Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
The People of the State of New York, v. G. Ramirez, Defendant.
Defendant G. Ramirez 1 was accused of shoplifting from a Target. Although the two officers who responded to the Target's loss prevention office activated their body-worn cameras to document the arrest, none of the footage was disclosed to the defense within the statutory speedy trial period. Instead, the footage was provided only after the speedy trial time had expired.
Ramirez now challenges the validity of the People's facially timely certificate of compliance. She argues, among other things, that the belated disclosure of the body-worn camera footage is the product of a lack of appropriate diligence by the People.
As explained below, although the body-worn camera footage ultimately revealed little of significance, the total nondisclosure of responding-to-the-scene footage weighs heavily against the People in a simple and straightforward case like this one, at least absent a more-extensive record of pre-readiness outreach. The People's post-readiness efforts here, to the extent relevant, are not enough to tip the scales back in favor of the People. Accordingly, the branch of Ramirez's motion that seeks to invalidate the certificate of compliance, strike the statement of readiness, and dismiss the accusatory instrument will be GRANTED. All other branches of her motion will be DENIED as academic.
I. Background
The Allegations and Charges
Ramirez was charged via a March 12, 2026 accusatory instrument with stealing beauty and grocery items from a Bronx Target the day prior. The two charges were one count each of petit larceny, P.L. § 155.25, and fifth-degree criminal possession of stolen property, P.L. § 165.40, both class A misdemeanors.
The accusatory instrument was sworn out by Officer Lopez-Bruno. According to the identification notice served at arraignment, Officer Lopez-Bruno also oversaw the identification of Ramirez by the store's asset protection specialist.
As will be relevant in a moment, the other officer who responded to the scene was Officer Lewis.
Ramirez was arraigned on March 12. The People filed their certificate of compliance (COC) and declared ready on June 8.
The People's Pre-Readiness Discovery Outreach
The People made four documented attempts at discovery outreach prior to declaring ready, on March 20, April 29, April 30, and June 8. The first three attempts were emails sent by a trial preparation assistant, on which the assigned Assistant District Attorney was CCed.2 The final attempt was from the Assistant District Attorney, and was sent shortly before the People declared ready.
On March 20, the trial preparation assistant emailed both Officer Lopez-Bruno and an NYPD discovery liaison to request certain missing discovery. Among the items identified were missing activity logs for both officers and missing body-worn camera footage from Officer Lewis only. See People's Supp. Resp., Ex. A at 1-2 (pdf pag.).
The discovery liaison responded April 28. Relevant here, the liaison indicated that the missing activity logs and body-worn camera footage had already been shared with the People. See id.
On April 29, the trial preparation assistant wrote back to the discovery liaison and Officer Lopez-Bruno with concerns about the body-worn camera footage. In a back-and-forth series of emails (which dropped Officer Lopez-Bruno as it went on), the assistant alerted the liaison that the videos were not showing up in the shared folder, attaching a screenshot showing that only one video from Officer Lopez Bruno had been shared—a video with a duration of only two minutes and 14 seconds. The liaison said that there should be 12 videos shared under the relevant arrest number, and advised the assistant to try "opening and closing the app" and reentering the arrest number. People's Supp. Resp., Ex. C at 1-3 (pdf pag.).
Then, on April 30, the trial preparation assistant once again emailed the discovery liaison to highlight the inability to find or access any body-worn camera footage beyond the short clip mentioned above. The assistant also appeared to assume that the clip was all that was available from Officer Lopez-Bruno, as the email flagged her footage as "received" but described Officer Lewis's as "still missing." People's Supp. Resp., Ex. E at 4 (pdf pag.).
Thirty-nine days later, at 3:47 p.m. on June 8—the 88th day of the speedy trial period—the assigned Assistant District Attorney emailed the discovery liaison, writing "Are we able to locate this body camera for Officer Lewis?" Id.
The People's Certificate of Compliance
The People disclosed discovery to the defense, filed their COC, and declared ready at 4:20 p.m. on June 8, less than an hour after sending the email described above. The discovery consisted of, among other things, a 911 call; police-generated paperwork; an ICAD; impeachment material for both officers; as well as "evidence.com," which presumably meant the short clip from Officer Lopez-Bruno. Defense's Mot., Ex. Q at 1-2.
In the COC itself, the People stated that Officer Lewis's body-worn camera footage was still missing. Despite their "duly diligent efforts," the People had been unable to obtain that footage, despite having requested it "on 3/20/26, 4/30/26, and 6/8/26." Defense's Mot., Ex. C at 2.
Post-Readiness Outreach and Conferral
The discovery liaison responded to the Assistant District Attorney's June 8 email three days later on June 11, which was 91 days after the case had commenced. Across a series of emails that afternoon, the two attempted to work out why the People were unable to access the videos. The Assistant District Attorney then added Officer Lewis to the chain for the first time at 2:50 p.m., although Officer Lewis does not appear to have weighed in. Instead, the June 11 thread came to a close without resolution around 3:07p.m., when the discovery liaison asked Officer Lewis to "please assist [the] ADA on this matter." People's Supp. Resp., Ex. E at 1-4 (pdf pag.).
Defense counsel emailed initial discovery objections in the early morning of June 23. The first item on a list of 20 objections was the missing body-worn camera footage, as defense counsel was currently in receipt of only "one two-minute clip of BWC footage from Officer Lopez[-B]runo, which does not show Ms. Ramirez." Defense's Mot., Ex. F at 1 (pdf pag.).
That email from defense counsel triggered renewed activity between the People and the NYPD. Later that afternoon, at 4:29 p.m., the Assistant District Attorney passed defense counsel's objections along to the discovery liaison and Officer Lewis. Regarding the body-worn camera footage, the Assistant District Attorney added a note of urgency: "[O]btaining this video is crucial, the case cannot be prosecuted without it. Please have both officers try and see if they are able to reupload their BWC." People's Supp. Resp., Ex. E at 1 (pdf pag.).
The same afternoon, at 4:38p.m.—apparently, without having received a response from the NYPD—the People responded to defense counsel's discovery objections. Regarding the body-worn camera footage, the People wrote, "actively trying to get the BWC, NYPD is having trouble tagging the video correctly to share with my office." Defense's Mot., Ex. G, at 1 (pdf pag.). Several other items were marked "see above related to BWC," whereas others were marked "requested to see if it exists" (such as the interrupted patrol log), "does not exist" (such as the WINQ), or "not automatically discoverable" (CCRB information). Id.
The next outreach by the People was on July 6, when they emailed the Bronx District Attorney's Office body-worn camera unit to raise the ongoing issues with accessing anything beyond the single, two-minute clip from Officer Lopez-Bruno. The unit responded that it had located the video, to which access would be provided within an hour. See People's Supp. Resp., Ex. F at 1-2 (pdf pag.).
After some possible false starts, it appears that the footage from Officer Lewis's body-worn camera was provided to the defense the next day, on July 7 or 8. See Defense's Mot., Exs. J-M.
Ramirez's Motion
This motion schedule was set on July 6, with Ramirez's motion due on July 13, 35 days after the COC had been filed and served.
In her timely, counseled motion, Ramirez argues, among other things, that the People's COC is invalid and, by extension, failed to stop the § 30.30 statutory speedy trial clock. The People had belatedly disclosed Officer Lewis's body-worn camera footage, and Officer Lopez-Bruno's primary footage—that is, the footage documenting the arrest, not just the shorter clip—was still outstanding. See Defense's Mot. at 6-7, 13-19. Other omissions identified included arrest photos, certain communications between the officers and complaining witness, surveillance footage, the ZOLPA, and impeachment material for the two main officers. See id. According to Ramirez, these omissions, in the context of the relatively simple case, undermined any claim by the People to due diligence and required invalidation of their COC and dismissal of the accusatory instrument. See id. at 21-26.
In response, the People contend that they substantially complied with their discovery obligations by timely disclosing a "robust discovery package" to the defense after making appropriate "diligent efforts." People's Resp. at 9. The People assert that there is no longer version of Officer Lopez-Bruno's video; the two-minute version is all that exists. People's Resp. at 9-10. Other alleged shortcomings identified by the defense pertained to material that either does not exist or is not discoverable; regardless, the People made reasonable efforts to obtain most of it. See People's Resp. at 10-18.
In reply, Ramirez challenges the People's invocation of diligence, such as by pointing out that the People realized the body-worn camera footage was missing when they declared ready—and, indeed, that Officer Lopez-Bruno should have a long video, as her body-worn camera was recording at the time of the incident. See Defense's Reply at 7. Footage from the arrest was important, because there otherwise was "no video or documentation of when the NYPD arrived on scene, the identification of Ms. Ramirez, her arrest, or transport to the 52nd precinct." Id.
Supplemental Briefing Order and Submissions; Final Body-Worn Camera Video
Upon initial review of the parties' filings, the Court determined that additional submissions were required for a fair decision to be rendered. Via a briefing order of August 17, the People were directed to, among other things, provide a sworn and documented record of their outreach. The defense was permitted to then file an additional reply. See Aug. 17 Order at 1-3.
The content of the parties' supplemental submissions has largely been incorporated into the narrative above. The People also provided the body-worn camera footage to the Court—which, by that time, included Officer Lopez-Bruno's primary body-worn camera footage, which the People had obtained and disclosed on August 27. See Defense's Supp. Aff. ¶¶ 4-5.
The footage depicts the officers arriving at the Target, arresting Ramirez, meeting with Ramirez's mother (who takes some of her property for safekeeping), and then departing with Ramirez to the precinct for processing. The two-minute clip from Officer Lopez-Bruno shows the officer delivering more of Ramirez's property to members of her family outside of the precinct and (very kindly) explaining the arrest process, the possibility of a DAT, and the estimated length of time that Ramirez would be in custody.
III. Legal Standard
When the top count charged is a class A misdemeanor, the People must be ready for trial within 90 days of a case's commencement. See C.P.L. § 30.30(1)(b). If this deadline is not met, the case must be dismissed if the defense so moves. See People v. Labate, 42 NY3d 184, 190 (2024).
The People cannot stop the speedy trial clock until they have certified compliance with their statutory discovery obligations. They do so by, among other things, filing a COC. A COC, if valid, is one of the ingredients of a proper declaration of readiness for trial. See People v. Bay, 41 NY3d 200, 210 (2023).
As in this case, the defense often attacks the validity of the COC and, by extension, whether the speedy trial clock ever stopped. Thus, the "key question" in assessing the validity of a COC is always whether the People have met the burden of showing that they exercised "due diligence" by making "reasonable inquiries" and "reasonable efforts" to comply with their statutory discovery obligations. Id. at 211, 213.
A nonexhaustive list of factors relevant to diligence is now codified in (among other places) C.P.L. § 245.50(5)(a), and includes an assessment of the People's efforts, the importance of any missing or belatedly disclosed material, the volume of discovery provided versus what was outstanding, the complexity (or simplicity) of the case, whether the People knew the belatedly disclosed material existed, and so on. Diligence must always be assessed based on the totality of the People's efforts rather than line-by-line or item-by-item, with no one factor or consideration being determinative. C.P.L. § 245.50(5), (5)(b).
If the People fail to meet their burden of demonstrating due diligence, "the COC must be deemed improper, the SOR stricken as illusory, and—so long as the time chargeable to the People exceeds the applicable CPL 30.30 period—the case dismissed." People v. Wilson, --- AD3d ---, 2026 NY Slip Op 05443, at *2 (3d Dept. 2026) (internal quotation marks and alterations omitted).
IV. Discussion 3
On this record, the People have not met their burden of showing that they exercised due diligence. The COC will thus be invalidated, the statement of readiness struck, and the accusatory instrument dismissed.
Many of the relevant factors are either neutral or weigh somewhat against the People. The relatively comprehensive discovery package is counterbalanced by the sheer simplicity of the case—a petit larceny with only two officers at the scene and a minimal amount of police-generated paperwork. Mistakes made in a simple case generally "cut[ ] against a finding of due diligence." People v. McMahon, 237 AD3d 746, 751 (2d Dept.), leave denied, 43 NY3d 1057 (2025); see also People v. Scardino, 2026 NY Slip Op. 51596(U), at *3 (App. Term, 9th & 10th Jud. Dists. 2026) (concluding that shortcomings in a "not particularly complex" case weighed against the People).
The main omission here, of course, is almost all the relevant body-worn camera footage, which the People did not obtain or disclose until well after declaring ready. As the § 245.50(5)(a) factors recognize, not all discovery documents—or, for that matter, discovery omissions—are created equal. Implications of artificial intelligence and other similar video-alteration concerns notwithstanding, body-worn camera footage provides an opportunity for the prosecutor, defense counsel, defendant, and court to see what happened at the scene, and can be of outsized importance in a case. See People v. Gonzalez, 86 Misc 3d 1230(A), 2025 NY Slip Op. 51064(U), at *6 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx Co. 2025) (explaining that body-worn camera footage "often depicts essential events, particularly when a complaining witness is involved"); People v. Morgan, 83 Misc 3d 1221(A), 2024 NY Slip Op. 50771(U), at *3 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Queens Co. 2024) ("[B]ody-worn camera footage is a basic part of any case.").
More to the point, body-worn camera footage of an arrest at an incident location, close in time to the alleged incident, is likely to be relevant, unlike certain other automatic discovery. The salience in a given case of the ZOLPA, for instance, is probably minimal, regardless of whether the ZOLPA is or is not automatically discoverable. The opposite is true for body-worn camera footage of the sort at issue here.
At the same time, and as made clear by both the pre- and post-revision Article 245 and applicable decisional law, the omission or delayed disclosure of "a few discoverable items" is not fatal to a showing of due diligence. People v. Kasner, --- Misc 3d ---, 2026 NY Slip Op 26159, at *2 (App. Term, 1st Dept. 2026) (quoting People v. Lee, 249 AD3d 555, 556 (1st Dept. 2026)). An omission of even of an important category of discovery must be assessed within the broader context of the "totality of the [People's] efforts to comply with" their discovery obligations. C.P.L. § 245.50(5).
One part of that analysis somewhat favors the People: this body-worn camera footage appears not to be of outsized importance, at least at first glance. The footage may contain statements by the asset protection specialist—the various parties are not easily identified—but if that person did make statements, they were neither extensive nor obviously audible. Ramirez's own statements were not particularly inculpatory, and not much of apparent relevance happened during the arrest. In short, while footage of the arrest could have been revealing, the actual footage here was not—or, at least, is not so in obvious fashion. This attenuates somewhat the People's failure to timely provide that footage, as it is at least arguable that the footage turned out to be largely insignificant, see C.P.L. § 245.50(5)(a). Compare with People v. Dixon, 88 Misc 3d 1266(A), 2026 NY Slip Op. 50654(U), at *4, 6-7 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx Co. 2026) (failure to provide correct body-worn camera footage struck "right at the core of the People's overall readiness for trial" when the footage of the arrest contained potentially exculpatory statements by the complaining witness, along with an examination of the scene and the defendant's own statements).
Thus, the error was still significant, but its impact is diminished. The People would thus need to do less to show that the totality of their efforts, see C.P.L. § 245.50(5), were still reasonable.
The People's efforts here nevertheless fell short of that standard.
First, that "insignificance" became apparent only once the footage was actually provided. In other words, the defense had no way of knowing what was in the footage until it was obtained and disclosed—and neither, for that matter, did the People. The People have not provided any reason to think that, in this specific case, it would have been appropriate to bank on the footage showing nothing of salience.
The People's efforts to find the footage, meanwhile, did not reflect the expected urgency. There were only four attempts at outreach prior to the People's declaration of readiness: March 20, April 29, April 30, and June 8. Across each, the People knew that they were missing Officer Lewis's footage in its entirety, yet seemed to be unaware that the footage they possessed from Officer Lopez-Bruno was a clip from later in the evening and not from the arrest and processing—immediately identifiable, in other words, as not being from the scene. See, e.g., People's Supp. Resp., Ex. E at 4 (pdf pag.). Officer Lewis himself was not included on any of the pre-readiness emails, despite his footage being the primary subject of the outreach. Then, on June 8, the People sent one additional email before declaring ready shortly thereafter.
To be clear, the actual content of the People's outreach—inquiring about the specific footage they believed to be missing, and highlighting early issues accessing the body-worn camera footage—was appropriate, and the People do earn credit for identifying a specific missing item or category rather than making general inquiries. But the follow through was wanting. The People knew—early, long before their certificate of compliance was due—that they were missing or could not access Officer Lewis's body-worn camera footage, yet took no significant steps prior to the declaration of readiness.
The People nevertheless certified compliance and declared ready on day 88 despite lacking the footage, and did less than an hour after emailing the discovery liaison once again to ask for the footage This email was the first direct outreach from an actual prosecutor, as opposed to a trial preparation assistant, and came after more than a month of inactivity.
Why the People decided to prematurely declare ready on day 88 is itself not clarified by the record. June 8, 2026 was a Monday, and more than 48 hours remained before their speedy trial time would have run. Forty-eight hours would be more than enough time to obtain the footage or, failing that, to try to do in a way that stood a better chance of withstanding scrutiny. The People also had the option of asking for more time, see Bay, 41 NY3d at 215 (describing the various ways in which the People can extend their time), but did not do so.
The People still yet could have tried to remediate the issue by obtaining and disclosing the body-worn camera shortly after declaring ready. But the post-readiness efforts were also unsatisfying. Absent a short and unproductive email discussion on June 11—day 91—the People took no additional steps to obtain the video until the discovery conferral email of June 23. While the People expressed urgency to the NYPD discovery liaison—conceding in an email that "obtaining this video is crucial, the case cannot be prosecuted without it," People's Supp. Resp., Ex. E at 1 (pdf pag.)—they told the defense that the fault lay with the NYPD, which was having "trouble tagging the video correctly." Defense's Mot., Ex. G, at 1 (pdf pag.).
The saga of Officer Lewis's video came to a close not with retagging, but with an internal email to the District Attorney's Office body-worn camera unit on July 6. Once that unit was contacted, the issue appears to have been fixed within an hour. See People's Supp. Resp., Ex. F at 1-2 (pdf pag.). In other words, the People appear to have been in actual possession of the video, not just constructive possession, for at least part of this period, with a technical fault standing in the way of access.
That the People managed to disclose the video within 35 days of declaring ready does not, on this record, say much about diligence. Correction of errors and omissions during the 35-day implied post-certification conferral period of C.P.L. § 245.50(4)(c) can, in certain circumstances, reflect positively on the People's diligence. See People v. Whitney, 88 Misc 3d 905, 909 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx Co. 2025). But that is diminished when, as here, the error or omission is something the People are already aware of before declaring ready. And exacerbating matters, it took more than one additional month for the People to disclose Officer Lopez-Bruno's "real" body-worn camera footage, as opposed to the snippet disclosed prior to declaring ready.
In sum, the People have not met their burden of showing that they exercised reasonable efforts and made reasonable inquiries to comply with their statutory discovery obligations. See Bay, 41 NY3d at 211, 213; C.P.L. § 245.50(5), (5)(a)-(b). Despite knowing that they were missing at least half of the body-worn camera footage from the scene—and, had they examined the footage they possessed, the People would have learned that they were missing all of the footage from the scene—the People took minimal steps to obtain that footage before declaring ready. Then, after declaring ready, the People waited entirely too long to fix the error. While the impact of the omission ultimately turned out to be minimal, body-worn camera footage from a close-to-incident arrest at the scene is a category of discovery highly likely to be relevant in any given case; that the People were lucky here does not do much to diminish the impact of their mistake. A holistic assessment, gauged against the People as the party with the burden, still falls short of "reasonable efforts" on this record.
***
For the reasons set forth above, it is ORDERED that the COC is INVALIDATED and the statement of readiness is STRUCK as illusory. Because the original COC could not stop the speedy trial clock, more than 90 days elapsed before any valid declaration of readiness. The branch of the motion seeking dismissal of the accusatory instrument is therefore GRANTED, and the accusatory instrument is DISMISSED AND SEALED, subject to any application the People may make to stay sealing when this decision is handed down. All other branches of Ramirez's motion are DENIED as academic.
Dated: October 8, 2026
Bronx, NY
David L. Goodwin
Judge of the Criminal Court
FOOTNOTES
1. The version of this decision submitted for publication has been lightly redacted to remove certain identifying information.
2. The People's supplemental affirmation reflects that the "assigned" requested discovery on these three occasions, see People's Supp. Aff. ¶¶ 2, 4, 6, but the reproduced emails are all from the trial preparation assistant, presumably acting at the assigned's behest.
3. Two issues warrant brief discussion.First, Ramirez does not challenge the People's good faith, which is a separate (if underexplored) prerequisite to the validity of a COC. Bay, 41 NY3d at 212. There is thus no need to address whether the People's COC was filed in good faith.Second, in response to the supplemental briefing order, the parties addressed the People's alleged failure to comply with the 35-day timing requirement of C.P.L. § 245.10(1)(a)(ii), and whether shortcomings of this sort should have been the subject of pre-motion conferral. Both prior to and since the August 2025 revisions to Article 245, courts generally have assessed § 245.10(1)(a) timing defects as one of the many factors relevant to the People's diligence overall. See People v. Stamm, 85 Misc 3d 136(A), 2025 NY Slip Op. 50497(U), at *3 (App. Term, 9th & 10th Jud. Dists. 2025); People v. Addai, --- Misc 3d ---, 2026 NY Slip Op 26095, at *5 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx Co. 2026); see also People v. Carter, 86 Misc 3d 1248(A), 2025 NY Slip Op. 51233(U), at *2 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct., Bronx Co. 2025) (collecting cases). As the post-August 2025 mechanics of the discovery deadline have not yet been defined—and as, frankly, compliance with the 35-day window seems to be the exception rather than the rule—this decision will not weigh this factor against the People, especially as the outcome would be the same in any event.
David L. Goodwin, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. CR-006358-26BX
Decided: October 08, 2026
Court: Criminal Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)