Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Matthew EVANS, an individual, Jeffrey Hoverson, an individual, and Douglas Pearson, an individual, Petitioners v. Michael HOWE, in his official capacity as Secretary of State, Respondent
[¶1] Matthew Evans, Jeffrey Hoverson, and Douglas Pearson (“Petitioners”) petition this Court to invoke its original jurisdiction and issue a writ of mandamus directing Secretary of State Michael Howe to declare insufficient the nominating petitions of four Republican legislative nominees: Terry Goerger, Blaine DesLauriers, Timothy Mihalick, and Steven Sauter (“the candidates”). Because the delay in filing of the petition creates substantial prejudice and is inequitable to the candidates on the ballot, we decline to invoke our original jurisdiction and deny the petition.
I
[¶2] A North Dakota legislative candidate's name may be placed on the primary ballot through a party certification of endorsement or a nominating petition. N.D.C.C. § 16.1-11-06(1). Goerger, DesLauriers, Mihalick, and Sauter each timely filed a nominating petition for their placement on the June 9, 2026 primary ballot. For the June 9, 2026 primary, nominating documents and any corrections were due by 4:00 p.m. on April 6, 2026, the sixty-fourth day before the primary. See N.D.C.C. § 16.1-11-39(2). The Secretary accepted each of the candidates’ petitions and placed their names on their respective ballots. All four candidates won the Republican nomination for their respective districts at the June 9, 2026 primary. Hoverson lost to DesLauriers and Mihalick. Evans lost to Goerger.
[¶3] On July 21, 2026, Petitioners requested copies of the candidates’ petitions from the Secretary of State. On July 28, 2026, Petitioners alleged defects in the candidates’ petitions to the Secretary's office, and on August 18, 2026, demanded that the Secretary act on the alleged defects. Petitioners claimed Goerger's petition failed to identify his political party because the party-affiliation box on its cover page was blank and the affidavit naming his party was executed after the signatures were gathered. Petitioners further claimed the Secretary improperly counted signatures on the DesLauriers, Mihalick, and Sauter petitions, alleging address information was added after signing and by someone other than the signer. Excluding those signatures, Petitioners asserted none of the three had the required number of valid signatures for placement on the primary ballot. On August 21, 2026, the Secretary declined Petitioners’ demand to act on the alleged deficiencies.
[¶4] When a filing officer discovers an insufficiency after the primary filing deadline, the candidate “may not be deemed nominated until the insufficiency is corrected,” and the candidate must file corrections “not later than four p.m. on the sixty-fourth day before the general election.” N.D.C.C. § 16.1-11-39(3). For the November 3, 2026 general election, the correction deadline was August 31, 2026. Petitioners filed their petition for a writ of mandamus on September 28, 2026.
[¶5] Petitioners argue the Secretary improperly listed the candidates on their respective district ballots and the Secretary's procedures fail to provide equal protection of the law. In response, the Secretary argues this is an inappropriate case to exercise our original jurisdiction, but if exercised: (1) N.D.C.C. § 16.1-11-39 allows candidates to correct their petitions without stating who must make the corrections, (2) Goerger's filing as a whole identified his party, and (3) Petitioners’ equal protection claims are without merit.
[¶6] Petitioners do not ask that the four names be removed from the ballot. Instead, Petitioners ask for a writ directing the Secretary to take the following steps if any of the four candidates wins the general election: declare that the candidate was not lawfully nominated or elected, annul his certificate of election, and declare a vacancy to be filled by the party's district committee. In addition, Petitioners ask for a writ compelling the Secretary to apply uniform standards to signature counting and ballot certification.
II
[¶7] “This Court's authority to exercise original jurisdiction under N.D. Const. art. VI, § 2, is discretionary, which cannot be invoked as a matter of right.” Bolinske v. Jaeger, 2008 ND 180, ¶ 4, 756 N.W.2d 336. “This Court will determine for itself whether or not to exercise its original jurisdiction.” Id. “[T]he power to exercise our original jurisdiction extends only to those cases where the questions presented are publici juris and affect the sovereignty of the state, the franchises or prerogatives of the state, or the liberties of its people.” Onstad v. Jaeger, 2020 ND 203, ¶ 7, 949 N.W.2d 214 (quoting Berg v. Jaeger, 2020 ND 178, ¶ 7, 948 N.W.2d 4).
[¶8] “A writ of mandamus may be issued to compel the performance of an act which the law specifically requires a state official to perform.” Onstad, 2020 ND 203, ¶ 8, 949 N.W.2d 214 (citing N.D.C.C. § 32-34-01). “A petitioner for a writ of mandamus must show a clear legal right to performance of the act sought to be compelled and must establish no plain, speedy, and adequate remedy exists in the ordinary course of law.” Id. (quoting Berg, 2020 ND 178, ¶ 9, 948 N.W.2d 4). “The law must require an act to be done to be enforceable by mandamus.” Id. “The writ of mandamus is not a mere writ of right, but a high, prerogative mandate that will, in the exercise of sound, judicial discretion, and on equitable principles, be issued only when called for by circumstances so exceptional that, if the extraordinary relief afforded by the writ is refused, a failure or miscarriage of justice will result.” State ex rel. Davis v. Willis, 19 N.D. 209, 124 N.W. 706, 706–07 (1910).
III
[¶9] This Court has often declined to invoke its original jurisdiction to issue a writ of mandamus. See, e.g., State ex rel. DeKrey v. Peterson, 174 N.W.2d 95, 99-100 (N.D. 1970) (declining to issue a writ of mandamus over a school excess-levy requirement because the controversy was of “local interest,” did not affect the sovereignty of the State, and could be litigated in district court); State ex rel. Spaeth v. Meiers, 403 N.W.2d 392, 394 (N.D. 1987) (declining to exercise original jurisdiction to compel the Senate's presiding officers to accept a House bill because the dispositive issue was “a procedural intra-branch dispute among members of the legislature”); Friends of the Rail Bridge v. N. D. Dep't of Water Res., 2023 ND 164, ¶ 1, 995 N.W.2d 461 (declining to exercise original jurisdiction to issue writs of mandamus and prohibition “[b]ecause adequate alternative remedies are available by law.”).
[¶10] This Court has said that a petitioner's delay in seeking relief can alone justify denying a petition for a writ of mandamus. See, e.g., State ex rel. McCue v. Blaisdell, 18 N.D. 55, 118 N.W. 141, 143 (1908). To make a threshold determination of whether we will exercise original jurisdiction here, we consider delay in filing the petition and its effect on nonparties and voters. The timing of the present petition disrupts an ongoing election, potentially confusing voters. Delayed filing also creates substantial prejudice for the four candidates. The deadline for a candidate to file corrections to their nominating petition for the November 3, 2026 general election was August 31, 2026. Petitioners did not file their petition until September 28, 2026, a month after the deadline. The candidates’ petitions were filed with the Secretary in February and March, 2026, and were obtainable as public records. Even accepting Petitioners’ claims that they were unaware of the defects until late July 2026, they possessed actual knowledge no later than July 28, 2026. The Secretary's final refusal followed on August 21, 2026. Despite having this information, Petitioners waited until September 28, 2026, to file. By then, the general election ballot had been certified and early voting began soon after.
[¶11] Petitioners’ delay is particularly significant because of the statute Petitioners themselves invoke. Under N.D.C.C. § 16.1-11-39(3), if the filing officer discovers an insufficiency after the primary filing deadline, “the candidate may not be deemed nominated until the insufficiency is corrected,” the filing officer must notify the candidate, and the candidate must file corrections “not later than four p.m. on the sixty-fourth day before the general election.” Petitioners rely on this subsection to argue the alleged defects survived the primary. Even assuming N.D.C.C. § 16.1-11-39(3) applies, this same subsection sets the period within which a challenge could be resolved without depriving the candidates of an opportunity to correct, and that period closed on August 31, 2026.
[¶12] By their own account, Petitioners learned of the alleged defects in late July 2026, more than a month before the August 31, 2026 deadline. The defects were raised with the Secretary on July 28, 2026, but a demand for action did not follow until August 18, 2026, and the Secretary declined to act on August 21, 2026, ten days before the correction period closed. Petitioners waited to petition this Court until September 28, 2026, more than five weeks after the Secretary's refusal and four weeks after the correction period had expired. Had Petitioners pursued their challenge with the diligence the statutory timeline required, any insufficiency could have been met with notice and an opportunity to correct. Instead, Petitioners ask this Court to declare the petitions insufficient when no correction is possible, an inequitable and harsher result than the statute they invoke contemplates, and after the voters in the affected districts have selected their preferred candidates. “[I]t is not for this court to thwart the will of the voters and the purpose of the statute by any technical refinements.” Bugbee v. Steele County, 41 N.D. 155, 170 N.W. 321, 324 (1918).
[¶13] An official has no discretion to ignore the command of a statute. Officials do, however, have broad discretion to implement agency operating procedures to fulfill statutory obligations. Petitioners ask us to issue a writ compelling the Secretary to apply uniform standards to signature counting and ballot certification. In response, the Secretary submits a declaration of the State Election Director, asserting uniform standards have been consistently applied to every statewide office candidate for at least the past 36 years. To the extent Petitioners ask us to compel the Secretary to implement and apply internal operating policies, we decline. See State v. Vesperman, 52 N.D. 641, 204 N.W. 202, 204 (1925) (“It is elementary that mandamus is not a proper remedy to control official discretion.”); see also City of Fargo v. Cass County, 286 N.W.2d 494, 498 (N.D. 1979) (“Generally, mandamus will not lie for the purpose of compelling officers to perform a discretionary act in a certain manner.”).
[¶14] We conclude this is not an appropriate case in which to exercise our original jurisdiction. Therefore, we decline to exercise our original jurisdiction and the petition is denied.
Friese, Justice.
[[¶15] Lisa Fair McEvers, C.J. Jon J. Jensen Mark A. Friese William A. Neumann, S.J. David E. Reich, S.J.[¶16] The Honorable William A. Neumann, S.J., sitting in place of Tufte, J., disqualified.[¶17] The Honorable David E. Reich, S.J., sitting in place of Bahr, J., disqualified.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: No. 20260350
Decided: October 28, 2026
Court: Supreme Court of North Dakota.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)