Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
People of the State of New York v. John A. Bartolini, FRANK BARTOLINI IRREVOCABLE TRUST, and ORSOLA BARTOLINI IRREVOCABLE TRUST, Defendants.
This decision addresses only defendant John A. Bartolini's motion to disqualify the Special Prosecutor, not the defendant's Omnibus Motion to Dismiss the underlying criminal action.
BACKGROUND
This case was transferred to this court from the Town of Yorktown Justice Court on July 2, 2026. The identifying case number in the Town of Yorktown is 2026-048.
The underlying facts concern alleged violations of various sections of the Town of Yorktown Code regarding the property more commonly known as and located at 2145 Hunterbrook Road, Yorktown Heights, New York 10598, located in the Town of Yorktown. In an appearance ticket dated and issued on May 29, 2026, the defendants were ordered to appear in the Town of Yorktown Justice Court on June 9, 2026, for various violations of the Yorktown Zoning Code, including but not limited to:
• the building of structures on the property without appropriate permits
• having construction equipment in designated wetlands without appropriate permits
• the removal of trees without appropriate permits.
In addition to the case before this court, the Town of Yorktown filed a complaint in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, County of Westchester, which was subsequently withdrawn without prejudice after the defendants filed an administrative appeal with the Town of Yorktown Zoning Board of Appeals. The defendant also filed an action in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York against the Town of Yorktown and other named defendants. All of these matters relate to the underlying facts of this case.1
As stated above, this decision relates solely to the defendant's motion before this court to disqualify the Special Prosecutor.
MATERIALS AND EVIDENCE CONSIDERED
1. Notice of Motion and Affirmation in support of the Defendant John A. Bartolini, received and filed with the Clerk of the Somers Justice Court on August 18, 2026.2
2. An affirmation of Special Prosecutor James Castro-Blanco in opposition to said motion filed with the Clerk of this Court on September 22, 2026, and an accompanying Memorandum of Law; and
3. Defendants' "Consolidated" Affirmation dated September 25, 2026.
DECISION SUMMARY
The defendant's application to disqualify the Special Prosecutor is denied. The Special Prosecutor's conversation with two individuals who are co-defendants with the Town of Yorktown in the defendant's federal civil rights action arising from the same facts as those before this court, one of whom is a Councilperson in the Town of Yorktown, did not violate the law, and did not create the "appearance of impropriety" as alleged by the defendant, John A. Bartolini.
DISCUSSION
The defendant alleges that in the Somers Justice Court on August 17, 2026, at the time of the defendant's appearance in the underlying matter, he observed Town Councilwoman Susan Siegel and John Netterfield, a Board Member in the "Huntersville Association,"3 present in the courtroom. He further claims they had no business with the court.
After his August 17, 2026, appearance before this court, the defendant claims that he observed the Special Prosecutor speaking with Ms. Siegel and Mr. Netterfield in the parking lot outside the courthouse.
The defendant further alleges that merely by conversing with co-defendants in the federal civil rights action he has filed against them, and allegedly ending the conversation when the Special Prosecutor became aware of the defendant's presence, somehow violated the Special Prosecutor's duty, and projected a reasonable impression that he could be improperly influenced in violation of New York Public Officers Law, Section 74(3)(a), and created the appearance of impropriety in violation of People v. Shinkle, 51 NY2d 417 (1980).4
The initial question is whether this court has authority to remove the special prosecutor under County Law Section 701. The statute does not mention town courts but states that "a superior criminal court," as defined in CPL § 10.10(2) to include County Court and Supreme Court, has the authority to appoint a special prosecutor under County Law Section 701(1). Under County Law, Section 701(6)(b), speaking about the Attorney General's office specifically, the power to discharge the Attorney General's office as special prosecutor is given to the "Superior Criminal Court."
There is authority for the local court to remove the special prosecutor and refer the matter to the superior criminal court to appoint a replacement. In People v. Rocci, 184 Misc 2d 670 (Utica City Court 2000), a bail bondsman was allegedly struck by the defendant, an incident witnessed by an Assistant District Attorney. The court noted that County Law Section 701(1): " specifically allows for the disqualification of a District Attorney from performing his or her duties at a term "of any court" , sufficient reason being present," and disqualified the District Attorney's office on its own motion.
In People v. Marrano, 2023 NY Slip Op 50420(U) (Glens Falls City Ct. 2023), the court said: "While a superior court must appoint, a lower court may disqualify." It called that inherent authority to be used "sparingly." See also People v. Nelson, 167 Misc 2d 665 (City Court, City of New York 1995). Citing People v. Zimmer, supra, the Marrano court stated: "However, courts have held that, in rare situations, the appearance of impropriety may be a sufficient basis for disqualification, when the appearance is such as to 'discourage public confidence in our government and the system of law to which it is dedicated." People v. Zimmer, 51 NY2d 390, 396, 434 N.Y.S.2d 206, 414 N.E.2d 705 [1980]. In a case of that nature, the defendant and the public at large are entitled to protection against the appearance of impropriety. Id. at 396; People v. Adams, supra, at 612—613, 964 N.Y.S.2d 495, 987 N.E.2d 272."
The issue is whether the facts in this case warrant the extraordinary remedy of disqualifying the Special Prosecutor and referring the matter to the County Court to appoint a new Special Prosecutor. While this court recognizes its inherent authority to disqualify a prosecutor, to be exercised sparingly (see People v. Marrano, supra), it finds that the facts here do not warrant such relief.
First, disposing of the defendant's argument that Ms. Siegel and Mr. Netterfield had no business in the Somers Town Justice Court, it is axiomatic that, absent special circumstances, the Town Justice Courts are open to any member of the public. An example of special circumstances would be when testimony is being taken, and a potential witness in the matter is excluded from the courtroom on the motion of one of the parties.
It is also axiomatic that an attorney, legally authorized to represent the Town of Yorktown by the Town Board and by the Westchester District Attorney's Office, is permitted to speak to representatives of the Town and others who could assist him in fulfilling his prosecutorial duties, consistent with applicable ethical rules.
The Court "as a general rule, should remove a public prosecutor only to protect a defendant from actual prejudice arising from a demonstrated conflict of interest or a substantial risk of an abuse of confidence (e.g., People v. Zimmer, 51 NY2d 390, supra; People v. Shinkle, 51 NY2d 417, 421) and the appearance of impropriety, standing alone, might not be grounds for disqualification." See Matter of Schumer v. Holzman, 60 NY2d 46, 55 (1983). See People v. Zimmer, 51 NY2d 390 (1980), where the District Attorney prosecuting the case had been counsel to the corporation involved in the alleged crime.
However, there is a major exception to this rule involving the appearance of impropriety. As stated by the court in People v. Zimmer, supra, at page 396: "However, in rare situations, the appearance of impropriety itself is a ground for disqualification, as our case law recognizes, when the appearance is such as to 'discourage [ ] public confidence in our government and the system of law to which it is dedicated."
The New York State Bar Association Committee on Professional Ethics, in Opinion 654, issued on April 28, 1994, citing People v. Zimmer, supra, states: "Because of the power and authority with which the district attorney is invested, both actual and perceived fairness in carrying out the duties of public prosecutor are vital to the fairness of the criminal justice system as a whole. See People v. Zimmer, 51 NY2d 390, 395." While this standard underscores the gravity of the Special Prosecutor's role, the conduct alleged here - a brief conversation in a public setting with representatives of the complaining municipality - does not implicate either actual or perceived unfairness.
The facts in this case do not meet the high bar required to order the Special Prosecutor's disqualification. A brief, observed conversation in a public parking lot between the Special Prosecutor and representatives of the complaining municipality does not constitute conduct that would "discourage public confidence in our government and the system of law to which it is dedicated." People v. Zimmer, 51 NY2d at 396.
The Court also notes that the defendant's reliance on New York Public Officers Law § 74(3)(a) is misplaced. Even assuming, arguendo, that provision applies to a special prosecutor appointed under County Law § 701 to prosecute a local code violation matter, the conduct alleged here - a brief, observed conversation in a public setting between the Special Prosecutor and representatives of the municipality he was appointed to serve - falls well short of the standard required to establish a violation of that statute or to
provide an independent basis for disqualification.
Therefore, the instant motion to disqualify the Special Prosecutor is denied.
The foregoing constitutes the opinion, decision, and Order of the Court and is hereby So Ordered:
Dated: November 2, 2026
Somers, New York
HON. JOSEPH A. MARRA
Town Justice
FOOTNOTES
1. The federal action alleges a violation of the defendant's civil rights by the Town of Yorktown and various officials of the town.
2. Mr. Bartolini, in an email to this court dated August 26, 2026, sought to deny the Special Prosecutor an opportunity to respond to the motion and requested a ruling only on his papers. That application was denied on the record.
3. On page 2 of the defendant's memorandum of law, it is asserted that both Ms. Siegel and Mr. Netterfield are members of the Yorktown Town Board
4. It is nowhere alleged that the defendant heard what was being discussed.
Joseph A. Marra, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. 26-060069
Decided: November 02, 2026
Court: Justice Court, New York,
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)