Learn About the Law
Get help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
ISAAC ASUSTA, Appellant, v. RONALD OLIVER, WARDEN, Respondent.
ORDER OF AFFIRMANCE
Isaac Asusta appeals from a district court order denying a postconviction petition for a writ of habeas corpus filed on April 14, 2025. Seventh Judicial District Court, White Pine County; Hon. Steve L. Dobrescu, Judge.
Asusta was convicted in 2008, pursuant to a guilty plea, of first-degree murder with the use of a deadly weapon and second-degree murder with the use of a deadly weapon. In his petition, Asusta contended, among other things, that trial-level counsel was ineffective for failing to inform him that the State had tested DNA obtained from the murder weapon and that the results excluded him as the source. The district court determined the postconviction petition was untimely and successive and denied the petition as procedurally barred.
On appeal, Asusta contends his petition was timely filed because (1) a corrected judgment of conviction was entered on April 29, 2024; and (2) the original judgment of conviction was not a valid, final judgment as it did not specify the victim who was to receive restitution. We reject these arguments. Regarding Asusta's first argument, “[u]nless there is good cause shown for delay, a petition that challenges the validity of a judgment of conviction or sentence must be filed ․ within 1 year after the appellate court of competent jurisdiction ․ issues its remittitur.” NRS 34.726(1). This time limit “[does] not automatically restart for [a petitioner's] post-conviction claims simply because the district court entered [an] amended judgment of conviction.”1 Sullivan v. State, 120 Nev. 537, 541, 96 P.3d 761, 764 (2004). Therefore, entry of the April 29, 2024, corrected judgment of conviction did not restart the time for filing a postconviction habeas petition.
As to Asusta's second argument, Asusta is estopped from challenging the finality of the original judgment of conviction because he previously litigated a direct appeal and a postconviction habeas petition in relation to that judgment. See Asusta v. State, No. 53053, 2011 WL 2139915 (Nev. May 26, 2011) (Order of Affirmance); Asusta v. Cox, No. 64209, 2014 WL 7091099 (Nev. Dec. 11, 2014) (Order of Affirmance); see also Witter v. State, 135 Nev. 412, 415, 452 P.3d 406, 409 (2019) (holding a defendant may not “treat a judgment of conviction with an indeterminate restitution provision as final by litigating a direct appeal and postconviction habeas petitions only to later change course and argue that the judgment was never final”). Therefore, the one-year statutory time limit for filing a postconviction habeas petition began to run from the supreme court's issuance of remittitur on direct appeal, not from the entry of the corrected judgment of conviction.
Asusta filed his postconviction habeas petition more than 13 years after issuance of the remittitur on direct appeal on June 20, 2011. See Asusta, No. 53053, 2011 WL 2139915. Thus, Asusta's petition was untimely filed. See NRS 34.726(1). Asusta's petition was procedurally barred absent a demonstration of good cause—cause for the delay and undue prejudice—see id., or a showing that he is actually innocent such that a fundamental miscarriage of justice would result were his claims not decided on the merits, see Berry v. State, 131 Nev. 957, 966, 363 P.3d 1148, 1154 (2015).
In his petition, Asusta claimed he discovered the forensic report with the DNA results in September 2022, and he learned in August 2024 that trial-level counsel had possession of this evidence since early 2007. Assuming this claim implicated good cause, we conclude Asusta is not entitled to relief. “In order to demonstrate good cause, a petitioner must show that an impediment external to the defense prevented him or her from complying with the state procedural default rules.” Hathaway v. State, 119 Nev. 248, 252, 71 P.3d 503, 506 (2003). “An impediment external to the defense may be demonstrated by a showing that the factual or legal basis for a claim was not reasonably available to counsel, or that some interference by officials, made compliance impracticable.” Id. (internal quotation marks omitted). Asusta did not allege specific facts indicating the factual basis for his claim was not reasonably available to him or that official interference prevented him from timely filing his postconviction petition.2 Therefore, Asusta failed to demonstrate good cause for the delay.
Asusta also contends the district court failed to consider his gateway claim of actual innocence. Asusta did not raise a gateway claim of actual innocence in his petition;3 rather, the record indicates Asusta was attempting to raise a freestanding claim of actual innocence pursuant to NRS 34.900-.990 in his postconviction habeas petition. Neither this court nor the supreme court has determined “whether and, if so, when a free-standing actual innocence claim exists” within the scope of a postconviction habeas petition, Berry, 131 Nev. at 967 n.3, 363 P.3d at 1154 n.3, and the legislature filled this gap in Nevada law by creating a new postconviction remedy: a petition to establish factual innocence, see Sanchez v. State, 140 Nev., Adv. Op. 78, 561 P.3d 35, 38 (2024). Thus, we conclude the district court did not err in not considering Asusta's freestanding claim of actual innocence in a postconviction habeas petition. Such a claim would need to be raised in a separate petition to establish factual innocence pursuant to NRS 34.900-.990.4
In light of the foregoing, we conclude the district court did not err in denying Asusta's postconviction petition as procedurally barred without holding an evidentiary hearing. Accordingly, we
ORDER the judgment of the district court AFFIRMED. 5
Bulla, C.J.
Gibbons, J.
Westbrook, J.
FOOTNOTES
1. We recognize that “the entry of an amended judgment may in and of itself provide the good cause required by the statute to present appropriate post-conviction claims relating to the amendment at issue.” Sullivan v. State, 120 Nev. 537, 541, 96 P.3d 761, 764 (2004). However, Asusta's claims did not relate to any corrections made to the judgment of conviction. To the extent Asusta separately claimed the district court erred by listing a deceased victim in the corrected judgment of conviction, such a claim did not challenge the validity of the guilty plea or allege counsel was ineffective and was thus outside the scope of a postconviction habeas petition stemming from a guilty plea. See NRS 34.810(1)(a).
2. To the extent Asusta claimed trial-level counsel never sent him the case file, any such purported failure does not constitute good cause. See Hood v. State, 111 Nev. 335, 338, 890 P.2d 797, 798 (1995).
3. Although Asusta filed a motion for leave to file a reply brief and raised a gateway claim of actual innocence in the attached reply, there is no indication in the record that the district court granted this motion, and we conclude the district court did not abuse its discretion by declining to consider issues raised for the first time in the reply. See NRS 34.750(5); Barnhart v. State, 122 Nev. 301, 303, 130 P.3d 650, 651 (2006) (“Generally, the only issues that should be considered by the district court ․ on a post-conviction habeas petition are those which have been pleaded in the petition or a supplemental petition and those to which the State has had an opportunity to respond.”).
4. The district court did not construe Asusta's petition as a petition to establish factual innocence, and Asusta does not contend on appeal that the district court erred in declining to so construe his petition. Therefore, any factual innocence claim must be brought in a separate petition.
5. To the extent Asusta raises claims not specifically addressed herein, we have considered the same and conclude that they do not present a basis for relief or need not be reached given our disposition.
Thank you for your feedback!
As the largest network of trusted legal brands, we help firms build authority across the platforms consumers and AI systems rely on most. Our network helps attorneys strengthen visibility, credibility, and preference where legal decisions begin.
Docket No: No. 92130-COA
Decided: October 29, 2026
Court: Court of Appeals of Nevada.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)
Harness the power of our directory with your own profile. Select the button below to sign up.
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleGet help with your legal needs
FindLaw’s Learn About the Law features thousands of informational articles to help you understand your options. And if you’re ready to hire an attorney, find one in your area who can help.
Search our directory by legal issue
Enter information in one or both fields (Required)