Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Daniel Erickson, Plaintiff, v. Valet Auto Wash, Defendant.
SUMMARY OF THE PROCEEDINGS
Plaintiff Daniel Erickson commenced this small claims action to recover damages for a broken rear spoiler sustained by his vehicle while passing through Defendant Valet Auto Wash's automatic car wash facility. Plaintiff appeared pro se and testified. Defendant appeared through its General Manager, Brayden Meade, pro se, and testified. Pursuant to UJCA § 1809(2), the Court inquired of the General Manager, who confirmed that he possessed authority to bind Defendant at trial. The Court finds both witnesses credible. The material facts are largely undisputed.
FINDINGS OF FACT
On March 9, 2026, at approximately 12:30 p.m., Plaintiff drove his vehicle, a 2016 dark gray Subaru WRX, into Defendant's automatic car wash facility located in the Town of Big Flats, which is within the jurisdiction of this Court. While the vehicle was undergoing the automated wash cycle, its rear spoiler was torn off by the wash equipment.
Plaintiff filed his Statement of Claim with this Court on April 15, 2026, seeking a total judgment of $2,296.01. Plaintiff testified that he had previously used Defendant's car wash more than 40 times without incident. On this occasion, however, he felt the vehicle lurch and heard a loud "pop" before realizing that the spoiler had been from the vehicle.
Plaintiff's Exhibits
Plaintiff offered six exhibits, all of which were admitted into evidence:
• Plaintiff's Exhibit 1: An array of four photographs. Three photographs depict the vehicle immediately after the spoiler was torn off, and the fourth photograph depicts the intact condition of the spoiler at some point shortly before it was damaged.
• Plaintiff's Exhibit 2: Two photographs showing a close-up view of the brackets of the spoiler after it was torn off.
• Plaintiff's Exhibit 3: An itemized repair estimate from Knappy's Auto Body totaling $2,006.01 to repair the damage to the 2016 Subaru WRX. The estimate explicitly reflects an anticipated physical repair period of five days.
• Plaintiff's Exhibit 4: A rental car estimate from Enterprise for a midsize vehicle covering a five-day Tuesday-to-Sunday window, reflecting a base rental rate of $710.96 and a total projected cost of $947.94 including taxes and fees.
• Plaintiff's Exhibit 5: A demand letter hand-delivered to the General Manager on March 31, 2026. In the letter, Plaintiff demanded reimbursement for the damage, asserting that the spoiler was firmly affixed and not compromised prior to the wash. Plaintiff noted that the vehicle had safely used the facility numerous times over several years and further asserted that the damage was directly caused by the wash equipment. Plaintiff further noted that, although he was aware of the posted signage regarding spoilers, such signs did not automatically relieve the business of responsibility for damage caused by its operations.
• Plaintiff's Exhibit 6: A contemporaneous incident report completed at the scene on March 9, 2026, signed by both Plaintiff and a Valet Auto Wash crew member. In that report, Plaintiff noted a thud, after which a crew member retrieved the severed spoiler. Plaintiff reported that an attendant informed him that the operator may have failed to select the equipment option designated for vehicles equipped with spoilers.
Plaintiff testified that the rental car amount reflected in the Statement of Claim was preliminary. The Enterprise estimate (Plaintiff's Exhibit 4) was obtained after filing once he received a court date. The initial trial date fell outside the rental period reflected in the Enterprise estimate. However, the action was adjourned for two weeks at Defendant's request, and the adjourned trial date fell within the period reflected in that estimate. Plaintiff testified to those rental costs during his presentation.
Defendant's Exhibits
Defendant offered four exhibits, all of which were admitted into evidence:
• Defendant's Exhibit A: A close-up photograph of the facility notice stating that Defendant is "not responsible for: ... spoilers."
• Defendant's Exhibit B: A close-up photograph of the facility notice stating that customers enter the car wash at their own risk and Defendant is not responsible for any damage.
• Defendant's Exhibit C: A photograph of the exterior of the car wash showing the positioning of the signs relative to the wash tunnel entrance.
• Defendant's Exhibit D: A USB flash drive containing two video clips. The first video clip shows Plaintiff's vehicle prior to entering the mitter on the date in question, from which the Court found it difficult to ascertain clear operational details. The second video clip was captured on the day of the trial to demonstrate the standard mechanical operation of the mitter equipment.
Defendant's photographic exhibits establish the location and configuration of the posted disclaimer signs. There are two identical copies of each sign posted at the entry. On the left side, the signs are posted on a portion of the building extending outward from the tunnel entrance; the spoiler-specific notice (Exhibit A) is mounted at eye level, and the "enter at your own risk" sign (Exhibit B) is positioned directly below it. On the right side, both signs are attached to the exterior wall immediately before entering the tunnel, with the spoiler notice and the "enter at your own risk" sign both positioned at approximately eye level.
In his closing argument, Plaintiff argued that Defendant should not permit vehicles equipped with spoilers to enter the wash if the equipment cannot safely accommodate them, and that under the circumstances, he should not be required to prove the precise mechanism by which the damage occurred, but simply that the equipment caused it. In its closing statement, Defendant acknowledged that Plaintiff's spoiler must have come into contact with some portion of the wash equipment during the wash cycle.
Following closing arguments, the Court formally reopened the proof to pose follow-up questions to the parties. Upon inquiry by the Court, Defendant's General Manager, Brayden Meade, testified that in the nearly four years the facility has been open, only two other vehicles have sustained damage, both of which were caused by falling wash equipment. The General Manager further testified that vehicles equipped with spoilers are routinely permitted to enter the wash facility notwithstanding the posted disclaimer signs. The Court finds that Defendant's practice of routinely admitting vehicles equipped with spoilers demonstrates that the posted notice was not intended to prohibit such vehicles from using the wash, but rather to disclaim responsibility for damage if it occurred.
Regarding the mechanical control settings, Defendant's General Manager testified that the wash system includes a manual override button designed to raise the top mitter curtains over vehicles equipped with rear spoilers and that, from his review of the video from the day of the incident, it appeared the attendant pressed the override button. However, he had not spoken directly to the attendant who was operating the control panel at the time of Plaintiff's wash.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Liability
The issue before the Court is whether Defendant's posted disclaimer signs bar recovery for damage caused by Defendant's wash equipment.
Although the Court need not determine whether Defendant's facility falls squarely within the scope of General Obligations Law § 5-325(1), the statute reflects a public-policy principle consistent with the reasoning of Courtney v Vescio, 131 Misc 2d 381 (Oswego City Ct 1986), where the court rejected a car wash operator's reliance upon disclaimer signs after wash equipment damaged a customer's vehicle.
In Courtney, the plaintiff sought damages after an automatic car wash severed the outside mirror from his vehicle. The defendant relied upon a sign stating that it was not responsible for damage to vehicles and that patrons entered at their own risk. The court rejected that defense, reasoning that although businesses may, in certain circumstances, disclaim responsibility for losses caused by third parties, they may not avoid liability for damage caused by their own conduct, equipment, or operations.
As in Courtney, Plaintiff testified credibly that the spoiler was securely attached before entering the wash and detached during the wash cycle. Defendant substantially concedes that the damage occurred while Plaintiff's vehicle was passing through Defendant's automated equipment. Additionally, Plaintiff's contemporaneous incident report memorializes a statement attributed to a crew member that the operator may have failed to select the appropriate setting for a vehicle equipped with a spoiler. Defendant acknowledged during closing argument that Plaintiff's spoiler must have caught on something during the wash cycle, and the Court finds no credible alternative explanation for the damage.
The Court finds that Plaintiff established, by a fair preponderance of the evidence, that his spoiler was torn off by Defendant's wash equipment. This finding is supported by Defendant's acknowledgment that the spoiler must have caught on something during the wash cycle, the existence of a manual override feature specifically designed to accommodate vehicles equipped with spoilers, and the absence of any credible alternative explanation for the damage.
Because the damage resulted from Defendant's own operations rather than the conduct of a third party, the posted disclaimer signs are ineffective to shield Defendant from liability. Accordingly, Defendant is liable for Plaintiff's damages.
Damages
Small claims courts are directed to do substantial justice between the parties according to the rules of substantive law (UJCA § 1804).
Repair Costs
Plaintiff established repair damages through the itemized repair estimate from Knappy's Auto Body in the amount of $2,006.01.
Loss of Use
New York law permits recovery for loss of use during the period reasonably necessary to complete repairs, regardless of whether the vehicle was used for business or personal purposes.
The ordinary measure of such damages is the cost of securing substitute transportation during the reasonable repair period.
Recovery for loss of use may not rest upon speculation and must be supported by competent proof establishing both the rental value of a substitute vehicle and the repair period. See Roundtree v Singh, 143 AD2d 995 (2d Dept 1988).
Although Roundtree involved the failure of a pro se litigant to present sufficient proof of loss-of-use damages, the Appellate Division emphasized that an award may not rest upon speculation. Small claims courts, however, operate under informal and simplified procedures and possess broader discretion when evaluating competent proof.
Here, Plaintiff satisfied that burden by presenting an itemized repair estimate identifying a five-day repair period (Plaintiff's Exhibit 3) together with a contemporaneous Enterprise rental estimate (Plaintiff's Exhibit 4) reflecting actual market rental rates. These exhibits provide a competent evidentiary basis for determining loss-of-use damages.
At trial, Plaintiff introduced evidence showing projected rental costs of $947.94 during the anticipated repair period. When combined with repair damages, that figure exceeds the amount demanded in the Statement of Claim.
The Court recognizes that, in appropriate circumstances, a small claims award may exceed the amount demanded where no prejudice results. See Mosny v Sabater, 83 Misc 3d 131(A), 2024 NY Slip Op 51158(U) (App Term, 2d Dept, 9th & 10th Jud Dists 2024).
The Court finds Mosny distinguishable. There, damages continued to accrue after commencement of the action. By contrast, this case involves a discrete incident of property damage, and Plaintiff's loss-of-use damages were capable of estimation when the action was filed.
Although the evidence establishes loss-of-use damages in an amount exceeding the demand stated in the Statement of Claim, Plaintiff expressly sought recovery of $2,296.01. The Court therefore declines to award damages beyond that amount. After deducting the repair cost of $2,006.01, the remaining recoverable amount is $290.00, which the Court awards for loss of use.
ORDER
Accordingly, upon the foregoing findings of fact and conclusions of law, it is hereby
ORDERED that judgment is awarded in favor of Plaintiff Daniel Erickson and against Defendant Valet Auto Wash in the principal sum of $2,296.01 ($2,006.01 for vehicle repairs and $290.00 for loss-of-use damages), together with costs of $15.00, for a total judgment of $2,311.01 in this action; and it is further
ORDERED that entry of judgment is stayed until December 9, 2026, to permit Defendant to satisfy this award without entry of judgment; and it is further
ORDERED that, if payment is not made by December 9, 2026, judgment may be entered upon Plaintiff's written request accompanied by a statement that (1) no appeal has been taken and (2) payment has not been made as directed herein.
This constitutes the Decision and Order of the Court.
Richard J. Brink, J.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: Docket No. 26040072
Decided: November 09, 2026
Court: Justice Court, New York,
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)