Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
The People of the State of New York v. Vashovn White Bain, Defendant.
Defendant Vashovn White Bain, charged with two counts of Assault in the Third Degree pursuant to Penal Law § 120.00 (1) ("Count One"), two counts of Assault in the Third Degree pursuant to Penal Law § 120.00 (2) ("Count Two"), two counts of Endangering the Welfare of a Child pursuant to Penal Law § 260.10 (1) ("Count Three"), two counts of Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree pursuant to Penal Law § 240.30 (4) ("Count Four"), two counts of Attempted Assault in the Third Degree pursuant to Penal Law §§ 110/120.00 (1) ("Count Five"), and two counts of Harassment in the Second Degree pursuant to Penal Law § 240.26 (1) ("Count Six"), moves for an order dismissing one count of each of the charged offenses on the ground that they are facially insufficient. The Defendant also moves to invalidate the People's Certificate of Compliance ("COC") pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law ("CPL") § 245.50, and to suppress evidence. The People oppose the Defendant's motions, and argue that the challenge to the COC is procedurally barred. For the reasons set forth below, the Defendant's motions to dismiss are granted in part and denied in part. The remaining motions are granted in part and denied in part.
I. Factual Allegations
The SSI 1 alleges that on March 24, 2026, at 5:30 pm, at 321 West 111th Street, New York, New York, the Defendant was walking with the complainant, the Defendant's eleven-year-old son. The Defendant pushed the complainant "forcefully into a gate," causing his "back to strike the gate," and pushed him "forcefully into a fence," causing his "back to strike the fence." The Defendant then struck the complainant twice in the chest with a closed fist; he also placed his fist under the complainant's chin and "pressed upwards," causing the complainant's feet to "lift . . . off the ground." The complainant sustained a bruise to the left side of his shoulder and redness to his face. During the incident, and for "several days after," the complainant experienced "substantial pain" to his back, shoulder, jaw, and face.
The SSI further alleges that the complainant's eight-year-old sister ("ZB") was present during this incident. The Defendant "grab[bed]" ZB by the arm and "forcefully pulled her forward approximately two or three times," causing ZB to "begin to cry and to shout 'ow' multiple times."
II. Legal Standards
(A). Facial Sufficiency
An information must contain factual allegations providing reasonable cause to believe that the defendant committed the offense charged in the accusatory part of the information, and non-hearsay factual allegations establishing, if true, that the defendant committed every element of the offense charged (CPL 100.40 [1] [b]-[c]).This latter requirement, the "prima facie case requirement," is " 'not the same as the burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt required at trial,' nor does it rise to the level of legally sufficient evidence that is necessary to survive a motion to dismiss based on the proof presented at trial" (People v Smalls, 26 NY3d 1064, 1066 [2015], quoting People v Kalin, 12 NY3d 225, 230 [2009]). "So long as the factual allegations of an information give an accused notice sufficient to prepare a defense and are adequately detailed to prevent a defendant from being tried twice for the same offense, they should be given a fair and not overly restrictive or technical reading" (People v Casey, 95 NY2d 354, 360 [2000]).
(B) Analysis
The Defendant is charged with two counts of each offense: one count for his alleged acts against the complainant, and one count for his alleged acts against ZB. He moves to dismiss all charges relating to his alleged conduct against ZB.2 Accordingly, the Defendant moves to dismiss one count of Assault in the Third Degree ( PL §§ 120.00 [1], [2]), one count of Endangering the Welfare of a Child (PL § 260.10 [1]), one count of Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree (PL § 240.30 [4]), one count of Attempted Assault in the Third Degree (PL §§ 110/120.00 [1]), and one count of Harassment in the Second Degree (PL § 240.26 [1]).
(i) Assault in the Third Degree and Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree
The Defendant asserts that Counts One, Two, and Four are facially insufficient as to his alleged conduct against ZB, because the accusatory instrument does not allege "physical injury." The Court agrees.
Under Penal Law § 120.00, an individual commits assault in the third degree when, "[w]ith intent to cause physical injury to another person, he causes such injury to such person," or when "[h]e recklessly causes physical injury to another person" (PL §§ 120.00 [1], 120.00 [2]). A person commits Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree when, "with the intent to harass, annoy, threaten or alarm another person, he . . . strikes, shoves, kicks or otherwise subjects another person to physical contact thereby causing physical injury to such person" (PL § 240.30 [4]). Accordingly, "physical injury" is a required element of Counts One, Two, and Four.
A "physical injury" is defined as an "impairment of physical condition or substantial pain" (PL § 10.00 [9]). The People do not contend that ZB sustained an "impairment of physical condition," but rather that the allegations establish "substantial pain." "Substantial pain . . . is more than slight or trivial pain" (People v Chiddick, 8 NY3d 445, 447 [2007]; see People v Coppedge, 70 Misc 3d 139[A], 2021 NY Slip Op 50103[U] [App Term, 1st Dept 2021]). "Substantiality" of pain may be inferred from factual allegations, including the injury inflicted, the complaining witness' "subjective description" of the pain, and the nature of the defendant's alleged act (see Chiddick, 8 NY3d at 447-48). Courts may also consider the surrounding circumstances (see People v Henderson, 92 NY2d 677, 680 [1999]; People v Lang, 81 AD3d 538 [1st Dept 2011]).
Here, the SSI alleges that the Defendant "grab[b]ed ZB by the arm" and "forcefully pull[ed] her forward approximately two or three times." In some instances, the nature of the alleged act will permit an inference of physical injury (see People v Lang, 81 AD3d 538 [1st Dept 2011] [allegations that defendant punched complainant in face permitted inference that complainant sustained substantial pain]). The act of pulling someone forward by the arm, however, even when done "forcefully," does not, on its own, necessarily permit such an inference. The allegations that ZB began to cry, and "shouted 'ow,' " certainly signal discomfort. Yet without a description of any injury sustained, medical treatment received, or even any allegation that ZB experienced "substantial pain," these allegations are insufficient to establish physical injury for ZB (see In re Jose B., 47 AD3d 461, 462 [1st Dept 2008]).
One count of Counts One, Two, and Four of the information, charging the Defendant with Assault in the Third Degree and Aggravated Harassment in the Second Degree as to ZB, are thus dismissed as facially insufficient.
(ii) Endangering the Welfare of a Child
Penal Law § 260.10 (1) provides, in relevant part, that an individual is guilty of endangering the welfare of a child when he "knowingly acts in a manner likely to be injurious to the physical, mental or moral welfare of a child less than seventeen years old." The Defendant argues that Count Three, charging him with Endangering the Welfare of a Child as to ZB, is facially insufficient, because the SSI does not allege that ZB sustained any physical injury. The Court disagrees.
A defendant need not physically injure a child to violate Penal Law § 260.10 (1) (see People v Johnson, 95 NY2d 368 [2000]). It is "sufficient that the defendant act in a manner which is likely to result in harm to the child, knowing of the likelihood of such harm coming to the child" (People v Simmons, NY2d 829, 831 [1998]).
Here, ZB, an eight-year-old child, was present while the Defendant allegedly pushed her eleven-year-old brother "forcefully" into a gate and fence, struck him twice in the chest with a closed fist, and pressed his fist under her brother's chin, lifting him from the ground. Allegations that a defendant engaged in acts of domestic violence in front of a child may sufficiently establish Endangering the Welfare of a Child (see Johnson, 95 NY2d at 372-73; People v Reyes, 284 AD2d 119 [1st Dept 2001]; People v Brooks, 270 AD2d 206 [1st Dept 2000]). In addition to allegedly assaulting ZB's brother in front of her, the Defendant also grabbed ZB "by the arm" and "forcefully pull[ed] her forward two or three times," which caused ZB to "cry and to shout 'ow' multiple times." These allegations, taken together, sufficiently allege that the Defendant knowingly acted in a manner likely to be injurious to the physical or mental welfare of ZB. Accordingly, the Defendant's motion to dismiss Count Three is denied.
(iii) Attempted Assault in the Third Degree
The Defendant also moves to dismiss Count Five, charging him with Attempted Assault in the Third Degree as to ZB (PL §§ 120.00 [1], [2]). Physical injury is not required to sustain a charge of Attempted Assault in the Third Degree (see People v Parker, 60 Misc 3d 131[A] [App Term, 2d Dept 2018]; People v Mohamed, 58 Misc 3d 1205[A], at *3 [Crim Ct, New York County 2018]). "An attempt is established when, 'with intent to commit a crime, [an individual] engages in conduct which tends to effect the commission of such crime' " (PL § 110.00). Intent may be established through the "logical implication from the conduct itself or from the surrounding circumstances" (Parker, 60 Misc 3d 131[A] at *2). The allegations that the Defendant grabbed ZB by the arm and "forcefully" pulled her forward multiple times, causing her to cry and say "ow" are, at the pleading stage, sufficient to establish the charge of Attempted Assault in the Third Degree. The Defendant's motion to dismiss Count Five as facially insufficient is denied.
(iv) Harassment in the Second Degree
"A person is guilty of harassment in the second degree when, with intent to harass, annoy or alarm another person he or she strikes, shoves, kicks or otherwise subjects such other person to physical contact, or attempts or threatens to do so" (PL § 240.26 [1]). The Defendant argues that Count Six, charging him with Harassment in the Second Degree as to ZB, should be dismissed, because the SSI does not allege that he possessed the requisite intent.
The allegations that the Defendant "grabbed" ZB's arm and "forcefully" pulled her "two or three times," and that the Defendant's actions caused ZB to cry and shout "ow," readily permit the inference of an intent to harass, annoy or alarm the complainant (see People v Lewis, 76 Misc 3d 137[A] [App Term, 1st Dept 2022]; People v Jackson, 66 Misc 3d 132[A] [App Term, 1st Dept 2019]). The Defendant's motion to dismiss Count Six is denied.
Thus, one count of Counts One, Two, and Four are dismissed. The case will proceed as to one count of Counts One, Two, and Four, and two counts of Counts Three, Five, and Six.
III. Procedural History
According to the People, on March 24, 2026, the Defendant and ZB, his eight-year-old daughter, picked up the complainant, the Defendant's eleven-year-old son, from the Boys Club. On the walk home, Defendant allegedly pushed his son into a gate and fence, struck him twice in the chest with a closed fist, and placed his knuckles under the complainant's chin and pressed upwards with sufficient force to lift the complainant from the ground. The Defendant also grabbed ZB's arm and forcefully pulled her toward him several times, causing her to cry in pain.
The Defendant brought the children to their mother's home, where the children informed her of the Defendant's actions. The children's mother called 911 to report the assault.
On March 25, 2026, the Defendant was arrested. That same day, staff from Safe Horizons interviewed the complainant and ZB regarding the alleged incident.
According to the People, on March 26, 2026, the Defendant made a Mirandized statement to Police Officer Merlyn Bermudez. Later that day, a criminal court complaint was filed and the Defendant was arraigned. The case was adjourned to May 14, 2026, for the People to obtain a supporting deposition.
On April 9, 2026, the assigned prosecutor interviewed the complainant. Based on the interview, the People drafted a superseding information ("SSI"), which the complainant reviewed and signed. The People filed and served the SSI off-calendar.
Also on April 9, 2026, the People began gathering discovery materials: they requested 911 documentation; spoke via telephone with an individual who had witnessed part of the alleged incident; requested the Prisoner Arraignment Lookup Sheet ("ZOLPA") and Domestic Incident Report ("DIR") related to the case; sought to obtain bodyworn camera footage ("BWC") from Officer Bermudez; and obtained surveillance footage from the Boys Club. Also, on April 9, 2026, the People filed and served the SSI.
On April 10, 2026, the People disclosed to the defense the Defendant's videotaped statement to police, notes from the People's interviews with the complainant and eyewitness, the videotaped interview with the complainant and ZB conducted by Safe Horizons, the ZOLPA form, the handwritten DIR, paperwork generated by the NYPD during the investigation and arrest of the Defendant, and the Defendant's arrest photograph. The People also served statement notice.
On April 13, 2026, the People sent the complainant's mother HIPAA forms; the People received the signed forms on May 6, 2026. Upon receiving the signed HIPAA forms, the People determined that the forms were missing certain required information, and on May 13, 2026, re-sent new HIPAA forms to the complainant's mother.
In court on May 14, 2026, the Court deemed the SSI an information. The case was adjourned to July 15, 2026, for hearings and trial.
On June 2, 2026, the People requested End of Tour Activity Logs for the officers who arrested the Defendant. They also sent record requests to NYC Administration for Children's Services ("ACS"). The People served disclosures on defense counsel, including 911 records, Criminal Court papers, Law Enforcement Disclosures ("LED") for Officer Bermudez, documentation for witness fees received by the complainant's mother, and one of the two surveillance videos from the Boys Club. The People served the defense with an Automatic Discovery Form ("ADF"), a COC, and a Certificate of Readiness ("COR"), and filed those documents with the Court on June 3, 2026. The COC stated that the prosecution was aware that certain materials remained outstanding, namely, medical records for the complainant and ZB, NYPD Internal Affairs Bureau ("IAB") records for Officer Bermudez, End of Tour Activity Logs, and ACS records.
On June 3, 2026, the Defendant filed off-calendar a motion to suppress evidence.
On July 2, 2026, defense counsel sent the prosecutor a conferral email requesting outstanding BWC footage from Officer Bermudez of the Defendant's arrest. Defense counsel also stated that he had been unable to review the disclosed Safe Horizons interview video, and requested that the People provide it in a different format.
On July 7, 2026, the Defendant filed off-calendar a motion to invalidate the People's initial COC and dismiss certain counts of the accusatory instrument for facial insufficiency. Shortly thereafter, the People responded to the conferral email, stating they were aware of the defense motion and would disclose the requested items by the following day.
On July 9, 2026, the People disclosed BWC footage for ten officers, and End of Tour Activity Logs for ten officers, to defense counsel. The People also disclosed ACS records, but mistakenly disclosed ACS records that did not pertain to the instant case. The People filed and served a Supplemental COC ("SCOC"), restatement of readiness, and updated Discovery List. The SCOC stated that the People were aware that medical records for the complainant and ZB, and IAB records for Officer Bermudez, remained outstanding. The People also emailed defense counsel with instructions for viewing the Safe Horizons video.
In court on July 15, 2026, the Defendant requested a motion schedule to supplement his previously-filed motions. The Court granted the request, and adjourned the case to September 29, 2026, for decision.
On July 29, 2026, the People mailed subpoenas and signed HIPAA forms to Mount Sinai West Hospital to obtain the children's medical records.
On August 4, 2026, defense counsel informed the prosecutor that the incorrect ACS records had been disclosed. The People requested an update from ACS regarding the status of their records request.
On August 5, 2026, the Defendant filed a motion to dismiss the accusatory instrument for facial insufficiency, to invalidate the People's initial COC, and to suppress evidence.3
On August 19, 2026, the People received medical records for ZB, and disclosed them to the defense the same day. On August 20, 2026, the People re-sent the hospital a subpoena and HIPAA form for the complainant's records.
On August 26, 2026, the prosecutor realized that he had failed to disclose the second ten-second surveillance video clip from the Boys Club. The People disclosed the video clip and ZB's medical records, and filed and served an SCOC and restatement of readiness. The SCOC stated that the People were aware that the medical records for the complainant, IAB records for Officer Bermudez, and ACS records remained outstanding.
IV. Challenges to the Certificate of Compliance
The Defendant contends that the People's initial COC, filed on June 2, 2026, is invalid, because discovery materials were belatedly disclosed. The People respond that the Defendant's motion should be denied for failure to comport with the requirements of CPL 245.50 (4) (c). In the alternative, the People assert that they have made good faith, diligent efforts to obtain and disclose all required discovery.
A. Criminal Procedure Law 245
Pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law Article 245, the People must produce certain initial discovery as a matter of course, without any demand from the defense 4 (CPL 245.10, 245.20). When a defendant is not in custody and no individualized circumstances apply, this discovery must be served on the defense within thirty-five days of the defendant's arraignment (CPL 245.10[1] [a] [ii]).
Criminal Procedure Law § 245.20 (1) sets forth a non-exhaustive list of materials subject to automatic disclosure. The prosecution must make a diligent, good faith effort to ascertain the existence of these materials, and to make any such materials available for discovery, even where the items are "not within the prosecutor's possession, custody or control" (CPL 245.20 [2]). "[A]ll items and information related to the prosecution of a charge" that are "in the possession of any New York state or local police or law enforcement agency" are deemed to be "in the possession" of the prosecution (id.). The People are not, however, required to obtain by subpoena duces tecum materials which the defense may also obtain via subpoena.
Once the People have fulfilled their disclosure obligations pursuant to CPL 245.20, they must file a COC (CPL 245.50 [1]). In doing so, the People must affirm that, "after exercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries and efforts to ascertain the existence of, obtain, and disclose material and information subject to discovery," the People have "disclosed and made available" all known, discoverable material that they have obtained (id.). In addition, the People must identify the specific items provided to the defense, and must disclose any materials "of which the prosecution is aware, but has been unable to obtain despite the exercise of due diligence" (id.).
Absent an individualized finding of special circumstances, only after a proper COC has been filed can the People be deemed ready for trial (CPL 245.50 [3]). Indeed, CPL 30.30 provides that "[a]ny statement of trial readiness must be accompanied or preceded by a certification of good faith compliance with the disclosure requirements of section 245.20" (CPL 30.30 [5]).
Once the People have filed a COC, the defendant must provide discovery to the prosecution within thirty days (CPL 245.10 [2]). Both the prosecution and the defense are bound by a continuing duty to disclose discoverable materials. If either party "subsequently learns of additional material or information which it would have been under a duty to disclose," then that party must "expeditiously notify the other party and disclose the additional material and information" (CPL 245.60).
Should the prosecution disclose additional discovery after filing a COC, the People must file and serve a supplemental COC. The supplemental COC must identify the additional materials provided, and must "detail the basis for the delayed disclosure" (id.; CPL 245.50 [1-a]). So long as the original COC was "filed in good faith and after exercising due diligence," the filing of a supplemental COC will not impact the validity of the original certificate 5 (CPL 245.50 [1-a]; see also People v Bay, 41 NY3d 200, [2023]; People v Coley, 240 AD3d 122 [2d Dept 2025]; People v McMahon, 237 AD3d 746 [2d Dept 2025]). The court will, however, "impose a remedy or sanction that is appropriate and proportionate to the prejudice" for any discoverable materials that are "disclosed belatedly" (CPL 245.80).
If the defense is aware of a "potential defect or deficiency" relating to a COC filed by the People, then the defense must file a motion challenging the COC "within 35 days of service of the certificate"6 (CPL 245.50 [4] [b], [c]). Any such challenge must include an affirmation that the defense "timely conferred in good faith" or "timely made good faith efforts to confer with" the prosecution "regarding the specific and particularized matters forming the basis for" the challenge, and that such efforts to resolve the issues raised "were unsuccessful" (CPL 245.50 [4] [c]).
A court will not invalidate a COC if the prosecution "has exercised due diligence and acted in good faith in making reasonable inquiries and efforts to obtain and provide the material required to be disclosed" (CPL 245.50 [6]). In assessing whether the prosecution exercised due diligence, courts weigh the totality of the People's efforts to comply with their discovery obligations, "rather than assess[ing] the [prosecution's] efforts item by item" (CPL 245.50 [5]). In particular, relevant factors include:
[T]he efforts made by the prosecutor to comply with [their discovery obligations]; the volume of discovery provided and the volume of discovery outstanding; the complexity of the case; whether the prosecutor knew that the belatedly disclosed or allegedly missing material existed; the explanation for any alleged discovery lapse; the prosecutor's response when apprised of any allegedly missing discovery; whether the belated discovery was substantively duplicative, insignificant, or easily remedied; whether the omission was corrected; whether the prosecution self-reported the error and took prompt remedial action without court intervention; and whether the prosecution's delayed disclosure of discovery was prejudicial to the defense or otherwise impeded the defense's ability to effectively investigate the case or prepare for trial.
(CPL 245.50 [5]).
B. Application
The Defendant argues that the People's failure to timely disclose all BWC footage and police activity logs renders their initial COC invalid. The People respond that the Defendant's motion is procedurally barred under CPL 245.50 (4) (c). The People further assert that, viewing the entirety of their efforts to collect and provide all required discovery, they have satisfied their statutory obligations.
(iv) CPL 245.50 (4) (c)
A defense challenge to a COC must include an affirmation that the defense "timely conferred" or "made good faith efforts to confer" with the prosecution regarding the issues forming the basis for the challenge. Additionally, a motion by the defense to challenge a COC or SCOC must be filed within thirty-five days of service of that certificate (CPL 245.50 [4] [c]).
The People assert that defense counsel sent a conferral email on July 2, 2026, and that they lacked sufficient "opportunity to confer and respond," because the defense filed the instant motion to invalidate the COC five days later on July 7, 2026. The People also note that the defense never conferred regarding the belated disclosure of the activity logs, and that belated disclosure thus cannot constitute a basis for invalidating their COC.
Here, defense counsel sent a conferral email to the People on July 2, 2026, twenty-nine days after the initial COC was filed and, therefore, timely pursuant to the statute (see CPL 245.50 [4] [c]). Having received no response from the People within five days of sending his conferral email, the defense filed the instant motion within the statutory 35-day period. As the defense sent a conferral email, waited five days, and after receiving no response, timely filed the instant motion, the Court declines to deem the motion procedurally barred.7
(ii) Disputed Discovery Material
The Defendant argues that the COC is invalid, because the People belatedly disclosed BWC footage and activity logs. He contends that the failure to disclose these materials prior to filing the initial COC undermines the People's claim that they exercised due diligence.
With regard to the BWC footage, the Defendant asserts, and the People do not dispute, that the BWC constitutes approximately six hours of footage from ten different officers. The footage depicts the initial police response to the complainants' home; interviews with the complainant, ZB, and their mother; and the Defendant's arrest at his home.
The Defendant asserts that this six hours of BWC footage, and in particular the complainant's and ZB's recorded accounts of the incident, are crucial to his defense, and to pretrial motion practice. The People concede that the materials are substantive, and non-duplicative, and state that the belated disclosure was in error. The assigned prosecutor affirms that he mistakenly believed that he had disclosed all BWC footage to the defense by June 2, 2026. The People note that, once apprised by the defense that the BWC footage was missing, the People disclosed it within one week.
The activity logs, which were identified as outstanding in the initial COC, are from ten officers, including officers who responded to the alleged incident, and officers who arrested the Defendant at his home.8
The belatedly-disclosed material is subject to automatic discovery, and the Court will assess this discovery lapse in its CPL 245.50 (5) analysis.
(iii) Criminal Procedure Law 245.50 Analysis
In considering whether the prosecution has exercised due diligence, courts weigh the totality of the People's efforts to comply with their discovery obligations, "rather than assess[ing] the [prosecution's] efforts item by item" (CPL 245.50 [5]). At the outset, the Court notes that the People have clearly sought, in good faith, to meet their disclosure obligations. Their response details their efforts to comply with their statutory requirements from the inception of the case. They list by date all communications to obtain discovery, any follow-up requests, and when particular items were received and disclosed. Additionally, the prosecutor conferred with his office's internal discovery support units to obtain materials; communicated directly with civilian witnesses; and repeatedly sought to obtain properly-signed HIPAA forms for the complainant and ZB. The Court further notes that, when apprised of the missing discovery, the prosecutor promptly sought to obtain and disclose these items, providing the outstanding discovery within one week.
On the other hand, the belatedly disclosed discovery was far from "insignificant" (see CPL 245.50 [5]). At the time that the People filed their COC, they had not yet disclosed six hours of BWC. This BWC contained statements and information that were highly relevant to the case, and to any potential defense, including interviews with the complainant, ZB, and his mother regarding the incident. The footage also captured the Defendant's arrest.
Nor were these materials "substantively duplicative." In some instances, the People timely disclose BWC from multiple officers from an incident, but belatedly disclose BWC from an additional officer from the same incident. In such cases, the People often argue that the belated BWC is "substantially duplicative," because the belatedly-disclosed footage captured the same incident as the timely-disclosed footage. Not so here. The People belatedly disclosed BWC from ten different officers. None of the timely-disclosed BWC appears to have captured the interview with the complainant, ZB, or their mother. None of the timely-disclosed BWC appears to have captured the Defendant's arrest at his home.
CPL Article 245 "seeks to ensure that defendants and their attorneys can intelligently investigate, secure and use any potentially exculpatory evidence, fairly weigh a guilty plea offer, or develop an appropriate trial strategy" (People v Godfred, 77 Misc 3d 1119, 1124 [Crim Ct, NY Cty 2022] [citation omitted]). Here, at the time the People filed their COC and stated that they were ready for trial, the Defendant had no access to these recorded interviews with the complainant, ZB, or their mother. The contents of these interviews would certainly assist defense counsel in investigating the case, and would very likely factor into the Defendant's decision as to whether to accept a disposition, or whether to proceed to trial. Accordingly, the belated disclosure of the six hours of BWC footage factors significantly in the Court's due diligence analysis.
The belated disclosure of outstanding activity logs, on its own, may not necessarily constitute grounds for invalidating the COC. Here, however, the Court considers the belated disclosure of ten activity logs in conjunction with the belated disclosure of the BWC for ten officers. Weighing the totality of the People's efforts to comply with their discovery obligations (see CPL 245.50 [5]), the belated disclosure of the materials at issue invalidates the initial COC.
The Defendant does not seek to dismiss this case, pursuant to CPL 30.30. The accusatory instrument was filed on March 26, 2026, and the Defendant was arraigned the same day. The Defendant filed an omnibus motion on June 3, 2026, and subsequently filed a challenge to the COC on July 7, 2026. The People contend, and the Defendant does not dispute, that the speedy trial clock stopped on June 3, 2026, when the Defendant filed his omnibus motion (CPL 30.30 [4] [a]). In court on July 15, 2026, the Court set a motion schedule for the Defendant's motions, and the case was adjourned to September 29, 2026, for decision. The People thus calculate the chargeable time between March 26, 2026, to June 3, 2026, as 69 days.
As the Defendant has not filed a motion pursuant to CPL 30.30, the Court declines to issue a ruling regarding the number of days chargeable to the People. The Court notes, however, that the invalidation of the June 3, 2026 COC does not result in dismissal pursuant to CPL 30.30, as the period from June 3, 2026, to September 29, 2026, is not chargeable to the People.
V. Remaining Motions
The Defendant's motion for a Huntley/Dunaway hearing is granted.
The Defendant's motion to suppress all evidence seized incident to his arrest is denied, subject to renewal before the trial court. The People do not assert that any property was recovered incident to the Defendant's arrest.
The Defendant's motion for a Payton hearing is granted.
The Defendant's motion for a Sandoval hearing is reserved for decision by the trial court.
This opinion constitutes the decision and order of the Court.
Dated: September 28, 2026
New York, New York
Kacie A. Lally, J.C.C.
FOOTNOTES
1. The Defendant was initially charged via a misdemeanor complaint; an SSI was filed on May 14, 2026.
2. The Defendant does not move to dismiss the counts relating to his alleged conduct against the complainant.
3. The Defendant's motion to dismiss for facial insufficiency addressed the allegations in the original misdemeanor complaint. The Court granted counsel the opportunity to file a supplemental motion solely on the issue of facial sufficiency of the SSI.
4. Criminal Procedure Law Article 245 went into effect on January 1, 2020, and has since been amended, most recently on August 7, 2025.
5. Similarly, a COC will not be deemed invalid if the People subsequently produce additional discovery that "did not exist at the time of the filing of the original certificate of compliance" (CPL 245.50 [1-a]).
6. This 35-day period may be extended upon a showing of good cause, or where the grounds for the challenge are "based upon a material change in circumstances" (CPL 245.50 [4] [c] [i], [ii]).
7. The People's argument that the Defendant should be barred from basing his COC challenge on the belated disclosure of the activity logs is rejected. The People listed the activity logs as outstanding in their COC, indicating that they were already aware that those items were outstanding and had not yet been disclosed. It is unclear what additional conferral the Defendant could, or should, have undertaken with regard to these materials, where the People had already affirmed that they had so far been unable to obtain those items, but would continue to make good faith efforts to do so.
8. The People also address their belated disclosure of the second surveillance video. The Defendant does not, however, base his objection to the COC on the belated disclosure of this surveillance video.
Kacie A. Lally, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. CR-008958-26NY
Decided: September 28, 2026
Court: Criminal Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)