Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Robert Williams, Petitioner v. Diomedes Tejada, Respondent
Recitation, as required by CPLR R 2219(a), of the papers considered in the review of Respondent's Order to Show Cause (OSC/m seq #1) seeking an order vacating the Court's Decision/Order After Inquest dated September 11, 2026 and Petitioner's Cross-Motion by OSC (m seq #2) seeking entry of a judgment of possession:
Papers Doc #
Respondent's OSC Seq #1, Affirmation, Revised Affirmation in Support, Exhibits A-G 1, 2, 3, 4-10
Petitioner's OSC Seq #2, Affirmation 11
Respondent's Affirmation in Opposition to Petitioner's OSC, Exhibits A-H 12, 13-20
Petitioner's Reply Memorandum of Law, Exhibits A, B1, B2, C1, C2 21, 22-26
For the reasons that follow, Respondent's order to show cause (OSC) to vacate the Decision/Order After Inquest (m seq #1) is granted, Petitioner's cross-motion/OSC for a judgment of possession is denied without prejudice, and this proceeding is restored to the Court's calendar for trial on December 10, 2026 at 9:30 a.m.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY & BACKGROUND
This is an illegal lockout proceeding commenced by Robert Williams pro se (Petitioner) by OSC and Verified Petition filed on August 31, 2026 alleging illegal lockout by Diomedes Tejada (Respondent) from the ground floor apartment at 647 East 229th Street in the Bronx (the apartment/the building). On the return date, September 11, 2026, Respondent failed to appear and the court conducted an inquest. Petitioner testified and presented documentary evidence showing that:
• he had served the OSC and Verified Petition on Respondent at 2969 Valentine Avenue in the Bronx, the address listed on Respondent's deed dated July 13, 2026;
• he has lived in the building since August or September 2009;
• his tenancy is subject to Rent Stabilization, as determined by Decision/Order After Trial in a holdover eviction proceeding entitled Barbara Smith v Robert Williams, LT-012299-19/BX, based on, inter alia, the undisputed existence of a violation placed by the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development (DHPD) on October 26, 2018 for five illegal "SROs" (single-room occupancy units) created in the place of a single apartment on the first floor of the building;
• the next owner of the building after Barbara Smith also brought a holdover eviction proceeding against Petitioner, 647 East 229th St Bronx LLC v Robert Williams, LT-319797-22/BX, under Rent Stabilization Code (RSC) § 2524.3(c) based on "the illegal nature of the tenancy which violates various building codes and laws and which has caused violations to be issued"; that case was dismissed without prejudice by Decision/Order After Trial dated July 16, 2025 due to the landlord's failure to prove that it was "actually" subject to civil or criminal penalties due to the unresolved DHPD violation for the creation of five "SROs" in the building's basement a/k/a first floor;
• in the meantime, there was a fire in the building on November 27, 2024 after which DHPD issued a vacate order on January 9, 2025 and placed Petitioner in a shelter;
• Petitioner's rent was reduced temporarily to $1.00/month by Order of the New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR) dated January 16, 2025, which he paid to the prior owner, 647 East 229th St Bx LLC, through June 2026;
• Petitioner filed an HP/harassment case against the prior owner after the fire, Robert Williams v 647 East 229th St Bronx LLC, LT-003620-24/BX;
• DHPD notified Petitioner by letter dated July 14, 2026 that the apartment had been "deemed habitable" and that he should contact his landlord to make arrangements to return;
• After receiving the DHPD notification Petitioner learned there was a new owner who had taken occupancy, installed new locks and refused to give Petitioner keys.
At the conclusion of the inquest, on default, the court issued a Decision/Order dated September 11, 2026 granting the illegal lockout petition, finding that Respondent had illegally locked Petitioner out, and ordering Respondent to reinstate Petitioner to possession.
On September 17, 2026 Respondent pro se filed an OSC seeking to vacate his default and the September 11, 2026 Decision and Order and restore the proceeding to the calendar, supported by his affirmation asserting that his excuse for his default was that he did not receive the court papers and had no actual prior notice that he was required to appear in court on the September 11, 2026 court date: Petitioner served the court papers on him at his old address, 2969 Valentine Avenue in the Bronx, a building he used to own but sold in June 2026 and did not live at when this proceeding was commenced. As a defense to this proceeding, Respondent asserted that he purchased the building on July 13, 2026 as a vacant, completely renovated, three-family house and the "SRO house" that Petitioner used to live in no longer exists; whereas Petitioner's prior occupancy before the fire concerned one room on the basement/first-floor area that had been divided "into approximately seven separate rooms and had been used as a rooming-house-type configuration", that floor of the building — similar to the other two floors of the building - now consists of a four-bedroom apartment. Respondent asks the Court to give him "the opportunity to establish the exact location and legal status of the premises Petitioner previously occupied through prior court records, DOB records, HPD records, DHCR records, plans, photographs, and other evidence" and for the Court to consider "the lawful occupancy and approved configuration of the building before and after the fire" and "determine the identity and legal status of Petitioner's former housing accommodation". The Court signed Respondent's OSC and made it returnable October 1, 2026.
On September 18, 2026 Petitioner filed an OSC, also seeking to restore the proceeding to the calendar, supported by his affirmation asserting that Respondent had refused to comply with the court's September 11, 2026 Decision/Order and that he was now seeking a judgment of possession and a warrant of eviction "to enforce my lawful occupancy", as well as compensatory damages. The Court signed Petitioner's OSC and also made it returnable October 1, 2026.
The two OSCs were adjourned, first to October 20, 2026 and then to November 16, 2026. In the interim, each party, without counsel, filed additional papers:
• Respondent filed an affirmation in opposition to Petitioner's OSC, arguing that "the Court should consider the full circumstances of my purchase, occupancy, lack of notice, and the present configuration of the property"; reiterating the arguments made in support of his OSC; and requesting that "the court determine the underlying possessory and service issues before ordering restoration or delivery of keys." Attached to Respondent's opposition papers are various documents, including paperwork from his sale of the property he used to own at 2969 Valentine Avenue and his purchase of 647 East 229th Street and proof of his residence at 647 East 229th Street in the form of a Con Edison Bill, a US Postal Service change-of-address notice, and his New York State driver's license.
• Petitioner filed a "Reply Memorandum of Law", arguing that Respondent's own motion papers "establish a textbook illegal lockout, offering no lawful basis to revisit the prior inquest trial hearing"; not only did Respondent fail to restore Petitioner to possession after DHPD lifted the vacate order but Respondent installed additional "heavy-duty mesh and specialized locking hardware" around the premises, in violation of provisions of the New York City Fire Code and the New York State Multiple Dwelling Law; Respondent mischaracterizes Petitioner's occupancy as being limited to a single room, as "the official historical and administrative record" shows that he "maintained full legal dominion over the entire apartment" as of the night before the fire; the DHCR orders support Petitioner's position; the evidence established that what occurred was an illegal lockout, which is strictly prohibited under New York law, citing to RPAPL §§ 711, 768 and 853; and there can be no factual dispute that Petitioner is entitled to an immediate judgment of possession and compensatory damages due to Respondent's "continuous, willful non-compliance" with the court's orders. Attached as Exhibit B1 is a copy of a DHCR "Order Determining Facts or Establishing Rent" dated July 21, 2025 issued in response to a "proceeding to determine the regulatory status" of the apartment filed by the prior owner 647 East 229th St Bronx, LLC. This Order references the Decision/Order issued by this Court under Index # LT-012299-19/BX and a DHCR Rent Administrator Order issued on May 16, 2021 under Docket # IO610009AD; notes that the owner failed to respond to the tenant's submissions; and concludes that the tenant [Petitioner herein, Robert Williams] is entitled to the "rights and protections afforded under the New York State Rent Stabilization Law and Code".
On November 16, 2026 Respondent appeared by newly-retained counsel and, after further argument on the record, the two OSCs were marked "decision reserved".
DISCUSSION
To prevail on a motion to vacate a default under CPLR R 5015(a)(1), the movant must make a showing of a reasonable excuse for the default and a meritorious claim or defense. 979 Second Ave LLC v Yue Wah Chao (227 AD3d 436, 209 NYS3d 397 [1st Dep't 2024]); Adefioye v Volunteers of Am (222 AD2d 246, 634 NYS2d 696 [1st Dep't 1995]). Relief from a default rests within the sound discretion of the motion court, Frenchy's Bar & Grill v United Int'l Ins Co (251 AD2d 177, 675 NYS2d 31 [1st Dep't 1998]), and courts have the inherent power, in the interest of justice, to vacate a prior order, Alvarez v Fiat Realty Corp (157 AD2d 456, 550 NYS2d 825 [1st Dep't 1990]).
Here, in the papers in support of his OSC filed on September 17, 2026 Respondent has asserted facts demonstrating that he has both a reasonable excuse for his failure to appear in court on September 11, 2026 and a meritorious defense to Respondent's claim of illegal lockout. As to his excuse for not appearing in court on September 11, 2026, Respondent's explanation as to his lack of notice and corroborating documentation is a reasonable one: The address Petitioner relied on for service on Respondent of the OSC and Petition commencing this case on August 31, 2026 was no longer Respondent's address at that time: he had sold that building in June 2026 and moved to the subject building in July 2026. Lack of actual notice of a court date is a reasonable excuse for failing to attend. 4168 Brokerage Inc v Reynoso (2024 NY Slip Op 34386[U]), 4 [Sup Ct NY Co 2024, SCJ A Silvera])(granting in part defendant's motion to vacate decision after inquest).
As to a meritorious defense, Respondent asserts that Petitioner should not be restored to possession as the Rent Stabilized unit Petitioner originally rented - an illegal "SRO" unit - no longer exists after the post-fire rehabilitation of the building. This argument finds support in case law such as Gregoretti v 92 Morningside Ave LLC (166 AD3d 466, 466, 89 NYS3d 20, 21 [1st Dep't 2018])(upholding lower court's dismissal of Rent Stabilized tenant's action seeking to be restored to possession of an apartment in a building that was "effectively demolished" by fire); and Devlin v New York State Div of Hous & Cmty Renewal (309 AD2d 191, 194, 764 NYS2d 100 [1st Dep't 2003], lv to app den, 2 NY3d 705, 812 NE2d 1261, 780 NYS2d 311 [2004])(discussing the history of DHCR's "first rent" policy, describing it as "a means of acknowledging that significant alterations might simply eliminate any rational basis for carrying an apartment's rental history forward" and remanding the case to the DHCR for a determination of the tenant's rent overcharge complaint), and see generally Vargas v 112 Suffolk St Apt Corp (66 Misc 3d 1214[A], 120 NYS3d 724 [Civ Ct NY Co 2020]), and cases cited therein. Respondent has raised sufficient questions of fact on the question of "whether the building was so damaged by the fire as to have been 'effectively demolished' ", Quiles v Term Equities (22 AD3d 417, 421, 802 NYS2d 679, 682 [1st Dep't 2005]), to demonstrate a potentially meritorious defense to this proceeding, especially because Petitioner is now arguing that Respondent "mischaracterizes Petitioner's occupancy as being limited to a single room, as 'the official historical and administrative record' shows that he 'maintained full legal dominion over the entire apartment' as of the night before the fire", and that he is entitled to possession of the entire basement/first-floor apartment, not just one SRO on that floor of the building.
The documents submitted by both parties raise questions of fact which can only be determined at trial. Upholding the court's Decision/Order After Inquest on this record likely would be reversible error. See, e.g., Aegis SMB Fund II, LP v Rosenfeld (189 AD3d 472, 137 NYS3d 25 [1st Dep't 2020]); Goncalves v Soho Vill Realty, Inc (47 Misc 3d 76, 77, 9 NYS3d 522, 523 [App Term 1st Dep't 2015]). Further, vacatur of the judgment issued on default after inquest is warranted by the strong public policy in New York State for cases to be heard on their merits. Walton v Perez (231 AD3d 570, 218 NYS3d 341 [1st Dep't 2024]); Velasquez v NYC Transit Auth/MTA (198 AD3d 555, 556, 152 NYS3d 823, 824 [1st Dep't 2021]); Petrovic v Lee (36 Misc 3d 145[A], 959 NYS2d 91 [App Term 1st Dep't 2012]). Appellate courts frequently cite to the fact that "a liberal policy is adopted with respect to opening default judgments in furtherance of justice to the end that the parties may have their day in court to litigate the issues", Raichle, Moore, Banning & Weiss v Commonwealth Fin Corp (14 AD2d 830, 831, 220 NYS2d 619, 621 [4th Dep't 1961]), cited and quoted in, e.g., Liberty Pointe Bank v 75 E 125th St, LLC (95 AD3d 706, 946 NYS2d 26 [1st Dep't 2012]); Sanford v 27-29 W 181st St Ass'n (300 AD2d 250, 251, 753 NYS2d 49, 51 [1st Dep't 2002]); 38 Holding Corp v New York (179 AD2d 486, 487, 578 NYS2d 174, 175 [1st Dep't 1992]); Cappel v RKO Stanley Warner Theaters, Inc (61 AD2d 936, 937, 403 NYS2d 31, 33 [1st Dep't 1978]).
CONCLUSION
Based on the foregoing, it is hereby ORDERED that:
Respondent's Order to Show Cause is granted and the order of dismissal is vacated; AND
Petitioner's Order to Show Cause seeking a judgment of possession is denied, without prejudice to renewal at a future date if appropriate; AND
by December 1, 2026 Respondent shall serve and file via email his Answer to the Petition; AND
the case is restored to the Part T calendar for trial on December 10, 2026 at 9:30 a.m.
This constitutes the Court's Decision and Order, which is being emailed to both parties and to Respondent's newly-retained attorney.
Diane E Lutwak, HCJ
Dated: November 18, 2026
Bronx, New York
Diane E. Lutwak, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Index No. LT-002190-26 /BX
Decided: November 18, 2026
Court: Civil Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)