Marie Wilson v. Alexandra Velez et al. (2011)

MEMORANDUM OF DECISION RE OBJECTION TO PRODUCTION # 244 AND OBJECTION TO PRODUCTION # 245, REPLY # 242.01

This matter comes to this court as Objections to Products of Documents.   The court heard oral argument, reviewed the pleadings.   The parties have limited their objections in # 244 to # s 5, 12, 14,15 and 23.

As to objection # 244, the court rules as follows:

1. As to # 5, the objection is sustained as to the years 2002, 2003.   The other years are to be produced.   Documents claimed to be attorney/client privilege need not be produced.

2. As to # 12, the objection is overruled except as to documents that are attorney/client privilege.   The objection is overruled as to payments made from 2004 forward, except as to attorney/client privileged materials.

3. As to # 15, the objection is overruled except for documents that reflect attorney/client privilege.   The objection is overruled except as to the attorney/client privileged materials.

Objections have been limited in # 245 to # s 13, 14 and 15.

As to Objection # 245, the court rules as follows:

1. As to Paragraph # 13, the objection is sustained.

2. As to Paragraph # 14, the objection is sustained

3. As to Paragraph # 15, the objection is overruled except as to attorney/client privileged materials and work product.

SO ORDERED.

EDWARD R. KARAZIN, JR.

Karazin, Edward R., J.T.R.