Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
BUILDING 77 QALICB, INC., Petitioner(s), v. JMFW PRINTING, INC., a business corporation organized under the laws of the State of North Carolina; “XYZ CORP,” Respondent(s)
Respondent JMFW Printing, Inc. moves to vacate the default judgment of possession and warrant of eviction and to dismiss this commercial nonpayment proceeding for lack of personal jurisdiction. Following a traverse hearing, this court finds that petitioner established proper service of the notice of petition and petition pursuant to RPAPL 735 by a preponderance of the credible evidence. Accordingly, the traverse is overruled and respondent's motion is denied.
Pursuant to CPLR 2219(a), this court has considered the papers previously recited in the court's decision and order dated May 22, 2026 (NYSCEF Doc No. 24), petitioner's post-traverse affirmation dated August 5, 2026 (NYSCEF Doc No. 28), respondent's post-traverse memorandum dated August 17, 2026 (NYSCEF Doc No. 30), and petitioner's reply affirmation dated August 19, 2026 (NYSCEF Doc No. 31), together with the testimony and exhibits received at the traverse hearing.
Procedural history
This proceeding concerns commercial premises at 141 Flushing Avenue, Building 77, Suite 507, Brooklyn, New York. Respondent failed to answer or appear, and a judgment of possession and warrant of eviction were issued on March 2, 2026. The warrant was executed on April 21, 2026. Respondent thereafter obtained an order to show cause seeking vacatur and restoration to possession.
By decision and order dated May 22, 2026, Judge Ellen Edwards granted respondent's order to show cause solely to the extent of directing a traverse hearing. Judge Edwards determined that respondent's sworn submissions raised factual questions concerning the process server's description of the premises and the mailing of the initiating papers. That determination required an evidentiary hearing; it did not establish that service was defective. The traverse hearing was held in this court on July 21 and July 29, 2026, after which the parties submitted post-hearing briefs.
Analysis
In general, a process server's affidavit constitutes a prima facie showing of proper service. Trovato v Galaxy Sanitation Servs. of NY, Inc., 171 AD3d 830, 831 (2d Dept. 2019) See F&V Realty Corp. v. Deck Flatbush-1014, LLC, 232 N.Y.S.3d 346, 346 (App. Term 2d Dept. 2025). Furthermore, “a properly executed affidavit of service raises a presumption that a proper mailing occurred, and a mere denial of receipt is not enough to rebut this presumption.” Kihl v. Pfeffer, 94 NY2d 118, 122 (1999); Forest Hills S. Owners, Inc. v Ishida, 33 Misc 3d 141(A), 141A (App. Term 2d Dept. 2011). However, once this prima facie showing is rebutted, the petitioner must establish personal jurisdiction at a traverse hearing by a preponderance of the evidence, Matter of Erika G. v Jason B., 184 AD3d 639, 640 (2d Dept. 2020); Godwin v Upper Room Baptist Church, 175 AD3d 1500, 1501 (2d Dept 2019); Mizerek v Rosenfeld, 162 AD3d 1005, 1007 (2d Dept. 2018). The burden of proof “rests at all times” upon the petitioner; it does not shift during the traverse hearing. Matter of Erika G., supra, 184 AD3d at 640. This court must therefore determine whether petitioner affirmatively established proper service on the hearing record.
RPAPL 735(1) authorizes conspicuous-place service of the notice of petition and petition only after “reasonable application” to deliver the papers personally or to an appropriate person at the premises has failed. Avgush v. Berrahu, 17 Misc 3d 85, 87 (App. Term 2d Dept. 2007). A lower level of effort is required to support a finding of “reasonable application” than is required to show “due diligence” under CPLR 308 (4) - a “reasonable application” only requires that there is “at least a reasonable expectation of success in finding a person on the premises to whom delivery may be made.” Fang Realty Corp. v. Prime Six, Inc., 2022 NY Misc. LEXIS 7669, *2 (App. Term 2d Dept. 2022); Joseph v. Lyu, 2018 NY Misc. LEXIS 599, *2 (App. Term 2d Dept. 2018). “At least two attempts at personal service are needed to satisfy the ‘reasonable application’ standard.” 809-811 Kings Highway, LLC v. Pulse Laser Skin Care, 2009 NY Slip Op 52121(U), 25 Misc 3d 130(A), 130A (App. Term 2d Dept. 2009). The conspicuous-place service method also requires timely certified or registered and regular first-class mailings. Avgush, supra, 17 Misc 3d at 87. The statutory acts must be completed; actual notice cannot replace an omitted act. George Doulaveris & Son, Inc. v P.J. 37 Food Corp., 39 Misc 3d 1, 3-4 (App Term, 2d Dept. 2013).
In addition to testifying regarding the manner in which service of process was effectuated, a process server must bring to the hearing all records in their possession “relating to the matter at issue,” and “where the process server is licensed, he or she also shall bring the license to the court.” 22 NYCRR § 208.29. They must also include bring “records from a mobile device that utilizes software that ‘makes an electronic record of the location where, and the time and date when,’ process is being served or attempted to be served using GPS ‘technology or Assisted—Global Positioning System (“A—GPS”) technology.’ ” (6 RCNY § 2-233b[a][1][I]); Elliot Place Est. LLC v. Williams, 2026 NY Misc. LEXIS 5161, *2 (Civ. Ct. Bronx Co. 2026).
This court finds that the process server Assmet Abderrahman (“process server” or “server”) satisfied the documentary-production requirements of 22 NYCRR § 208.29. In addition to testifying about the manner in which service was attempted and effectuated, he brought his process server's license and all records in his possession relating to this matter. Those records included the service logs admitted as petitioner's Exhibits C-1 and C-2 and the corresponding photographs and electronic location records for October 7 and October 9, 2025. The electronic records identified the proceeding and premises and contained geographic coordinates and device and cellular time stamps, documenting the location, date, and time of the recordings contemplated by 6 RCNY § 2-233b(a)(1)(i). Accordingly, the server produced the records necessary for the court to evaluate his testimony and respondent's challenge to service.
Respondent emphasized that the process server first attended to an unrelated service on the fourth floor on October 7. That circumstance does not contradict his testimony that he thereafter proceeded to Suite 507 on the fifth floor. Having considered the testimony and documentary evidence, the court credits the server's account of that sequence. Resolving questions of credibility is the province of the hearing court. See, Freud v St. Agnes Cathedral School, 64 AD3d 678, 679 (2d Dept 2009).
Respondent challenges the process server's compliance with 6 RCNY § 2-233b because the GPS recordings were made outside Building 77 rather than at the door of Suite 507. The process server testified that on October 7 and October 9, 2025, he attempted to use his service application inside the building but could not obtain a signal. He therefore took ordinary photographs inside and, after leaving the building, took photographs through the application when a signal became available. Subdivision (a)(2)(i) requires an electronic record of location, date, and time immediately after each attempted or effected service. A recording made before service is noncompliant; one made more than five minutes afterward creates a rebuttable presumption of noncompliance. The regulation also anticipates unavailable reception. It requires cellular-triangulation capability when GPS is unavailable and, when neither signal is available, software that automatically adds the location, date, and time when reception returns (6 RCNY § 2-233b[a][1][ii]—[iii]). Thus, the absence of an indoor GPS signal does not, standing alone, establish a violation.
Plaintiff's Exhibits C-1 and C-2 identify the process server's name and license number, unique file identifier, the process server's and agency's license numbers, notations that service was not effected, the title of the proceeding, the intended recipient's name, the date and time of attempted service, the service address (Building 77 and Suite 507), and the court and county. Exhibits A-1 and B-1 contain photographs of the front entrance to the subject building, geographic coordinates, and device and cellular times stamps.
For October 7, 2025, Exhibit C-1 records the attempted service at 14:13, which corresponds with the stamps on Exhibit A-1, a photograph depicting the outside entrance to Building 77, containing a device timestamp of 14:13:00 and a cellular timestamp of 14:12:55. For October 9, 2025, Exhibit C-2 records service at 10:25, which corresponds with Exhibit B-1, another photograph depicting the outside entrance. Exhibit B-1 contains a cellular time stamp of 10:25:48 and a device timestamp of 10:25:51. The October 9 entries also state “No signal in building,” corroborating the server's explanation for obtaining the location recording outside.
This court credits the process server's testimony that he proceeded to Suite 507 on each occasion, attempted to obtain a signal inside, and obtained the exterior GPS photographs after returning outside. The differences of several seconds between the device and network time stamps do not establish that the recordings preceded service. Those time stamps reflect separate time sources; they do not independently establish when the server knocked on the suite door or affixed the papers.
The evidence also does not establish that either electronic recording occurred more than five minutes after the relevant service attempt. Accordingly, the court does not apply the rebuttable presumption of noncompliance.
The exterior coordinates corroborate the server's presence at Building 77. His presence at the suite door and the acts performed there were established by his credited testimony considered together with the photographs and service records. In 600 W. 218th St. Assoc. LLC v Proano (84 Misc 3d 1025, 1031—1032 (Civ Ct, NY County 2024)), the court similarly considered exterior GPS information together with the server's records and detailed testimony in finding proper service. The court recognized that GPS connections were routinely lost in elevators. Id. That decision supports evaluating the evidence as a whole; it does not dispense with the regulation's requirements concerning the timing and operation of the recording device.
The record nevertheless does not establish whether the process server's application used cellular triangulation when GPS was unavailable or automatically added location information to a record initiated inside when reception returned. The record does not establish compliance with the fallback-recording requirements of 6 RCNY § 2-233b(a)(1)(ii)—(iii). However, the absence of GPS records at a traverse hearing does not necessarily defeat proof of service. See, Elliot Place Est. LLC v. Williams, 2026 NY Slip Op 31927[U], 2026 NY Misc. LEXIS 5161, *3 (Civ. Ct. Bronx Co. 2026) (although the absence of GPS records would not necessarily defeat proof of service, that omission, combined with substantial credibility concerns, warranted dismissal there). Accordingly, this court rejects respondent's contention that obtaining the GPS recordings outside Building 77 rendered service defective. Although complete technical compliance with § 2-233b has not been established, the asserted GPS deficiencies do not, on this record, warrant rejecting the server's account or sustaining the traverse. Rather, the determination of whether service satisfied RPAPL 735 rests on the proof of the service attempts, affixing, and mailing.
The server's two visits occurred on different weekdays, one in the afternoon at approximately 2:13 pm, and the other in the morning at 10:25 am, during ordinary business hours. Those circumstances satisfy the “reasonable-application” requirement. See, 159 W. 23rd LLC v Spa Ciel De NY Corp., 2020 NY Slip Op 50122(U), 2020 NY Misc. LEXIS 400, *1 (App. Term 2d Dept. 2020) (two attempts to personally serve corporate tenant during normal business hours, specifically at 4:41 p.m. and the next morning at 10:10 a.m., before conspicuous service was effected was sufficient to satisfy the reasonable application requirement of RPAPL 735); 809-811 Kings Highway, LLC v Pulse Laser Skin Care, 25 Misc 3d 130[A], 2009 NY Slip Op 52121[U], *1-2 (App Term, 2d Dept, 2009) (upholding attempts at 1:45 p.m. and 10:05 a.m. on separate business days). Having credited the server's testimony that he gained access to the suite door and attempted service there on both occasions, the court finds that his failure additionally to ask building security to telephone respondent did not render those efforts unreasonable.
Modi Realty, Inc. v Sambula-Colon (85 Misc 3d 138[A], 2025 NY Slip Op 50509[U] [App Term, 2d Dept, 2025]) and Joseph v Lyu (58 Misc 3d 159[A], 2018 NY Slip Op 50250[U] [App Term, 2d Dept, 2018]) do not compel a different result. In Modi Realty, the server acknowledged that he expected to find no one at the premises, and the attempts preceded the business's operating hours. In Joseph, the landlord knew that no business had ever opened at the premises. Here, the evidence does not establish that the attempts were made outside respondent's known operating hours or with knowledge that no recipient could reasonably be found.
Koren Benbow, respondent's principal, testified that she was absent when the attempts occurred. That absence limits her ability to contradict the server's account of events at the door. The badge-access records are consistent with that absence. This court does not treat those records as proof that service occurred, that respondent actually saw the posted papers, or that respondent bore the burden of disproving service. The finding of proper affixing rests on petitioner's affirmative proof.
This court has also considered the affidavit's description of a door to the right of the elevator and the testimony concerning the additional hallway travel and turn necessary to reach Suite 507. The description is incomplete as a set of directions. Nevertheless, considered with the server's explanation and identification of the photographs, that imprecision does not persuade this court that he visited or affixed the papers to a different suite. This court gives greater weight to the fifth-floor floor plan marked as petitioner's Exhibit F, the credited testimony identifying the actual entrance, and the photographs of the posting than to the affidavit's abbreviated directional description.
Mailing and the Kent Avenue address
Douglas Philip (“mailing witness”) testified that he prepared the mailings and took them to the post office, and identified the postal receipts and certificates of mailing. This court credits that testimony, considered together with petitioner's exhibit D, consisting of stamped USPS certified mail receipts and certificates of mailing, as establishing that copies of the notice of petition and petition were mailed on October 9, 2025, to JMFW Printing, Inc. at 141 Flushing Avenue, Building 77, Suite 507 on the Fifth Floor, Brooklyn, New York 11205, by certified mail and by regular first-class mail. The mailings thus followed the affixing of the notice of petition and petition on the same day.
The mailing witness admitted that certified-mail number 9589071052702352221932, although included in his affidavit, was not used. That admission diminishes the affidavit's reliability and warrants scrutiny of the remaining evidence. No evidentiary weight is given to the unused number as proof of any mailing. Nevertheless, this court credits the separately supported proof of the certified mailing to respondent at Suite 507, associated with the number 9589071052702352221925, and prepaid regular first class mail. A deficiency in one aspect of a witness's account does not require rejection of the testimony in its entirety; the fact finder may credit some portions while rejecting others. Scalogna v Osipov, 117 AD3d 934, 935 (2d Dept 2014); O'Connor v. Soc'y Pass Inc., 2026 NY Slip Op 31419(U), 2026 NY Misc. LEXIS 2765, *5 (Sup. Ct. NY Co. 2026)). This court has considered the identified deficiencies in weighing the evidence and finds the remaining testimony and corroborating records reliable. The inaccuracy concerning one number does not, on this record, establish that those separately proven mailings did not occur.
Defense counsel argued in his post-traverse brief that petitioner's failure to mail the papers to 965 Kent Avenue constituted a separate defect in service under RPAPL § 735(1)(b), which provides that service shall be made upon a corporation “at the property sought to be recovered,” and where the corporation's principal office or principal place of business is elsewhere, written information of that location within the state requires additional mailings. If petitioner lacks that information but has written information of another office or place of business within the state, the statute likewise requires additional mailings to such a location.
The evidence did not establish that the Kent Avenue address was a separate office or place of business of JMFW of which petitioner had the written information contemplated by RPAPL 735(1)(b). Respondent's memorandum asserts conditionally that Department of State records would establish the necessary corporate connection, but those records were not introduced at the hearing. This court further notes that respondent had an opportunity at the traverse hearing to submit evidence as to this additional mailing issue, but failed to do so. This court will not consider facts that are dehors the hearing record. See, Tri State Flood, Inc. v. Wet Out Now Cleaning & Restoration, LLC, 2021 NY Misc. LEXIS 6699, *4 (App. Term 2d Dept. 2021) (“we do not consider any materials that are dehors the record”).
The USPS tracking entry for number 1925 reports delivery to a front desk, reception area, or mail room in Brooklyn, ZIP code 11205, but does not identify a street address or addressee. However, this court found the mailing witness’ testimony credible, which was corroborated by the stamped USPS certified mail receipts and certificates of mailing in exhibit D. The general delivery notation does not contradict that evidence.
RPAPL 735 requires proof of the prescribed mailings, not a signature from respondent's principal or tracking confirmation that each item was carried to the suite. “Service by mail is complete upon mailing regardless of delivery.” Spangenberg v. Chaloupka, 229 AD2d 482, 483 (2d Dept. 1996). See, Cit Bank N.A. v. Schiffman, 36 NY3d 550, 556 (2021) (“this Court has long recognized a party can establish that a notice or other document was sent through evidence of actual mailing (e.g., an affidavit of mailing or service)”).
Vacatur and restoration to possession
Petitioner established service in compliance with RPAPL 735. Accordingly, respondent's motion to vacate the default judgment of possession and warrant of eviction and to dismiss the proceeding for lack of personal jurisdiction is denied pursuant to CPLR 5015(a)(4). The denial rests on petitioner's proof of proper service, not on respondent's rent arrears or its failure to establish an excuse for default. Neither a reasonable excuse nor a meritorious defense is required to obtain vacatur for lack of personal jurisdiction. Fountain Terrace Owners, Inc. v Balic, 59 Misc 3d 136[A], 2018 NY Slip Op 50519[U], *2 (App Term, 2d Dept. 2018). Although execution of the warrant does not foreclose restoration to possession under RPAPL 749(3), respondent has established no basis for that relief on this application.
Conclusion
Accordingly, it is ORDERED that the traverse is overruled; and it is further
ORDERED that respondent JMFW Printing, Inc.’s motion to vacate the default judgment of possession and warrant of eviction, to dismiss the petition for lack of personal jurisdiction, and to be restored to possession is denied; and it is further
ORDERED that any interim stay imposed in connection with respondent's application is vacated upon service of a copy of this decision and order with notice of entry.
This constitutes the decision and order of the court.
Tehilah H. Berman, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Index No. LT-326390-25 /KI
Decided: October 29, 2026
Court: Civil Court, City of New York,
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)