Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Christopher James Gum, Plaintiff and Appellant v. Muddy Boyz Drywall LLC, Defendant and Appellee
[¶1] Christopher Gum appeals from a judgment, certified under N.D.R.Civ.P. 54(b), granting Muddy Boyz Drywall LLC's motion for summary judgment and dismissing Gum's claims. We reverse, concluding there were genuine issues of material fact precluding summary judgment, and remand for further proceedings.
I
[¶2] On April 15, 2023, Gum and Muddy Boyz entered into a contract in which Muddy Boyz leased a dump trailer to Gum for a seven-day period for a flat rate of $400. On or about April 17, 2023, Gum was arrested while using the trailer to transport materials from a West Fargo storage facility; he was charged with burglary, theft of services, and other offenses. The trailer and its contents were transported to the police department. After learning the trailer was registered to Muddy Boyz, the reporting officer contacted Muddy Boyz and confirmed Gum was renting the trailer. Later that same day, Muddy Boyz picked up the trailer. Gum was released from custody before the lease term ended.
[¶3] Gum sued Muddy Boyz, alleging Muddy Boyz breached their contract when it reclaimed possession of the trailer during the lease term. Gum also alleged Muddy Boyz knowingly disposed of his property—“vehicle parts, engines, nonprecious metals, copper, copper wiring, brass, and tools”—which he valued to be between $50,000 and $60,000. Muddy Boyz answered and counterclaimed for conversion, breach of contract, fraud, and trespass.
[¶4] Muddy Boyz moved for summary judgment on Gum's claims, asserting there were no genuine issues of material fact. Muddy Boyz's managing member, Jamie Ament, filed an affidavit acknowledging the lease agreement and its basic terms. He added that they had “agreed that Gum would return the Trailer in the same or substantially the same condition as when the lease began, that he would not use the Trailer for any unlawful purposes, and that the Trailer would be returned empty.” Ament testified that law enforcement notified him before he retrieved the trailer that Gum was arrested for stealing or possessing various stolen materials from local construction sites and had used the trailer to transport the stolen materials. Ament testified there was “extensive damage” to the trailer and it contained miscellaneous items that he classified as “junk,” which he took to the junkyard or landfill for “processing.” Muddy Boyz argued that Gum breached the contract by using the trailer for unlawful purposes (transferring stolen property) and causing damage to the trailer, and that its ability to perform under the contract was impossible due to the trailer being impounded and damaged.
[¶5] Gum opposed summary judgment, arguing his only contractual obligation was to return the trailer by April 22, 2023, and that Muddy Boyz breached the lease and converted his property. He filed affidavits and exhibits in support of his arguments. Gum testified that the items disposed of were his property and the trailer was not used for unlawful purposes. Two of his exhibits are criminal judgments, showing his burglary and non-theft charges were dismissed. Gum testified that after being released from custody, he contacted Ament to retrieve his property, but Ament told him that “the trailer was empty when we recovered it from the police.” Gum testified that an officer informed him that Muddy Boyz took possession of the trailer and its contents.
[¶6] The district court granted Muddy Boyz's motion for summary judgment and entered judgment dismissing Gum's claims. Gum appealed, and we dismissed the appeal for lack of a final judgment resolving all of the parties’ claims in Gum v. Muddy Boyz Drywall LLC, 2025 ND 111, ¶ 1, 22 N.W.3d 720. After Muddy Boyz moved to dismiss its counterclaims, the court granted the motion and dismissed the counterclaims without prejudice. Gum appealed, and we dismissed the appeal for lack of a final judgment or N.D.R.Civ.P. 54(b) certification in Gum v. Muddy Boyz Drywall LLC, 2026 ND 5, ¶¶ 8-9, 30 N.W.3d 316. Gum moved for Rule 54(b) certification, which the court granted, certifying the judgment dismissing Gum's claims. Gum appeals the certified judgment.
II
[¶7] Gum argues the district court erred in granting summary judgment.
Summary judgment is a procedural device for the prompt resolution of a controversy on the merits without a trial if there are no genuine issues of material fact or inferences that can reasonably be drawn from undisputed facts, or if the only issues to be resolved are questions of law. A party moving for summary judgment has the burden of showing there are no genuine issues of material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. In determining whether summary judgment was appropriately granted, we must view the evidence in the light most favorable to the party opposing the motion, and that party will be given the benefit of all favorable inferences which can reasonably be drawn from the record. On appeal, this Court decides whether the information available to the district court precluded the existence of a genuine issue of material fact and entitled the moving party to judgment as a matter of law. Whether the district court properly granted summary judgment is a question of law which we review de novo on the entire record.
Berger v. Sellers, 2023 ND 171, ¶ 7, 996 N.W.2d 329.
A
[¶8] Gum argues there were genuine issues of material fact whether Muddy Boyz breached the contract by repossessing the trailer before the end of the lease term.
[¶9] “A breach of contract is the nonperformance of a contractual duty when it is due. The elements of a prima facie case for breach of contract are: (1) the existence of a contract; (2) breach of the contract; and (3) damages which flow from the breach.” Dahms v. Legacy Plumbing, LLC, 2024 ND 53, ¶ 6, 5 N.W.3d 531. “While construction of a written contract to determine its legal effect presents a question of law, whether a party has breached a contract is a finding of fact.” Northstar Ctr., LLC v. Lukenbill Fam. P'ship, LLLP, 2024 ND 212, ¶ 15, 17 N.W.3d 1 (cleaned up).
[¶10] The record contains no written lease. Muddy Boyz acknowledged that Gum paid in full $400 for a seven-day lease of the trailer and that it repossessed the trailer within a day or two. Ament testified law enforcement notified him that Gum was arrested for stealing or possessing stolen materials and that he “must retrieve the Trailer from the impound lot.” He testified that extensive damage had been done to the trailer, costing him hundreds of dollars to “make the initial repairs, scrub, degrease, pressure wash the floor of the Trailer, and remove twine and wire wrapped around the axles and hubs.” Ament testified they had “agreed that Gum would return the Trailer in the same or substantially the same condition as when the lease began, that he would not use the Trailer for any unlawful purposes, and that the Trailer would be returned empty.” Muddy Boyz argues that Gum breached the contract by using the trailer for unlawful purposes (transferring stolen property) and causing damage to the trailer, and that its ability to perform under the contract was impossible due to Gum's breach, the impoundment of the trailer, and the damage to the trailer.
[¶11] Gum argues his only contractual obligation was to return the trailer by April 22, 2023. He testified that he was not transporting stolen materials, that he owned the property being transported, and that he never used the trailer for an unlawful purpose.
[¶12] Muddy Boyz's repossession of the trailer thwarted Gum's possession and use of the trailer for the rest of the seven-day period. Whether the contract required the trailer to be returned “in the same or substantially the same condition” or prohibited use of the trailer for “unlawful purposes” are genuine issues of material fact. See Rocket Dogs K-9 Aquatics & Wellness Ctr., LLC v. Derheim, Inc., 2023 ND 103, ¶ 8, 991 N.W.2d 53 (“The existence of an oral contract and the extent of its terms are also questions of fact.”). With no written contract in the record and conflicting statements from the parties, the terms at issue are unclear.
[¶13] Further, whether unlawful-purpose or same-condition provisions were breached by Gum remain genuine issues of material fact. The criminal charges against Gum in the record, including burglary, were dismissed, and Gum testified he owned the property on the trailer. Whether Gum violated the contract's purported unlawful-purpose term by using the trailer for an unlawful purpose is a genuine issue of material fact precluding summary judgment.
[¶14] As to condition, Ament testified there was “extensive damage,” including “a broken jack handle, a destroyed hydraulic control box, a bent fender, a rear swing-door snapped off, three broken lights, missing pins for locking the door panels for the trailer ramps, twisted and bent structural tubing, a missing original wheel replaced with an old rusty wheel, missing spare tire and fasteners, and the trailer deck was gouged and covered in a thick layer of grease.” Ament testified, however, that the trailer only needed to be returned in substantially the same condition, not maintained in substantially the same condition throughout the lease period. Gum still had five or six days on his lease to improve the condition of the trailer and return it to Muddy Boyz. Ament testified that he was able to make the “initial repairs” and improve its condition through his own labor over 11.5 hours and through additional expenditures. What the agreed condition term was and whether Gum breached it at the time Muddy Boyz repossessed the trailer are genuine issues of material fact.
[¶15] Muddy Boyz argues that Gum's arrest, the damage to the trailer, and the trailer's impoundment made its performance impossible. The doctrine of impossibility or impracticality applies “where, after a contract is made, a party's performance is made impracticable without his fault by the occurrence of an event the non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption on which the contract was made, his duty to render that performance is discharged, unless the language or the circumstances indicate the contrary.” Red River Wings, Inc. v. Hoot, Inc., 2008 ND 117, ¶ 56, 751 N.W.2d 206 (cleaned up). Impossibility doctrine does not apply where the “impossibility is caused by a party to the contract.” Id. “If one party prevents the other's performance, it excuses the performance and provides a defense in a suit for breach by such nonperformance.” Barnes v. St. Joseph's Hosp., 1999 ND 204, ¶ 16, 601 N.W.2d 587. Gum's conduct did not prevent Muddy Boyz's performance. Leasing the trailer to Gum for the full seven days was not rendered impossible by Gum's arrest or the impoundment of the trailer. Gum was released within the seven-day period and, as shown by Muddy Boyz, the trailer was able to be retrieved from the impound lot. Whether the damage sustained by the trailer made it impractical for Muddy Boyz to continue the lease term is a genuine issue of material fact.
[¶16] Muddy Boyz also asserts Gum failed to provide any admissible evidence of damages. “The determination of the amount of damages caused by a breach of contract is a finding of fact.” Three Aces Props. LLC v. United Rentals (N. Am.), Inc., 2020 ND 258, ¶ 10, 952 N.W.2d 64. Gum testified his damages for the breach were $285, which is roughly the prorated rent for the five unused days ($400 times 5/7 is about $285). Muddy Boyz acknowledges that if breach were shown, there would be some damages: “the extent of Appellant's damages could only amount to the value of an additional five- or six-days’ use of the trailer.” Gum's breach of contract claim does not fail as a matter of law for lack of evidence on damages.
[¶17] At the summary judgment stage, Gum is entitled to have the evidence viewed in the light most favorable to him and to be given the benefit of all favorable inferences which can reasonably be drawn from the record. Berger, 2023 ND 171, ¶ 7. On this record, we conclude the district court erred in determining there were no genuine issues of material fact concerning Gum's breach of contract claim.
B
[¶18] Gum argues there were genuine issues of material fact whether Muddy Boyz unlawfully converted his property. “Conversion consists of a tortious detention or destruction of personal property, or a wrongful exercise of dominion or control over the property inconsistent with or in defiance of the rights of the owner.” Kluver v. SGJ Holdings, LLC, 2023 ND 65, ¶ 14, 988 N.W.2d 569.
1
[¶19] The parties disagree about whether Gum alleged a conversion claim in his complaint.1 While both parties state their position, neither briefs the issue.
[¶20] The complaint does not separate out the causes of action. For example, there is no heading labeled “Breach of Contract” or “Conversion.” The complaint states in relevant part:
(9) On April 17 2023 in Cass County North Dakota Muddy Boyz Drywall LLC. took possession of the dump trailer along with it's contents, property of Christopher Gum which Defendant knew to be fact then with malice and intent to deprive Plaintiff of said property “disposed” of said property of Plaintiff while under contract/agreement breaching this rental contract.
(10) On April 17 2023 Defendant Muddy Boyz Drywall LLC “disposed of” Plaintiffs property including but not limited to vehicle parts, engines, non precious metals, copper, copper wiring, brass and tools the value of said items exceeding $50,000.00 in value.
[¶21] Rule 8(a), N.D.R.Civ.P., requires “(1) a short and plain statement of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief; and (2) a demand for the relief sought, which may include relief in the alternative or different types of relief.” “Although a concise and non-technical complaint is all that is required by N.D.R.Civ.P. 8(a), a complaint nevertheless must be sufficient to inform and notify the adversary and the court of the pleader's claim.” Sanderson v. Cole, 2026 ND 16, ¶ 22, 31 N.W.3d 135. “Rule 8 does not require the complaint to have detailed factual allegations, but allegations that are merely conclusory statements unsupported by factual allegations are not sufficient to state a cause of action.” Id. “Pleadings must be construed so as to do justice.” N.D.R.Civ.P. 8(e).
[¶22] Gum alleged Muddy Boyz took possession and disposed of his property, which it knew to be his, with the intent to deprive him of that property. These allegations are sufficient under our liberal pleading standards to allege a conversion claim and to put Muddy Boyz on notice of that claim. We conclude conversion was alleged in the complaint.
2
[¶23] Ament testified that law enforcement told him that Gum used the trailer to transport stolen material; that when he retrieved the trailer from the impound lot, it contained miscellaneous items that he classified as “junk”; and that he took the items to the junkyard or landfill for “processing.” In contrast, Gum testified he owned the items and identified the items disposed of and their approximate value. Genuine issues of material fact exist as to whether Gum owned the items, the items had any value, and Muddy Boyz wrongfully destroyed or exercised dominion or control over the items inconsistent with or in defiance of Gum's ownership rights.
[¶24] Muddy Boyz argues it did not wrongfully come into possession of the items. This Court has said both that “if the defendant rightly came into possession and there was no wrongful taking of goods, demand and refusal to return may be required for conversion,” and that “demand and refusal are evidence of conversion but are not necessary to constitute conversion where a demand would be unavailing.” Ritter, Laber & Assocs., Inc. v. Koch Oil, Inc., 2004 ND 117, ¶ 11, 680 N.W.2d 634. Even if “demand and refusal” were required, Gum testified that he contacted Ament to retrieve his property and Ament told him that “the trailer was empty when we recovered it from the police.” Muddy Boyz also admitted that Gum asked on April 20, 2023, to retrieve the contents and that it told him it had disposed of them. On summary judgment we view that evidence in the light most favorable to Gum. Berger, 2023 ND 171, ¶ 7. So viewed, the evidence supports an inference that Gum demanded the items and Muddy Boyz refused to return them. Moreover, even if Muddy Boyz did not wrongfully come into possession of the items, its later disposal of them makes demand and refusal unnecessary because it assumes the defendant still has the property. See Dairy Dep't v. Harvey Cheese, Inc., 278 N.W.2d 137, 144 (N.D. 1979) (noting demand and refusal are “usually necessary” where “there has been no wrongful taking or disposal of the goods” (emphasis added)).
[¶25] We conclude the district court erred in determining there were no genuine issues of material fact concerning Gum's conversion claim.
III
[¶26] We reverse the judgment dismissing Gum's claims and remand to the district court for further proceedings.
[¶27] Lisa Fair McEvers, C.J.
Jerod E. Tufte
Jon J. Jensen
Douglas A. Bahr
Mark A. Friese
FOOTNOTES
1. In November 2024, Gum moved to amend his complaint to add a claim for conversion. The district court never ruled on the motion. Gum has not argued that the court erred in failing to rule on the motion, or that it should be deemed denied and the court's denial was in error. See Alerus Fin., N.A. v. Erwin, 2018 ND 119, ¶ 12, 911 N.W.2d 296 (“[I]f a court does not rule on a motion, it may be deemed denied.”). Thus, we address only whether the original complaint alleged a conversion claim.
Opinion of the Court by Tufte, Justice.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: No. 20260179
Decided: November 06, 2026
Court: Supreme Court of North Dakota.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)