Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Aryel Demirdag, Claimant, v. Alexia Schapira, Defendant.
Claimant brought this small claim for breach of contract to recoup travel costs associated with a trip from Istanbul, in the Republic of Türkiye to New York City for the purpose of visiting her grandson. A non-jury trial began on April 8, 2026, however, Claimant, who is a native Turkish speaker, did not have various exhibits translated into English. The Court adjourned the trial to give Claimant an opportunity to have those documents translated. Claimant provided the translated documents at the continued trial that was completed on April 29, 2026. Both parties testified. Ms. Sibel Benmayor provided Turkish-to-English translation for both portions of the trial.
BACKGROUND
Claimant testified that she reached out to Defendant seeking to visit her grandson, Defendant's son. Defendant agreed to the visit and it was scheduled for February 21, 2025 (see Claimant's exhibit 2a). However, due to inclement weather, the meeting was rescheduled. At the time, Claimant was caring for a loved one in Türkiye. The parties arranged to have a meeting between Claimant and her grandson on February 25, 2025. Claimant flew to New York on February 25, 2025 and flew back to Türkiye on March 21, 2025. Clamant testified that the sole purpose of the trip was to see her grandson. On cross-examination, Claimant admitted that she stayed with her son but visiting him was not the purpose of her trip.
Defendant and Claimant's son are married but do not live together. Defendant testified that she and Claimant's son are embroiled in a tumultuous and emotionally charged ongoing dispute about dissolving their marriage and custody of their child. Defendant reported that she and her son have been the subject of threats of abuse and kidnapping by Claimant's son. Defendant also testified that she's been the victim of several meritless lawsuits brought by Claimant and various members of Claimant's family, including Claimant's son. Among them are civil actions and a Petition brought by Claimant in Family Court seeking an order permitting her to visit her grandson (see Defendant's exhibit A, Family Court Order of Dismissal and Order on Motion). Although the Family Court Petition was dismissed with prejudice on standing grounds, as relevant here, the Family Court Order on Motion supports Defendant's testimony in this case regarding her concerns for her and her son's safety related to her husband's threats (id.).
Given Defendant's concern, she insisted that someone else accompany her and her son for their protection during the agreed-upon meeting — a condition that applied to such previous meetings. On cross-examination, Defendant conceded that she was not afraid of Claimant and Claimant did not make any threats against Defendant or her son. Defendant further testified that she was worried by Claimant's repeated pressure to avoid having a stranger accompany them during the meeting because it made Claimant feel "uncomfortable and uneasy" (see Claimant's exhibit 2d). Adding Claimant's son's threat to kidnap his son exacerbated Defendant's worries. Consequently, on February 25, 2025, Defendant messaged Claimant cancelling the meeting that was supposed to occur on the same day, stating:
"I received some angry and threatening messages from [Claimant's son] yesterday. Between those, and your strong insistence on my coming to the rescheduled visit alone with [Claimant's grandson], I no longer feel comfortable meeting. After consultation with my attorneys I have decided that it is best for me and [Defendant's son/Claimant's grandson] not to meet at this time" (Claimant's exhibit 2F).
As a result of the cancelled meeting, Claimant was unable to see her grandson. She brought this lawsuit to hold Defendant accountable for travel costs related to her travel from Türkiye to New York.
ANALYSIS
The Civil Court does not have subject matter jurisdiction to enter an order regarding visitation (see Family Court Act § 511 ["Except as otherwise provided, the family court has exclusive original jurisdiction in proceedings to order support and to make orders of custody or of visitation "]. Here, Claimant seeks a judgment to recoup monetary damages based on a breached visitation agreement, not to seek an order granting visitation. Thus, this Court has jurisdiction over this claim.
"The elements of [a claim for breach of contract] include the existence of a contract, the plaintiff's performance thereunder, the defendant's breach thereof, and resulting damages" (Harris v Seward Park Hous. Corp., 79 AD3d 425, 426 [1st Dept 2010] [internal citations omitted]). Here, it is undisputed that the parties agreed to a meeting. It is further undisputed that Claimant performed under the agreement, but Defendant breached the agreement when she cancelled the meeting. Defendant was aware that Claimant was travelling from abroad and incurred expenses for the visit. Were this a garden variety contract claim, Claimant would succeed as there is no real dispute that Defendant breached the contract.
Out-of-court agreements between family members for visitation of a minor are treated differently in New York. "[C]ourts view these sorts of agreements more skeptically and police them to ensure the resolution is in the best interests of the child it is the court's job to be the child's watchdog pursuant to the doctrine of parens patriae" (2 Corbin on New York Contracts § 81.05; see also Friederwitzer v Friederwitzer, 55 NY2d 89, 95 [1982] ["No agreement of the parties can bind the court to a disposition other than that which a weighing of all of the factors involved shows to be in the child's best interest."]). Immediate threats to a child's safety are a key concern (see Maureen S. v Margaret S., 184 AD2d 159, 165 [2d Dept 1992] ["It is well settled that a court may make a temporary change in custody to protect children from immediate threat to the well-being of the children." (Internal quotation marks omitted)]). Where it is "reasonably necessary to protect the parties' children from future immediate and ongoing danger to a member of the household" (Matter of Gil v Gil, 55 AD3d 1024, 1025 [3d Dept 2008] [Internal quotation marks and citations omitted]), the Court may take measures to prevent that harm.
"Generally, once a party to a contract has made a promise, that party must perform or respond in damages for its failure, even when unforeseen circumstances make performance burdensome " (Kel Kim Corp. v Cent. Mkts., Inc., 70 NY2d 900, 902 [1987] [Internal citation omitted]). However, "[c]ourts will apply equitable considerations and refuse to enforce a contract if greater harm ensues it" (see 2 Corbin on New York Contracts § 74.02]).
Here, Defendant credibly testified about her fear for her and her son's safety based on threats of harm made by Claimant's son. It was undisputed that the Defendant dealt with a history of threating messages and abusive lawsuits. In response, Claimant dismissively stated that Defendant's concerns were irrelevant, contending that this is a simple breach of contract claim. In doing so, Claimant failed to take seriously the context of the parties' agreement and the risk of harm raised by the threats, even though she did not make those threats herself. Given that Claimant was staying with her son while in New York, her insistence on seeing her grandson without supervision, the threat of kidnapping, that Claimant was aware of the hostile nature of Defendant's relationship with her son, and apparent indifference to the safety concerns to Defendant and her grandson, the Court finds that Claimant is not credible. The Court also finds that these facts present an extraordinary circumstance that excuses Defendant's breach of the visitation agreement. The Court finds that Defendant's decision not to proceed with the visit was based on a reasonable fear of harm and was, therefore, in the best interest of her child. Thus, money damages are unwarranted.
Lastly, while the Court does not believe that Claimant brought this claim in bad faith, the Court is very concerned about the alleged history of harassing and vexatious litigation. Out of an overabundance of caution, the Court admonishes the parties to avoid bringing harassing, meritless lawsuits against each other in the future. If claims are proven to be brought in bad faith and with intent to harass another person, the party bringing the lawsuit may be subject to monetary sanctions, held in contempt of court, or face other serious, negative consequences (see e.g. Judiciary Law § 753, Power of courts to punish for civil contempts).
Based on the foregoing, it is hereby ORDERED that the Clerk of the Court enter judgment in Defendant's favor dismissing this claim with prejudice.
This constitutes the Decision and Order of the Court.
Dated: October 23, 2026
New York, NY
HON. L. AUSTIN D'SOUZA, A.J.S.C.
Judge, New York City Civil Court
L. Austin D'Souza, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Index No. SC-000706-25 /NY
Decided: October 23, 2026
Court: Civil Court, City of New York.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)