Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
The People of the State of New York v. Sharod Bell, Defendant.
Defendant Sharod Bell moves to dismiss this matter pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law ("CPL") § 30.30. The People oppose the Defendant's motion and argue that it is procedurally barred. For the reasons set forth below, the Defendant's motion to dismiss is denied.
I. Factual Allegations
According to the superseding information ("SSI"),1 on February 16, 2026, at 5:10 PM, inside 114 East 122nd Street, New York, New York, the Defendant grabbed the complainant by her left shoulder; he then grabbed her jacket collar and threw her to the ground, causing the complainant's seven-year-old son to fall to the ground as well. The Defendant then dragged the complainant by her hair, repeatedly struck her on the right side of her head with a closed fist, and kicked her with both feet. The complainant sustained a laceration, bleeding, and substantial pain to the top of her head and right ear. Her seven-year-old son was present for the entirety of the alleged incident.
The parties' motion papers provide the following additional factual allegations: the complainant and Defendant are former intimate partners, and the seven-year-old child is their child in common. On February 16, 2026, the complainant went to the Defendant's apartment to pick up the child, and the alleged incident occurred. Both the complainant and the Defendant allegedly called 911, and NYPD officers responded to the apartment. The officers spoke with both the complainant and the Defendant, who each accused the other of assault.
The defense asserts that, according to bodyworn camera footage "(BWC") disclosed by the People, the officers conferred at the scene regarding whether to arrest both parties, or to arrest only one party. During this discussion, officers searched the NYPD's Domain Awareness System ("DAS") for both the complainant and the Defendant.2 The DAS noted that an open Investigation Card ("I-Card") existed for the complainant, indicating there might be probable cause for her arrest on another matter. Police Officer Sidhu viewed the complainant's I-Card on his cell phone, and then, according to the BWC, accessed another document on his cell phone via a link on the complainant's DAS report. Officer Sidhu then showed this document to other officers, including Officer Luis Yauri. The officers discussed these documents, and conferred regarding how to proceed, given the parties' differing accounts of the alleged incident.
An NYPD sergeant arrived at the scene, spoke with Officer Sidhu, and reviewed the complainant's I-Card on Officer Sidhu's phone. Officers from the NYPD 32nd precinct then notified the officers at the scene that the complainant's I-Card had been cancelled. Officer Yauri arrested the Defendant for the instant case.
II. Procedural History
On February 17, 2026, the People filed a misdemeanor complaint charging the Defendant with Assault in the Third Degree (PL § 120.00 [1], [2]), Endangering the Welfare of a Child (PL § 260.10 [1]), Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree (PL § 240.30 [4]), Attempted Assault in the Third Degree (PL §§ 110/120.00 [1]), Attempted Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree (PL §§ 110/240.30 [4]), and Harassment in the Second Degree (PL § 240.26 [1]). The Defendant was arraigned the same day. The case was adjourned to April 7, 2026, for the People to obtain a supporting deposition from the complainant.
That same day, the Case Management Services Unit of the District Attorney's Office requested that the NYPD provide recordings and metadata of any 911 calls and police radio runs. On February 20, 2026, the People interviewed the complainant, and the complainant provided injury photographs from the alleged incident. On February 27, 2026, the People obtained a signed SSI from the complainant.
In court on April 7, 2026, the People filed and served the SSI, which was deemed an information by the Court. The case was adjourned to May 26, 2026, for trial.
In the interim, on April 30, 2026, the People requested law enforcement disclosure ("LED") materials for Officer Yauri from the NYPD. On May 1, 2026, the People placed an expedited request to the NYPD for the 911 materials; the NYPD provided these materials to the People on May 5, 2026.
On May 11, 2026, the People requested and obtained BWC footage from the 25th Precinct Domestic Violence Squad for officer home visits. On May 13, 2026, the People requested any in- and out-of-state rap sheets for the complainant. The People also requested and obtained NYPD Enterprise Case Management System ("ECMS") files for prior Domestic Incident Reports involving the parties. In addition, the People requested NYPD activity logs for officers on three different dates, and a Prisoner Arraignment Lookup Sheet ("ZOLPA"). The People received these materials on May 15, 2026.
On May 15, 2026, the assigned prosecutor called, texted, and left voicemails for Officer Yauri inquiring as to the existence of an additional version of the NYPD Aided Report; the prosecutor did not receive a response. The People served an attorney from the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem ("NDS") with discovery, an Automatic Discovery Form ("ADF"), a Discovery List, a Certificate of Readiness ("COR"), and a Certificate of Compliance ("COC"). The COC stated that certain discoverable materials remained outstanding, specifically, a finalized Aided Report and Administration for Children's Services ("ACS") records. The People noted that they had disclosed a non-finalized Aided Report, and that they had requested but had not yet received the ACS records.
NDS has represented the Defendant since his arraignment; however, the NDS attorney whom the People served is not the Defendant's attorney of record.
In court on May 26, 2026, People stated that they were ready for trial. The Defendant appeared with his NDS counsel of record. At the appearance, defense counsel learned that the People had served discovery materials, as well as the COC and COR, upon a different NDS attorney. The case was adjourned to July 17, 2026, for trial. That same day, the People served all previously-served discovery upon the Defendant's attorney of record.
On June 17, 2026, defense counsel emailed the prosecutor regarding certain disclosed materials, and requested disclosure of: (1) the document that Officer Sidhu had accessed via the complainant's DAS report, and (2) underlying documents regarding the incident that had generated the complainant's the I-Card, specifically, an alleged assault from 2022. The People responded that same day that they had no information regarding the document Officer Sidhu had accessed. The People also asserted that they had disclosed all relevant law enforcement documents, and that any underlying documents regarding the complainant's I-Card, to the extent they existed, were outside the scope of discovery. The People additionally served an ACS Records Request Form 3 and filed and served a supplemental COC ("SCOC") and restatement of readiness.
Between June 18, 2026, and June 26, 2026, the parties conferred via email and telephone regarding these items. The defense also requested the People's consent to an extension of time to challenge the People's COC, from June 22, 2026, to June 26, 2026, given the ongoing conferrals regarding the disputed materials. The People responded that they would endeavor to provide substantive responses to the Defendant's inquiries by June 26, 2026.
On June 23, 2026, the People informed the defense that the complainant's 2022 I-Card had been cancelled because the statute of limitations had run; that the Defendant was not the alleged victim in that case; and that the alleged victim was an acquaintance of the complainant. The Defendant filed and served the instant motion off-calendar on June 26, 2026.
In court on July 17, 2026, the Court set a motion schedule, and the case was adjourned to September 9, 2026, for decision.
III. Challenges to the Certificate of Compliance
The Defendant contends that the People's initial COC and COR, filed on May 15, 2026, and their subsequent SCOC and restatement of readiness are invalid, because neither the document opened by Officer Sidhu via a link in the complainant's DAS report, nor materials related to the complainant's 2022 assault I-Card have been disclosed. The People respond that the Defendant's motion should be denied for failure to comply with CPL 245.50 (4) (c). In the alternative, the People assert that they have made good faith, diligent efforts to obtain and disclose all required discovery.
A. Criminal Procedure Law 245
Pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law Article 245, the People must produce certain initial discovery as a matter of course, without any demand from the defense 4 (CPL 245.10, 245.20). When a defendant is not in custody and no individualized circumstances apply, this discovery must be served on the defense within thirty-five days of the defendant's arraignment (CPL 245.10[1] [a] [ii]).
Criminal Procedure Law § 245.20 (1) sets forth a non-exhaustive list of materials subject to automatic disclosure. The prosecution must make a diligent, good faith effort to ascertain the existence of these materials, and to make any such materials available for discovery, even where the items are "not within the prosecutor's possession, custody or control" (CPL 245.20 [2]). "[A]ll items and information related to the prosecution of a charge" that are "in the possession of any New York state or local police or law enforcement agency" are deemed to be "in the possession" of the prosecution (id.). The People are not, however, required to obtain by subpoena duces tecum materials which the defense may also obtain via subpoena.
Once the People have fulfilled their disclosure obligations pursuant to CPL 245.20, they must file a COC (CPL 245.50 [1]). In doing so, the People must affirm that, "after exercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries and efforts to ascertain the existence of, obtain, and disclose material and information subject to discovery," the People have "disclosed and made available" all known, discoverable material that they have obtained (id.). In addition, the People must identify the specific items provided to the defense, and must disclose any materials "of which the prosecution is aware, but has been unable to obtain despite the exercise of due diligence" (id.).
Absent an individualized finding of special circumstances, only after a proper COC has been filed can the People be deemed ready for trial (CPL 245.50 [3]). Indeed, CPL 30.30 provides that "[a]ny statement of trial readiness must be accompanied or preceded by a certification of good faith compliance with the disclosure requirements of section 245.20" (CPL 30.30 [5]).
Once the People have filed a COC, the defendant must provide discovery to the prosecution within thirty days (CPL 245.10 [2]). Both the prosecution and the defense are bound by a continuing duty to disclose discoverable materials. If either party "subsequently learns of additional material or information which it would have been under a duty to disclose," then that party must "expeditiously notify the other party and disclose the additional material and information" (CPL 245.60).
Should the prosecution disclose additional discovery after filing a COC, the People must file and serve a supplemental COC. The supplemental COC must identify the additional materials provided, and must "detail the basis for the delayed disclosure" (id.; CPL 245.50 [1-a]). So long as the original COC was "filed in good faith and after exercising due diligence," the filing of a supplemental COC will not impact the validity of the original certificate 5 (CPL 245.50 [1-a]; see also People v Bay, 41 NY3d 200, [2023]; People v Coley, 240 AD3d 122 [2d Dept 2025]; People v McMahon, 237 AD3d 746 [2d Dept 2025]). The court will, however, "impose a remedy or sanction that is appropriate and proportionate to the prejudice" for any discoverable materials that are "disclosed belatedly" (CPL 245.80).
If the defense is aware of a "potential defect or deficiency" relating to a COC filed by the People, then the defense must file a motion challenging the COC "within 35 days of service of the certificate"6 (CPL 245.50 [4] [b], [c]). Any such challenge must include an affirmation that the defense "timely conferred in good faith" or "timely made good faith efforts to confer with" the prosecution "regarding the specific and particularized matters forming the basis for" the challenge, and that such efforts to resolve the issues raised "were unsuccessful" (CPL 245.50 [4] [c]).
A court will not invalidate a COC if the prosecution "has exercised due diligence and acted in good faith in making reasonable inquiries and efforts to obtain and provide the material required to be disclosed" (CPL 245.50 [6]). In assessing whether the prosecution exercised due diligence, courts weigh the totality of the People's efforts to comply with their discovery obligations, "rather than assess[ing] the [prosecution's] efforts item by item" (CPL 245.50 [5]). In particular, relevant factors include:
[T]he efforts made by the prosecutor to comply with [their discovery obligations]; the volume of discovery provided and the volume of discovery outstanding; the complexity of the case; whether the prosecutor knew that the belatedly disclosed or allegedly missing material existed; the explanation for any alleged discovery lapse; the prosecutor's response when apprised of any allegedly missing discovery; whether the belated discovery was substantively duplicative, insignificant, or easily remedied; whether the omission was corrected; whether the prosecution self-reported the error and took prompt remedial action without court intervention; and whether the prosecution's delayed disclosure of discovery was prejudicial to the defense or otherwise impeded the defense's ability to effectively investigate the case or prepare for trial.
(CPL 245.50 [5]).
B. Application
The Defendant states that the People failed to disclose NYPD documents for the alleged 2022 assault that generated the complainant's I-Card. Specifically, the Defendant contends that the People must disclose any initial report, complaint report, witness interview notes or recordings, any documentation regarding law enforcement efforts to arrest the complainant, and any efforts by the complainant to evade arrest. The Defendant argues that the non-disclosure of these materials, as well as the non-disclosure of the document that Officer Sidhu accessed via the complainant's DAS report, invalidate the People's COC, SCOC, and statements of readiness. The People respond that the Defendant's motion is procedurally barred under CPL 245.50 (4) (c). The People further assert that, viewing the entirety of their efforts to collect and provide all required discovery, they have satisfied their statutory obligations.
(i) CPL 245.50 (4) (c)
A defense challenge to a COC must include an affirmation that the defense "timely conferred" or "made good faith efforts to confer" with the prosecution regarding the issues forming the basis for the challenge. Additionally, a motion by the defense to challenge a COC or SCOC must be filed within thirty-five days of service of that certificate (CPL 245.50 [4] [c]).The People assert that the defense did not "timely confer," as the defense first emailed the People regarding discovery issues on June 17, 2026, 33 days after the initial COC was filed. The People further contend that the instant motion is untimely, as it was filed more than 35 days after service of the COC, and the Defendant neither requested nor received an extension from the court.
The Defendant argues that the motion is, at most, a single day late, because the original deadline fell on Friday, June 19, 2026, which was a court holiday. The next business day was Monday, June 22, 2026, and the Defendant filed the instant motion the following day, June 23, 2026. The Defendant further contends that the one-day delay does not constitute lack of timeliness, because the People originally served a different NDS attorney with discovery, and counsel of record did not receive the discovery until May 26, 2026. In any event, the Defendant argues, the People consented to an extension of time to file the motion.
CPL 245.50 provides that the moving party must request an extension of time to challenge a COC "before the expiration" of the 35-day deadline. Upon receiving that request, "the court may extend the time period" (CPL 245.50 [4] [c] [i]). Accordingly, regardless of whether the parties agree to an extension, any extension must be granted by the court.
Here, the defense did not request such an extension, nor was an extension granted by the Court. Based upon the specific circumstances presented, however, including the People's initial service of discovery on the incorrect NDS attorney, the parties' conferral via email and telephone regarding the materials at issue, and the People's apparent consent to the extension, the Court will consider the instant motion on its merits.
(ii) Disputed Discovery Material
The Defendant asserts that he is entitled to the document that Officer Sidhu accessed via a link in the complainant's DAS report, as well as the I-Card and other underlying materials related to the 2022 assault allegation. He argues that these items constitute potential impeachment and Brady material pursuant to CPL 245.20 (1) (k). The People respond that the disputed materials are not discoverable, as they were not created during the investigation or arrest of the Defendant in the instant case. The People also claim that these materials do not relate to either a "judgment of conviction" or a "pending criminal action," and are thus not discoverable under CPL 245.20 (1) (p) or CPL 245.20 (1) (q).
(iii) Disputed Materials
a. Document Accessed Via DAS Report Link
The defense has provided a good-faith basis for the assertion that the officers' review of the document accessed via the DAS report potentially factored into the officers' determination to arrest only the Defendant, rather than to arrest both parties. Officer Sidhu allegedly showed the document to other officers at the scene, including the sergeant. Officers allegedly discussed the existence and content of this document in conferring regarding how to proceed, given the parties' differing accounts of the alleged incident. A document that potentially affects an officer's determination to arrest or not arrest an individual at the scene of an alleged incident reasonably constitutes a written statement "related to the subject matter of the case" subject to automatic discovery (see CPL 245.20 [e]).7 Accordingly, the People must promptly obtain and disclose the document that Officer Sidhu accessed via the complainant's DAS report.
b. Underlying materials regarding the Complainant's I-Card
The defense has also provided a good-faith basis to believe that documents relating to the complainant's I-Card that the officers actually reviewed at the scene could potentially have affected their determination to arrest only the Defendant, and not both parties. The People must therefore promptly disclose any such documents that the officers reviewed at the scene of the alleged incident.
Any additional underlying materials, however, are not automatically discoverable. The defense is on notice of the alleged incident: specifically, that an I-Card was issued relating to a 2022 alleged assault of the complainant's acquaintance. The alleged incident did not involve the Defendant, did not involve allegations of domestic violence, and did not result in an arrest. Any contention that the complainant actively evaded arrest is speculative. Accordingly, the remaining underlying materials are not automatically discoverable.
(iv) Due Diligence
In determining whether the People exercised due diligence, the Court considers the totality of the People's efforts to comply with their discovery obligations (CPL 245.50 [5]). Here, the People's response details their efforts to comply with their statutory requirements from the inception of the case. They list by date all communications to obtain discovery, any follow-up requests, and when particular items were received and disclosed. The People also timely responded to defense counsel's emails and inquiries and immediately remedied their failure to upload an ACS Records Request once apprised by counsel of the omission. In total, the People disclosed more than 180 documents and files of discovery to the defense.
Overall, the People have met their burden of showing that they exercised both good faith and due diligence. They made and documented numerous inquiries to ascertain discoverable material and once identified, to obtain it. The People timely disclosed the vast majority of discoverable materials. The People's failure to disclose the documents reviewed by the officers at the scene, when viewed in the totality of their efforts to comply with their discovery obligations (see CPL 245.50 [5]), does not vitiate their due diligence, particularly where the People have advanced good faith arguments that the materials were not discoverable, and the Defendant has not alleged any prejudice resulting from the undisclosed materials. The non-disclosure of these items thus does not invalidate the initial COC, SCOC, or statements of readiness.
IV. 30.30 Motion
The Defendant is accused of a misdemeanor offense punishable by a sentence of imprisonment of more than three months. Accordingly, the People must be ready for trial within 90 days of the commencement of the criminal action, absent excludable time (CPL 30.30 [1] [b]).8 Once a defendant has alleged an unexcused delay greater than the statutory allowance, the burden shifts to the People to demonstrate that specific periods of delay should be excluded (see People v Santos, 68 NY2d 859, 861 [1986]; People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d 333, 349 [1980]).
In his motion to dismiss, the Defendant argues that more than 129 days are chargeable to the People. The People, on the other hand, contend that 87 days should be charged. This Court finds that 87 days are chargeable to the People, as follows:
A. February 17, 2026 to April 7, 2026: 49 days
The accusatory instrument was filed on February 17, 2026, and the Defendant was arraigned on that same date. The case was adjourned to April 7, 2026, for the People to obtain a supporting deposition. This 49-day period is chargeable to the People.
B. April 7, 2026 to May 26, 2026: 38 days
On April 7, 2026, the People filed and served an SSI and the Court deemed the accusatory instrument an information. On May 15, 2026, the People filed and served off-calendar a COC and COR. As set forth in Section III (B), supra, the initial COC and COR are valid. Therefore, the filing of the COC and COR tolled the speedy trial clock. The 38-day period from April 7, 2026 to May 15, 2026 is chargeable to the People. The remainder of this period is not chargeable to the People.
C. May 26, 2026 to July 17, 2026: 0 days
On May 26, 2026, the People stated that they were ready for trial. The case was adjourned to July 17, 2026, for trial. On June 17, 2026, the People disclosed an ACS Records Request Form that was inadvertently omitted from the initial discovery, and filed an SCOC and restatement of readiness. The People's belated filing of this material does not invalidate the initial COC and COR.9 On June 26, 2026, the Defendant filed and served off-calendar the instant motion. This period is not chargeable to the People.
D. July 17, 2026 to September 9, 2026: 0 days
On July 17, 2026, the Court set a motion schedule, and the case was adjourned to September 9, 2026, for decision. This period is not chargeable to the People (CPL 30.30 [4] [a]).
Accordingly, 87 days are chargeable to the People; the motion to dismiss is denied.
This opinion constitutes the decision and order of the Court.
Dated: September 8, 2026
New York, New York
Kacie A. Lally, J.C.C.
FOOTNOTES
1. The Defendant was initially charged via a misdemeanor complaint; an SSI was filed on April 7, 2026.
2. The DAS compiles a wide range of police and government data about a specific person, including arrest and warrant history, criminal investigations involving the person as either a suspect or victim, contact information, aliases, and 911 and 311 calls placed (see generally People v Gourdine, 83 Misc 3d 1264[A], 2024 NY Slip Op 51031[U] [Sup Ct, Kings County 2024]; People v Lampe, 84 Misc 3d 1203[A], 2024 NY Slip Op 51353[U] [Sup Ct, Bronx County 2024]).
3. The People assert that signed and unsigned copies of the ACS Request Form were included on their Discovery List but inadvertently omitted from the disclosed documents on May 15, 2026.
4. Criminal Procedure Law Article 245 went into effect on January 1, 2020, and has since been amended, most recently on August 7, 2025.
5. Similarly, a COC will not be deemed invalid if the People subsequently produce additional discovery that "did not exist at the time of the filing of the original certificate of compliance" (CPL 245.50 [1-a]).
6. This 35-day period may be extended upon a showing of good cause, or where the grounds for the challenge are "based upon a material change in circumstances" (CPL 245.50 [4] [c] [i], [ii]).
7. The People's argument that the document would not be admissible at trial is non-dispositive, as the scope of the People's discovery obligations is broader than that which is necessarily admissible at trial.
8. CPL 1.20 (17) provides that "[a] criminal action is commenced by the filing of an accusatory instrument against a defendant in a criminal court." Here, the accusatory instrument was filed on February 17, 2026. The speedy trial clock started running the next day (People v Stiles, 70 NY2d 765, 767 [1987]).
9. The defense does not rely on the omission of the ACS Records Request Form in challenging the May 15, 2026 COC and COR.
Kacie A. Lally, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. CR-005139-26NY
Decided: September 08, 2026
Court: Criminal Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)