Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
99 Realty Co. LLC, Petitioner-Landlord, v. Covey; E. AND N'S LLC D/B/A "345 C.", Respondent-Tenants, "JOHN DOE 1-2"; "ABC CORP" Respondent-Undertenant(s).
I. Background
In this commercial landlord-tenant holdover summary proceeding, Petitioner moved by motion seeking a supplemental judgment against Respondents S. T. Covey (hereinafter, "Covey") and E. and N.'s LLC D/B/A 345 C. (hereinafter, "E&N") for its reasonable attorney's fees in the amount of $16,759.02 ("Motion Seq. #4"). Thereafter, Respondents Covey and E&N (hereinafter, collectively, "Respondents") moved by cross-motion seeking an order directing that Petitioner's motion be determined only after a fee hearing or inquest, and that Petitioner's motion be denied as against Respondent Covey individually on the ground that Respondent Covey did not execute the lease agreement in his personal capacity, or in the alternative, to reduce the fee award ("Motion Seq. #5").
By decision and order of this Court, entered on April 21, 2026 (hereinafter, "April 2026 Decision"), this Court denied Petitioner's motion (Motion Seq. #4) without prejudice, and granted Respondents' cross-motion (Motion Seq. #5) solely to the extent of scheduling the matter for an attorney's fee hearing (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 64). The remaining branches of Respondents' cross-motion (Motion Seq. #5) were otherwise denied (id.). This Court further directed Respondents to raise objections to any billing entry in the legal invoices and to inform Petitioner of such objections by August 1, 2026 prior to the attorney's fee hearing (id.).
Thereafter, the parties appeared before this Court for an attorney's fee hearing on August 10, 2026. J. Nadelbach, Esq. (hereinafter, "Nadelbach") from Borah, Goldstein, Altschuler, Nahins & Goidel, P.C. (hereinafter, "Borah Goldstein"), testified on behalf of Petitioner. K. O'Donoghue, Esq. (hereinafter, "O'Donoghue") from O'Donoghue PLLC, testified on behalf of Respondents.
II. Testimonies and Exhibits
i. Testimony of J. Nadelbach, Esq.
During the instant attorney's fees hearing, Petitioner initially requested that a judgment for attorneys' fees and disbursements through July 2026 be awarded in favor of Petitioner and against Respondent in the sum of $21,971.72. Nadelbach introduced into evidence, a copy of the standard retainer agreement made between Borah Goldstein and Petitioner (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 71); the legal invoices billed by Borah Goldstein to Petitioner (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 72); a legal fee chart indicating the hours expended and amount billed as reflected in the legal invoices (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 73); and a copy of Nestor v Britt, 16 Misc 3d 368, 2007 NY Slip Op 27155 (Civ Ct, NY County 2007) (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 74). Nadelbach testified that Petitioner did not receive from Respondents any objections to the legal invoices as directed by this Court's April 2026 Decision.
Upon Respondents' objections that they did not have adequate time to review the foregoing exhibits, which were uploaded to NYSCEF on August 10, 2026, the date of the instant hearing, Petitioner subsequently sought attorney's fees and disbursements through January 31, 2026 in the sum of $16,759.02, which was the original amount of attorney's fees indicated in the motion filed on March 19, 2026 (Motion Seq. #4) (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 48-53). Petitioner requested that the aforementioned sum be awarded in favor of Petitioner and against Respondents in light of Respondents' failure to comply with this Court's April 2026 Decision.
Nadelbach testified that he was admitted to the New York State bar in 2016 and began his legal career at Ingram Yuzek Gainen Carrol & Bertolotti, LLP in their landlord tenant department; that he joined Borah Goldstein in 2018, where he was elevated to a partner in 2021; that he had billed 38.50 hours at an hourly rate of $360.00 per hour for the legal services rendered through January 31, 2026, and that his work had consisted of drafting and preparing the motion papers, appearing for court appearances and handling correspondence with the client and the opposing counsel. Nadelbach further testified that he drafted and prepared an opposition to Respondents' motion to dismiss and Petitioner's cross-motion for summary judgment, which consisted of a twenty-five (25) page memorandum of law, a client affirmation, an attorney affirmation and six (6) exhibits, as well as a reply in further support of Petitioner's cross-motion for summary judgment.
Nadelbach continued to testify that he worked on the instant proceeding together with David B. Rosenbaum, Esq. (hereinafter, "Rosenbaum"); that Rosenbaum was admitted to the New York State bar in 1985 and was a co-managing partner with Borah Goldstein; that Rosenbaum had worked in real estate law for about forty-two (42) years, served as an arbitrator in small claims court, and lectured and given CLE courses for NYCLA; and that Rosenbaum oversaw the instant proceeding and had billed about five (5) hours at an hourly rate of $500.00 per hour and $510.00 per hour for the legal services rendered through January 31, 2026.
Nadelbach concluded that Borah Goldstein's billing rates were reasonable and customary within the industry and made reference to Nestor v Britt, a decision and order of Hon. Gerald Lebovits, dated April 23, 2007 in support of such claim (see Nestor v Britt 16 Misc 3d 368, 2007 NY Slip Op 27155 [Civ Ct, NY County 2007]; NYSCEF Doc. No. 74). Nadelbach testified that the said 2007 decision from almost twenty years ago held that it was reasonable to charge about $350.00 per hour for a junior partner and more than $500.00 per hour for a senior partner; that the hourly rate charged by Borah Goldstein in the instant proceeding was similar to the rate found to be reasonable by Hon. Gerald Lebovits in his 2007 decision. According to Nadelbach, even accounting for inflation, Borah Goldstein could reasonably have charged an even higher hourly rate. Nadelbach testified that discounted rates were provided to Petitioner, and that the usual hourly rate for Nadelbach was $450.00 per hour and close to $600.00 per hour for Rosenbaum.
In opposing Respondents' contention that Borah Goldstein had billed an excessive number of hours for a proceeding where there were no disputed facts, Nadelbach testified that while the instant holdover proceeding concerned an expiration of a lease where the legal issues were indeed clear-cut, Respondents' characterization of the proceeding as such was, in Nadelbach's view, disingenuous. Nadelbach testified that Respondents had previously moved seeking dismissal of the proceeding, to which Petitioner responded by filing a cross-motion for summary judgment. According to Nadelbach, Respondents could not initially seek dismissal of the proceeding and once said position proved unsuccessful, subsequently characterize the instant matter as having been straightforward and clear-cut from the outset. In addition, Nadelbach alleged that Respondents could have simply stipulated to vacate the subject premises, as is customary in the majority of holdover proceedings where the tenant stays past the expiration of their lease, rather than to litigate the matter through a motion to dismiss and forcing Petitioner to incur legal fees.
Nadelbach further testified that Borah Goldstein had never double billed as alleged by Respondents and that it was reasonable for a senior partner to oversee proceedings. In addition, Nadelbach testified that he worked primarily in Borah Goldstein's Commercial Division and that he did not handle run-of-the-mill holdover proceedings as alleged by Respondents.
ii. Testimony of K. O'Donoghue, Esq.
O'Donoghue testified that objections to the legal invoices had already been raised in Respondents' cross-motion, filed March 29, 2026 (Motion Seq. #5), and that those objections were set forth in detail in NYSCEF Doc. No. 60. O'Donoghue further testified that he had understood the April 2026 Decision to mean that he need not raise those objections again prior to August 1, 2026 as he had already done so in Respondents' cross-motion (Motion Seq. #5).
O'Donoghue testified that he did not dispute Nadelbach's ability nor hourly billing rates, but rather, the number of hours billed; and that an experienced attorney as Nadelbach should not require billing of 38.50 hours for a "routine holdover" like the instant summary proceeding, where there were no disputed facts and the outcome was legally clear. According to O'Donoghue, most of the filings were effectively templates which Borah Goldstein, an established law firm, had used for years in similar litigation. O'Donoghue testified that Borah Goldstein and Nadelbach, in particular, currently handled approximately two hundred similar proceedings in New York County alone, and a few hundred additional proceedings throughout the other New York City Courts; and that he himself was a solo practitioner, but yet he had only billed 7.2 hours for the instant proceeding, compared to the 38.50 hours billed by Nadelbach.
O'Donoghue further testified that Rosenbaum billed an additional 4.77 hours, which was duplicative work as having a senior managing partner supervise and review papers prepared by Nadelbach, a partner-level attorney with nearly a decade of real estate ligation experience, added unnecessary cost without adding commensurate value.
In support of such claims, O'Donoghue introduced the following: a copy of a timesheet detailing the number of hours billed by O'Donoghue PLLC to Respondents (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 68); case search results on NYSCEF for cases handled by Nadelbach in New York County (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 69); and bar graphs showing the number of cases handled by Nadelbach and Rosenbaum in New York County and the remaining New York City boroughs (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 70).
III. Discussion
"The courts have the inherent power to supervise the legal fees charged for services and regulate the practice of law" (see Matter of Thomas B. v Lydia D., 120 AD3d 446, 446 [1st Dept 2014] [internal citation omitted]). In determining reasonable attorney's fees, the court must consider "the difficulty of the issues and the skill required to resolve them; the lawyers' experience, ability and reputation; the time and labor required; the amount involved and benefit resulting to the client from the services; the customary fee charged for similar services; the contingency or certainty of compensation; the results obtained and the responsibility involved" (see Morgan & Finnegan v Howe Chem. Co., 210 AD2d 62, 63 [1st Dept 1994] [internal citations omitted]).
Here, Petitioner alleged that Nadelbach, a partner with Borah Goldstein, expended 38.50 hours at an hourly rate of $360.00 per hour, and that Rosenbaum, a co-managing partner with Borah Goldstein, expended 4.75 hours at an hourly rate of $500.00 per hour and 0.02 hours at an hourly rate of $510.00 per hour for the legal services rendered through January 31, 2026. The disbursements associated with the instant proceeding were in the sum of $422.02.
Based on Nadelbach's testimony and the proffered exhibits, the Court finds the hourly rates of Nadelbach and Rosenbaum to be reasonable. Further, contrary to Respondents' contention, the Court finds that the number of hours billed by Borah Goldstein were neither excessive nor unnecessary. Borah Goldstein demonstrated that it prepared the notice of petition, the petition, an opposition to Respondents' motion to dismiss and Petitioner's cross-motion for summary judgment, and a reply in further support of Petitioner's cross-motion for summary judgment, appeared for the court appearances and handled correspondence with Petitioner and the opposing counsel. The Court is unpersuaded by Respondents' mostly speculative argument that Nadelbach could not reasonably have expended 38.50 hours in connection with the instant proceeding due to his handling of multiple cases across New York City. Moreover, the Court finds that Rosenbaum's billing of 4.77 hours did not constitute duplicative work as it is reasonable to expect that Rosenbaum, a co-managing partner for Borah Goldstein with the responsibility of overseeing the firm's landlord tenant cases, would review the work prepared by Nadelbach, a junior partner (see Nestor v Britt, 16 Misc 3d 368, 2007 NY Slip Op 27155 [Civ Ct, NY County 2007] [holding that a senior partner's review of a junior partner's work was not duplicative work]). In light of the foregoing, the Court finds that Petitioner established a prima facie entitlement for attorney's fees and disbursements in the amount of $16,759.02.
Notwithstanding the absence of sufficient factual basis to object to particular billable entries, Respondents failed to comply with this Court's April 2026 Decision, which directed Respondents to raise objections to any billing entry stated in Borah Goldstein's legal invoices to Petitioner by August 1, 2026 (see NYSCEF Doc. No. 64). Accordingly, Petitioner's prayer for attorney's fee in the amount of $16,759.02, disbursements included through January 31, 2026, is granted.
IV. Order
Accordingly, it is hereby:
ORDERED that the Clerk of the Court is directed to enter judgment in favor of Petitioner and against Respondents Covey and E. and N.'s LLC D/B/A 345 C., jointly and severally, in the amount of $16,759.02; and it is further
ORDERED that Petitioner shall serve a copy of this Decision and Order upon Respondents Covey and E. and N.'s LLC D/B/A 345 C. with notice of entry within thirty (30) days thereof.
This constitutes the DECISION and ORDER of the Court.
Dated: October 5, 2026
County of New York
Hon. Wendy CHANGYONG Li
Judge of the Civil Court
Wendy Changyong Li, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Index No. LT-311316-25 /NY
Decided: October 05, 2026
Court: Civil Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)