—an extraordinary salient category of discovery—is a significant mistake in a case as simple as this one. The People have not otherwise made a record sufficient to demonstrate that they exercised reasonable diligence, or to otherwise explain how this mistake came to pass. See Martinez-Perez, 2025 NY Slip Op. 51648(U), at *1; see also People v. Zeigler, 2026 NY Slip Op. 50232(U), at *2 (App. Term, 1st Dept. 2026) (concluding that the People did not meet their burden when, among other things, they "made only vague assertions regarding their efforts to obtain the required items"); cf. Carr v. Saul, 593 U.S. 83, 89 (2021) (observing, in the context of issue exhaustion, that the "critical feature that distinguishes adversarial proceedings from inquisitorial ones is whether claimants bear the responsibility to develop issues for adjudicators' consideration").
IV. Conclusion
Accordingly, the COC and first SCOC (which was filed close in time afterwards) are invalid. The corresponding statements of readiness are struck as illusory. And as over 90 days had elapsed before a valid statement of readiness or a pause in chargeable time—June 8 was the 90th day—the accusatory instrument is dismissed on § 30.30 grounds. All other issues are academic in light of this disposition.
Dated: October 23, 2026
Bronx, NY
David L. Goodwin
Judge of the Criminal Court
FOOTNOTES
1. The version of this decision submitted for publication has been lightly redacted to remove certain identifying information.
2. The omission of the missing 911 calls from the relevant section of the COC also weighs against the People's diligence. The People knew the calls were missing, and they should have told the defense as much in their COC. Knowing of the ongoing production delays, the People also should have asked for the calls with more than a month to spare, and expedited before readiness, not after. Given the well-known backlog, a month is not quite enough lead time, and almost ensures that the calls will not be provided by the readiness date.
3. The People have not requested a sur-reply, even though the defense's reply was filed August 27.
4. In a similar vein, the defense's accounting of the delay is slightly inaccurate, as is the suggestion that all time prior to this motion schedule was chargeable. See, e.g., Defense's Mot. at 15. Because the defense was granted a good-cause extension, any time beyond the 35-day implied conferral window would itself be excludable. See C.P.L. § 245.50(4)(c)(i).
David L. Goodwin, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. CR-006077-26BX
Decided: October 23, 2026
Court: Criminal Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)