Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Riverbay Corp, Petitioner/Landlord v. Charles Alleyne, JOHN DOE, JANE DOE, Respondent/Tenant
Recitation of the papers considered in review of Movant's Motions, as required by CPLR 2219(A). NYSCEF Doc. No. 11-22, 27-39, 40-43
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The instant holdover proceeding initiates by the filing of a notice of petition and petition on March 12, 2026. See NYSCEF # 1-4.
The petition attaches a Notice To Quit and Termination of License, addressed to Charles Alleyne, John Doe, and Jane Doe which states in part:
"The facts of this matter are that the original tenant and proprietary lessee of the Apartment, Edna E. Alleyne, passed away on March 21, 2022. No one in possession of the Apartment surrendered possession to the landlord. Charles Alleyne thereafter applied for succession rights, which application was denied in writing dated February 3, 2022. An appeal was taken from that denial, which was denied in writing dated February 29, 2024, a copy of which is annexed hereto for reference. Upon information and belief, CHARLES ALLEYNE is in possession pursuant to license granted by Edna E. Alleyne. "John Doe" and "Jane Doe" are in occupancy pursuant to license from either Edna E. Alleyne or from CHARLES ALLEYNE, whose possessory rights are hereby terminated." See NYSCEF # 1, Pg. 4 of 16.
Respondent then retains counsel who files an answer and a demand for a bill of particulars.
Respondent now files a motion to dismiss
RESPONDENT'S MOTION TO DISMISS
Specifically, Respondent moves because of Petitioner's failure to serve the mandatory Violence Against Women's Act (VAWA), failure to inform Respondent of his right to meet with Petitioner within ten days of service of the notice of termination, Dismissing the petition for failure to inform Respondent of his right to request reasonable accommodation, failure to serve the notice of termination, and compelling Petitioner to comply with Respondent's demand for a Bill of Particulars. See NYSCEF # 11-22.
PETITIONER'S CROSS MOTION
Petitioner cross moves to deny Respondent's motion to dismiss, and pursuant to CPLR 3025 (b) for leave to amend the Petition to annex the affidavit of service of the ten-day notice to quit and termination of license.
DISCUSSION
Turning first to Respondent's first basis to dismiss: the VAWA notice.
Respondent's counsel writes: "Put simply, a landlord whose building falls under one of the enumerated programs, including a federal program designed to serve low-to-moderate-income tenants, is obligated to comply with the VAWA protections set forth in 24 C.F.R. 5.2005. The protections set forth in 24 CFR 5.2005 include a number of notices that a covered housing provider must provide to each of its tenants." See NYSCEF # 14, Pg. 7 of 17.
"Here, the building where Respondent resides is subject to regulatory agreement between HUD and Petitioner." "Consequently, the building is part of a "covered housing program" under 34 U.S. Code 12491 (a)(3)(P). Petitioner therefore must comply with the notice requirements under VAWA." See NYSCEF # 14, Pg. 9 of 17.
Petitioner further writes that Section P allows the agency to identify other programs, and a chart on Respondent further writes that the licensees are "equally entitled to receive the VAWA notice [,]" and that "[w]hile Petitioner identified Respondent as a licensee pursuant to DHCR's denial of his appeal for succession, Respondent is still entitled to a VAWA notice as an occupant [.]" See NYSCEF # 14, Pg. 9 of 17.
PETITIONER'S CROSS MOTION
In Petitioner's cross motion, Petitioner writes that a "Federal mortgage, standing alone, does not make a property a covered housing program; the property must fall within one of the enumerated programs. Riverbay's mortgage is insured under Section 207/223 (f) pursuant to Section 223 (a)(7) of the National Housing Act." "None of those sections is among the covered housing programs listed in 34 U.S.C. 12491 (a)(3) or identified by HUD. Mortgage insurance under Section 223 is not rental assistance, and it does not bring a property within a covered housing program. Riverbay, moreover, is a Mitchell-Lama development organized under Article II of the Private Housing Finance Law and supervised by DHCR. It is a creature of state law, not a federal housing program. The catch-all in 34 U.S.C. 12491 (a)(3)(P) reaches only other Federal Housing programs, and HUD has not identified Mitchell-Lama developments or Section 223 mortgages as covered." See NYSCEF # 30, Pg. 3 of 14.
Petitioner further writes that HUD issues a chart that does not add mortgages under Section 223 of the National Housing Act to Section P. See NYSCEF # 30, Pg. 6 of 14.
"Respondent's status is not an open question in this proceeding. He applied to succeed to the shareholder interest in the apartment; DHCR determined that he did not qualify for occupancy as a remaining family member; and DHCR denied his administrative appeal by order mailed February 29, 2024." "Respondent never commenced a proceeding under CPLR Article 78 to review that determination, and the time within which to do so expired long ago." "Thus, it has been determined that respondent is no longer an application and does not qualify to be a tenant. As a result, VAWA does not apply." See NYSCEF # 30, Pg. 9 of 14.
In reply, Respondent writes that "[t]he full title of the Regulatory Agreement is "U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT REGULATORY AGREEMENT FOR MULTIFAMILIY PROJECTS UNDER SECTION 207, 220, 221 (d)(3), 221 (d)(4), 223 (a)(7), 223 (f) and 231 OF THE NATIONAL HOUSING ACT, AS AMENDED." "This Regulatory Agreement clearly brings the subject building under HUD's rules and regulations as to require Petitioner to provide VAWA notices to tenants facing eviction. Indeed, the National Act framework, the Regulatory Agreement of the subject building, Petitioner's bylaws, and the congressional intent of the Violence Against Women Act notice requirement make clear that the subject building is precisely the kind of project that Congress intended to be captured in its catch-all category. The list of "covered housing programs" under section (P) of the VAWA statute includes an open-ended category for unenumerated programs. 34 U.S. Code 12491 (a)(3). This category captures "any other Federal housing programs providing affordable to low-and moderate-income persons by means of restricted rents or rental assistance, or more generally providing affordable housing opportunities, as identified by the appropriate agency through regulations, notices or any other means" (emphasis added). 34 US Code 12491 (a)(3)(P)." See NYSCEF # 41, Pg. 2 of 10.
Further, Respondent writes: "Respondent is the grandson of the deceased of record has lived in the apartment both as a child and permanently as an adult since 2011." "Those facts are undisputed. Moreover, Respondent has properly brought to the Court's attention that the federal rules include family member occupants in the definition "Tenant." As this definition has been judicially recognized as dictating the application of the VAWA notice, such definition governs the instant proceeding." See NYSCEF # 41, Pg. 8 of 10.
DISCUSSION
The relevant portions of 24 CFR § 5.2005(a) of VAWA state:
"A covered housing provider must provide to each of its applicants and each of its tenants the notice of occupancy rights and the certification form as described in this section: ... the notice required by (a)(1)(i) of this section and certification form required by paragraph (a)(1)(ii) of this section must be provided to an applicant or tenant no later than at each of the following times: (i) At the time the applicant is denied assistance or admission under a covered housing program; (ii) At the time the individual is provided assistance or admission under the covered housing program; (iii) with any notification of eviction or notification of termination of assistance ..."
Failure to include the notice in a petition, will result in dismissal. See Rahman vs. Lewis, 84 Misc 3d 720, 217 N.Y.S.3d 830 (Civil. Ct. Bronx. Cty. 2024); Bradhurst Assocs. Vs. Swinton, 2026 NY Slip Op 32042 (U) (Civil. Ct. NY Cty. 2026); Cross Bronx Preserv. LLC vs. Delgado, NY Slip Op 31036 (U) (Civil. Ct. Bronx. Cty. 2025) ("The failure to service the VAWA notice, and failure to serve a proper predicate notice are fatal defects.")
In deciding Respondent's motion and Petitioner's cross motion, the fundamental question to be answered is whether the subject premises are a covered housing program. Petitioner does state that the subject building has a Federal connection, in that the building has a HUD-insured mortgage under Section 207/223 (f). Petitioner seeks to distinguish — differentiate, the insured mortgage from other Federal programs (connections) in that it is not a rental subsidy. Respondent, however asserts that the connection between the Federal government and the subject premises is more intertwined than Petitioner's HUD mortgage. Respondent points to the regulatory agreement filed between the Petitioner and HUD. The regulatory agreement imposes the National Housing Act: 207, 220, 221 (d)(3), 221 (d)(4), 223 (a)(7), 223 (f) and 231. That the HUD-insured mortgage is not included in the catchall, is relevant, but Petitioner fails to properly rebut the connection between Petitioner and HUD, per the regulatory agreement. Moreover, the Petitioner's bylaws include a HUD provisions section. Further, the chart, in support of its cross motion is not current.
Whether Respondent qualifies as a tenant entitled to the VAWA notice, does not require an analysis of the status of a remaining family member grievance. Boulevard Together Master Tenant vs. Elvis Fermin, LT 302021-24/KI (Civ. Ct. Kings. County.) Respondent is evidently occupying the dwelling unit, which is part of the HUD definition of tenant. See 24 C.F.R. 5.504 (b), Williamsburg Pact LLC vs. Robin Doe, LT 305948-24/KI (Civ. Ct. Kings. County.) Respondent is thus a tenant pursuant to CFR, and requires service of the VAWA. Failure to do is fatal to the petition.
As such, Respondent's motion to dismiss is granted, and the petition is dismissed. Petitioner's cross motion is denied. The remainder of Respondent's motion is deemed moot.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons stated above, it is hereby ORDERED that Respondent's motion is GRANTED (Seq # 1) and the proceeding is dismissed. Petitioner's cross motion (Seq # 2) is DENIED.
Hon. Alberto M. Gonzalez, HCJ
Dated: October 5, 2026
Bronx, New York
Alberto M. Gonzalez, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: L&T: 309069-26 /BX
Decided: October 05, 2026
Court: Civil Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)