Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
The People of the State of New York v. Joel Corona, Defendant.
Defendant Joel Corona, charged with Identity Theft in the Third Degree (PL § 190.78 [1]) ("Count One"), Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree (PL § 240.30 [1] [a]) ("Count Two"), and Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree (PL § 240.30 [1] [b]) ("Count Three"), moves to dismiss Count One of the accusatory instrument on the ground that it is facially insufficient. The Defendant also moves for hearings, and for discovery-related relief. The People oppose the Defendant's motions. For the reasons set forth below, the Defendant's motion to dismiss Count One is granted. The remaining motions are granted in part and denied in part.
I. Factual Allegations
The superseding information ("SSI"), affirmed by Police Officer Leslie Romero, states 1 :
I observed a Criminal Court Part D subpoena return associated with docket #CR-004599-26 containing bank records from Credit One Bank, N.A. I observed an application inquiry page that states the personal identifying information used when creating a new credit card. I further observed that the name listed in the applicant information was [complainant's name], the birthdate used for the application is the same as [complainant's] birthdate, the social security number used is the same number as [complainant's] social security number, and the address is [complainant's address]. I further observed that the email address listed on the application inquiry page is that of the defendant, and the phone number listed on the application inquiry page is that of the defendant.
I further observed a response cover letter from the aforementioned subpoena that states in sum and substance: [defendant] was added as an Authorized User on 03/31/2024 to the account.
I am informed by [complainant] that she did not open the aforementioned credit card account with Credit One Bank. I am further informed by [complainant] that she did not give the defendant permission or authority to open the aforementioned credit card account or add himself as an authorized user to the credit card account.
II. Facial Sufficiency
An information must contain factual allegations providing reasonable cause to believe that the defendant committed the offense charged in the accusatory part of the information, and non-hearsay factual allegations establishing, if true, that the defendant committed every element of the offense charged. (CPL 100.40 [1] [b]-[c]) This latter requirement, the "prima facie case requirement," " 'is not the same as the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt required at trial,' nor does it rise to the level of legally sufficient evidence that is necessary to survive a motion to dismiss based on the proof presented at trial" (People v Smalls, 26 NY3d 1064, 1066 [2015], quoting People v Kalin, 12 NY3d 225, 230 [2009]). "So long as the factual allegations of an information give an accused notice sufficient to prepare a defense and are adequately detailed to prevent a defendant from being tried twice for the same offense, they should be given a fair and not overly restrictive or technical reading" (People v Casey, 95 NY2d 354, 360 [2000]).
The defense argues that the SSI fails to establish that it was the Defendant, rather than some other individual, who filled out the credit card application. He also contends that the alleged conduct cannot constitute Identity Theft in the Third Degree, because the Defendant is not alleged to have actually used the complainant's credit. The People respond that reasonable inferences drawn from the factual allegations establish that the Defendant opened an account using the personal information of the complainant, his former girlfriend. They also assert that a credit card constitutes "property" within the meaning of Penal Law § 190.78 (1).
As is relevant here, an individual commits Identity Theft in the Third Degree when he "knowingly and with intent to defraud assumes the identity of another person" by "using personal identifying information of that other person," and "thereby obtains goods, money, property or services or uses credit in the name of such other person or causes financial loss to such person" (PL § 190.78 [1]).
As an initial matter, the SSI sufficiently alleges that the Defendant "assumed the identity" of the complainant. "[A]n accusatory instrument may include factual allegations supported by circumstantial evidence" (People v Rucano, 46 Misc 3d 142[A], 2015 NY Slip Op 50177[U] [App Term, 2d Dept 2015]. Here, the "application inquiry page" was filled out using the complainant's name, birthday, social security number, and address. Yet the contact information, specifically the email address and phone number, did not belong to the complainant, but instead were the Defendant's email address and phone number. As the complainant affirms that she did not complete this inquiry, it necessarily follows that another person did so.
Moreover, the Defendant was "added as an Authorized User" to the account; the complainant affirms that she did not provide any such authorization. Thus an individual, who is not the complainant, but had access to the complainant's identifying information, filled out a credit card application inquiry page; listed the Defendant's phone number and email address on the application; and added the Defendant as an Authorized User to the account. Based on these allegations, a reasonable inference can be drawn that the Defendant, the complainant's former boyfriend, committed the alleged acts (id. [accusatory instrument sufficiently alleged that defendant installed program to record keystrokes on former girlfriend's computer, where program had been installed "at a time when they were living together, and his former girlfriend's email account was accessed from an 'IP Address' registered to defendant"]).
Count One of the accusatory instrument is insufficient, however, for a separate reason. Penal Law § 190.78 (1) requires that, by using the personal identifying information of another person, a defendant "obtain[ ] goods, money, property or services," "use[ ] credit in the name of" the person, "or cause[ ] financial loss" to that person. Indeed, the Legislature enacted the identity theft statutes to address the "unauthorized use of individuals' personal information," which "caused significant financial harm to victims, who were often unaware that their information had been stolen until they received debt collection notices or discovered their credit ratings had been ruined"2 (see People v Roberts, 31 NY3d 406, 416 [2018]).
Here, the SSI does not allege that the Defendant "used" credit in the complainant's name (see People v Roberts, 31 NY3d 406, 421 [2018] "[t]he act of using another's credit card falls squarely within the identity theft statutes" [emphasis added]]). There are no allegations that the Defendant made any purchases or charges to the credit card account (compare People v Vandermuelen, 42 AD3d 667, 670 [3d Dept 2007] [evidence at trial sufficient to establish identity theft in the third degree where credit card account was opened with complainant's identifying information, and three charges were made to account]). Nor are there allegations that the Defendant caused "financial loss" to the complainant.
The allegations that a credit account card application inquiry page was completed in the complainant's name; that the Defendant's contact information was submitted with the inquiry page; and that the Defendant was added as an authorized user to the account, do not establish that the defendant "obtain[ed] goods, money, property or services," "use[d] credit in the name of" the complainant, "or cause[d] financial loss" to the complainant (cf. People v Debranche, 38 Misc 3d 872, 876 [Crim Ct, New York County 2012] [finding petit larceny charge facially insufficient, and holding that "[b]y opening a cellular account in a false name, defendants may well have intended, and indeed attempted, to steal property," but that "absent an allegation that even a single telephone call was placed using the fraudulently opened account, or that a single charge was incurred, no one, including the telephone company, has been deprived of any money, property or thing of value"]).
The People argue that the Defendant obtained "property," because a credit card constitutes "a piece of property" (People's Opp 8). While this may be true, the SSI does not allege that the Defendant actually obtained a credit card. The SSI alleges that, on some unspecified date, a credit card application inquiry was filled out. On March 31, 2024, the Defendant was added as an "Authorized User" to "the account." It is not clear, however, whether this is the same date on which the initial account application inquiry was made, or whether the Defendant was later added to an established account.
Nor is it clear from the SSI whether the application was approved or denied, or whether, for example, the complainant realized that the inquiry had been made and notified the bank. There is no allegation that the bank issued any card in response to the credit card application inquiry, and thus no allegation that a card was issued, or sent, to the Defendant.3
Accordingly, the Defendant's motion to dismiss Count One of the accusatory instrument, charging Identity Theft in the Third Degree (PL § 190.78 [1]), is granted.
III. Remaining Motions
The motion for a Mapp/Dunaway hearing is granted.
The motion for a Huntley/Dunaway hearing is granted.
The Defendant's motion requesting a hearing to determine the voluntariness of any non-noticed statements that the Defendant made to police officers, which the People intend to use on cross-examination, is denied at this time, subject to renewal before the trial court.
The Defendant's motion requesting a hearing to determine the voluntariness of any statements made by the Defendant to civilians is denied at this time, subject to renewal before the trial court.
The Defendant's motion to preclude the prosecution from introducing evidence of any statement or identification testimony for which proper notice has not been given pursuant to CPL 710.30 (3) is denied at this time, subject to renewal before the trial court.
The Defendant's motions for orders directing the People to comply with CPL 245.55 (2) and CPL 245.55 (3) are denied. The People's obligation to provide the requested information is set forth in the statute.
The Court declines to order the People to file an additional certificate of compliance (CPL 245.35 [3]).
The Defendant's motion for a Sandoval hearing is reserved for decision by the trial court.
This opinion constitutes the decision and order of the Court.
Dated: July 27, 2026
New York, New York
Kacie A. Lally, J.C.C.
FOOTNOTES
1. The SSI contains additional factual allegations that support Counts Two and Three, charging the Defendant with Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree. The Defendant does not move to dismiss those Counts, and thus those factual allegations are not transcribed here.
2. In contrast, offenses such as unlawful possession of personal identifying information do not require that the defendant actually "use" the complainant's personal information (see People v Essalek, 17 Misc 3d 835, 838 [Crim Ct, New York County 2007] ["[A] person need not actually use or attempt to use personal identification information to commit [unlawful possession of personal identifying information in the third degree]; rather, the charge requires only that a defendant possess personal identification information and have knowledge that such information is intended to be used in commission of a crime"]).
3. The People do not assert that the credit extended by Credit One Bank constitutes "services" pursuant to Penal Law § 190.78 (1). Even if such an argument were made, however, it is not clear that the credit card application was ever approved, or any such credit actually extended.
Kacie A. Lally, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. CR-004599-26NY
Decided: July 27, 2026
Court: Criminal Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)