Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
AARON THOMAS, Appellant, v. THE STATE OF NEVADA, Respondent.
ORDER OF AFFIRMANCE
Aaron Thomas appeals from a district court order denying a postconviction petition for a writ of habeas corpus filed on October 20, 2023, and a supplemental petition filed on April 22, 2024. Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; Hon. Jacqueline M. Bluth, Judge.
At a party held on New Year's Eve, the victim was shot during an altercation with a rival gang member. Thomas was convicted, pursuant to a jury verdict, of second-degree murder with the use of a deadly weapon and two counts of discharging a firearm from or within a structure or vehicle. Thomas filed a direct appeal, and this court reversed Thomas's convictions for the two counts of discharging a firearm. See Thomas v. State, No. 83985-COA, 2023 WL 2033458 (Nev. Ct. App. Feb. 15, 2023) (Order Affirming in Part, Reversing in Part, and Remanding). Thereafter, Thomas filed the instant postconviction habeas petition and supplement. The district court denied the instant petition after holding a limited evidentiary hearing, and this appeal followed.
Thomas argues the district court erred by denying his claims that trial counsel was ineffective. To demonstrate ineffective assistance of trial counsel, a petitioner must show counsel's performance was deficient in that it fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and prejudice resulted in that there was a reasonable probability of a different outcome absent counsel's errors. Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668, 687-88 (1984); Warden v. Lyons, 100 Nev. 430, 432-33, 683 P.2d 504, 505 (1984) (adopting the test in Strickland). Both components of the inquiry must be shown, Strickland, 466 U.S. at 687, and the petitioner must demonstrate the underlying facts by a preponderance of the evidence, Means v. State, 120 Nev. 1001, 1012, 103 P.3d 25, 33 (2004). We give deference to the district court's factual findings if supported by substantial evidence and not clearly erroneous but review the court's application of the law to those facts de novo. Lader v. Warden, 121 Nev. 682, 686, 120 P.3d 1164, 1166 (2005). To warrant an evidentiary hearing, a petitioner must raise claims supported by specific factual allegations that are not belied by the record and, if true, would entitle the petitioner to relief. Hargrove v. State, 100 Nev. 498, 502-03, 686 P.2d 222, 225 (1984).
First, Thomas argued trial counsel was ineffective for failing to impeach a witness, Alexis Edmond, with the oral statement she gave to law enforcement. Edmond was at the party when the shooting occurred and told police she saw the shooter. A police report recounted her description of the shooter as a Black male wearing blue jeans and a black shirt, with a face tattoo below his eye that was either a dollar sign or a crown and with shoulder-length dreads. A different police report stated that Edmond said the hair was ear-length dreads. This description of the shooter was at odds with the description of the shooter given by the victim's sister, Sidney Jones, and matched the description of two other partygoers.
At trial, Edmond was uncooperative and attempted to avoid having to testify. She was ultimately located, and counsel informed the district court at trial, outside the presence of the jury, that Edmond's father threatened trial counsel to keep her from testifying. Trial counsel called her to the stand at trial, but she was very uncooperative and refused to answer many questions or claimed not to remember. Trial counsel never asked her about the description she gave to the police, nor did counsel call the law enforcement officers to whom she gave her statement, in order to impeach her.
Even assuming trial counsel's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, the district court found that Thomas failed to demonstrate he was prejudiced by trial counsel's performance. The record supports the decision of the district court. The State presented substantial evidence of Thomas's guilt, including: (1) Jones's identification of Thomas as the shooter and her testimony that she saw flashes of light emanating from Thomas at the time of the shooting; (2) video evidence that Thomas was at the party; (3) the coroner's testimony that the shots were from more than a foot away; and (4) evidence that the car Thomas was driving in when he was arrested contained ammunition matching cartridges found at the party. Given this evidence, we conclude that, even had trial counsel impeached Edmond, Thomas failed to demonstrate a reasonable probability of a different outcome at trial. Accordingly, we conclude the district court did not err by denying this claim.
Second, Thomas argued trial counsel was ineffective for failing to request a defense-of-others jury instruction. At trial, counsel suggested a defense-of-others jury instruction, and the trial court requested that trial counsel provide it with authorities and evidence to support the instruction. Trial counsel did not provide this information, and the instruction was not given. When asked at the evidentiary hearing about why he did not seek the instruction, trial counsel stated he looked into the instruction and determined the defense “really wasn't” there. We conclude that this was a strategic decision by trial counsel to not ask for a defense-of-others instruction, and strategic decisions are virtually unchallengeable. See Lara v. State, 120 Nev. 177, 180, 87 P.3d 528, 530 (2004) (holding that counsel's strategic decisions are “virtually unchallengeable absent extraordinary circumstances” (quotation marks omitted)). Further, although Thomas alleged counsel should have presented evidence at trial to support a defense-of-others instruction, he failed to allege or identify what evidence would have supported such an instruction, and this court on direct appeal determined that no credible evidence supported a defense-of-others jury instruction. See Thomas, No. 83985-COA, 2023 WL 2033458, at *6. Thus, we conclude Thomas failed to demonstrate that trial counsel's performance was deficient or a reasonable probability of a different outcome at trial had trial counsel requested the instruction. Accordingly, we conclude the district court did not err by denying this claim.
Third, Thomas argued that trial counsel was ineffective for failing to object to the trial court's reply to a jury question that was given without consulting the parties. He also contended trial counsel should have objected to the jury's verdict based on the trial court's communication with the jury. During deliberations, the jury requested a playback of Jones’ trial testimony. Without consulting either the defense or the State, the trial court sent a note telling the jury that the trial court was handling jury selection in a different case, that the jury should continue deliberations, and that the trial court would get back to the jury's request when it could. The underlying claim, that the trial court erred by answering the jury's question without first consulting with the defense, was raised on direct appeal. Id. This court concluded it was error for the district court to have answered the jury's question without first consulting the parties. Id. However, this court also concluded that: (1) the jurors had already asked for a playback of a detective's testimony, so they knew they could watch Jones’ testimony once the court was free; (2) the trial court's message would not have been materially different had the parties been notified of the note; and (3) Thomas did not establish that any changes to the message would have affected the verdict in light of the substantial evidence of guilt. Id. at *7. Given these determinations, we conclude, even assuming counsel's performance was deficient, Thomas failed to demonstrate a reasonable probability of a different outcome at trial had trial counsel objected to the district court's reply or the verdict. See Hall v. State, 91 Nev. 314, 315, 535 P.2d 797, 798 (1975) (“The law of a first appeal is the law of the case on all subsequent appeals in which the facts are substantially the same.” (quotation marks omitted)). Therefore, we conclude the district court did not err by denying this claim.
Finally, Thomas argued that the cumulative errors of trial counsel entitled him to relief. Even if multiple instances of deficient performance could be cumulated for purposes of demonstrating prejudice, see McConnell v. State, 125 Nev. 243, 259 & n.17, 212 P.3d 307, 318 & n.17 (2009), Thomas failed to demonstrate trial counsel's alleged errors, considered cumulatively, would have entitled him to relief, see Mulder v. State, 116 Nev. 1, 17, 992 P.2d 845, 854-55 (2000) (stating the relevant factors to consider in evaluating a claim of cumulative error). Therefore, we conclude the district court did not err by denying this claim.1
Having considered Thomas's claims and determined the district court did not err by denying his petition, we
ORDER the judgment of the district court AFFIRMED.2
Bulla, C.J.
Gibbons, J.
Westbrook, J.
FOOTNOTES
1. Given our disposition, we conclude the district court did not err by failing to hold a full evidentiary hearing on each of Thomas's claims.
2. To the extent the State argues the district court should have dismissed Thomas's petition because it failed to allege any specific claims, we conclude this claim was not raised below, and we decline to consider it in the first instance on appeal. See State v. Wade, 105 Nev. 206, 209 n.3, 772 P.2d 1291, 1293 n.3 (1989).
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: No. 90996-COA
Decided: November 05, 2026
Court: Court of Appeals of Nevada.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)